This study examines the effects of teachable agents’ expressed self-efficacy on students. A total of 166 students, 10- to 11-years-old, used a teachable agent-based math game focusing on the base-ten number system. By means of data logging and questionnaires, the study compared the effects of high vs. low agent self-efficacy on the students’ in-game performance, their own math self-efficacy, and their attitude towards their agent. The study further explored the effects of matching vs. mismatching between student and agent with respect to self-efficacy. Overall, students who interacted with an agent with low self-efficacy performed better than students interacting with an agent with high self-efficacy. This was especially apparent for students who had reported low self-efficacy themselves, who performed on par with students with high self-efficacy when interacting with a digital tutee with low self-efficacy. Furthermore, students with low self-efficacy significantly increased their self-efficacy in the matched condition, i.e. when instructing a teachable agent with low self-efficacy. They also increased their self-efficacy when instructing a teachable agent with high self-efficacy, but to a smaller extent and not significantly. For students with high self-efficacy, a potential corresponding effect on a self-efficacy change due to matching may be hidden behind a ceiling effect. As a preliminary conclusion, on the basis of the results of this study, we propose that teachable agents should preferably be designed to have low self-efficacy.
Previous research shows that critical constructive feedback, that scaffolds students to improve on tasks, often remains untapped. The paper’s aim is to illuminate at what stages students provided w...
How should a pedagogical agent in educational software be designed to support student learning? This question is complex seeing as there are many types of pedagogical agents and design features, and the effect on different student groups can vary. In this paper we explore the effects of designing a pedagogical agent’s self-efficacy in order to see what effects this has on students´ interaction with it. We have analyzed chat logs from an educational math game incorporating an agent, which acts as a digital tutee. The tutee expresses high or low self-efficacy through feedback given in the chat. This has been performed in relation to the students own self-efficacy. Our previous results indicated that it is more beneficial to design a digital tutee with low self-efficacy than one with high self-efficacy. In this paper, these results are further explored and explained in terms of an increase in the protégé effect and a reverse role modelling effect, whereby the students encourage digital tutees with low self-efficacy. However, there are indications of potential drawbacks that should be further investigated. Some students expressed frustration with the digital tutee with low self-efficacy. A future direction could be to look at more adaptive agents that change their self-efficacy over time as they learn.
1 January 2019 in PRESENCE: Virtual and Augmented Reality
Virtual Reality has long been proposed to combine the reliability of controlled laboratory settings with the ecological validity of real life. While the technological development steadily pushes towards even more realistic renderings of the real world – the elusiveness of social and emotional elements gradually becomes more evident. This is not the least true for behavioral studies in rich socio-cultural contexts. This paper examines the outcomes of a study on distractions, taking place in a socially rich context – the classroom. The study made use of a Virtual Reality environment simulating a junior high school lesson, where the distraction condition consisted of peers watching nonrelevant content on their laptops. In the control condition these laptops were closed. No significant distraction effects were found, neither on learning nor behavior. Given the strong support in the literature for such effects, the study design, including technical aspects, is scrutinized and discussed. We specifically highlight the difficulty of simulating a social relationship between the participant and agents in VR, which in this case makes the distraction stimulus significantly weaker. It is argued that the distraction effect of nearby peers’ laptop-use relies (partly) on shared attention with social agents with an established social relation and common interests.
10 September 2024 in PRESENCE: Virtual and Augmented Reality
To study engagement and learning, we developed an asymmetric collaborative version of an existing VR-experience about environmental sustainability, enabling student teams of three, with only one wearing a headset at any time, to collaborate in three different virtual reality subgames. We compared this collaborative version to a non-collaborative version in a between-subjects experimental study (n = 20), finding that student teams using the collaborative version interacted to a larger extent while performing the subgames. The students in these teams self-reported a higher level of engagement, and observations suggested that interactions extended beyond necessary instructions. We did not find any significant differences when it comes to learning measured by scores on pre- and post-knowledge tests, but quantitative analysis of responses indicates that the VR-experience affected students overall and a qualitative analysis of an open question suggested a particular effect on the collaborative teams. Logged performance data indicated that collaborative teams managed to solve the tasks involved in the subgames at least as efficiently as the teams using the non-collaborative version.
12 April 2025 in International Journal of Social Robotics
At the current time, social robots are poised to enter human society in an unprecedented way. However, robots currently are not adept at communicating emotional states, even if humans to a large extent rely on such communication to regulate interaction. Although facial expressions are difficult for robots to make use of, colored lights are readily available. Currently though, there is no consensus on how to best represent emotions using colors in robots. In this paper, we study how humans perceive the humanoid robot, Epi, when displaying different eye colors, eye color intensity, pupil sizes, head postures in combination with eye directions. Two online experiments were conducted where subjects were presented with pictures of the robot and asked how they perceived it in relation to six different emotions (anger, fear, surprise, disgust, sadness and enjoyment). In experiment 1, we looked at how eye color and light intensity correlates to the different emotions. In experiment 2, we focus on how pupil size, head posture and eye direction affect how the robot is perceived. Results indicate that red is strongly associated with anger, and that people rate Epi as expressing disgust and sadness more when light intensity dims.