Objectives Considerable resources are invested in health system innovation and strengthening. This calls for efforts to ensure the sustainability of such interventions. We conducted a scoping review to identify factors influencing the sustainability of externally funded health system strengthening interventions targeting primary healthcare, the sustainability outcomes observed in such interventions and the methods used to measure sustainability. Design Scoping review following the Joanna Briggs Institute scoping review guidelines. Data sources Web of Science, Ovid Medline and Embase databases were searched through 11 March 2024. Eligibility criteria Studies in English with no restriction on study type or country. Externally funded health system strengthening interventions targeting primary health systems and measuring sustainability. Data extraction and synthesis One reviewer screened all titles and abstracts, and two independent pairs of reviewers read full texts. Relevant study data were extracted from the articles and descriptively analysed. Results From the 6439 titles retrieved, eight eligible studies were identified and included in the final analysis. Only four studies presented a sustainability definition. Institutionalisation and continued programme activities were described four times as sustainability outcomes, followed by capacity building twice and continued health impact and benefits once. Sustainability was assessed in five studies after intervention completion and in three studies during the implementation period. The sustainability factors were mostly related to processes (n=19), inner context (n=18), intervention characteristics (n=12) and outer context (n=11), with stakeholder engagement and partnership (n=6) as well as funding (n=3) being the most reported factors. Conclusion This review highlights the limited documentation on the sustainability of externally funded health system strengthening interventions. Sustainability was mainly assessed retrospectively. Influencing factors spanned over all categories of the integrated sustainability framework, with stakeholder engagement and funding playing key roles. Planning for sustainability assessments with clear definitions, methods and timeframes can enhance evidence on achieving lasting impacts of health system strengthening interventions. Registration Open Science Framework, https://osf.io/hazqp/?view_only=d53472afbba447e790049d81ca60aa29.
Introduction: Although well-performing workforce is essential to equitable and efficient health service delivery, few countries have systematically addressed performance improvements. How health workers use their work time and what tasks they accomplish is here an important starting point. Therefore, a time motion study was conducted to assess the work time allocation patterns of primary health care doctors and nurses in two regions of Albania.Methods: We used observation tool to record the time allocation along eight predefined main categories of activities. Conditional to presence at work, 48 health workers were continuously observed in early 2020 before start of the Covid-19 pandemic over five consecutive working days.Results: The observed health workers spent 40.7% of their overall working time unproductively (36.8% on waiting for patients and 3.9% on breaks), 25.3% on service provision to users, 18.7% on administrative activities, 12.7% on outreach activities, 1.6% on continuous medical education and 1% on meetings. The study found variations in work time allocation patterns across cadres, with nurses spending more time unproductively, on administrative activities and on outreach and less on all other activities than doctors. Further, the work time allocation patterns were similar between urban and rural settings, except for nurses in rural settings spending less time than those in urban settings on administrative work.Conclusion: This study found that primary health care workers in Albania devote a substantial amount of work time to unproductive, service provision to users and administrative activities. Consequently, there is possibility for productivity, respectively efficiency gains in how health workers use their time.
Introduction: Despite efforts to strengthen primary health care, Moldova faces continues challenges related to health personnel shortages and distribution disparities, resulting in high workloads. To better understand the current situation, we sought to assess the work-time allocation of family doctors and medical assistants in primary health care centers in Moldova. Methods: An observational, cross-sectional study was conducted to investigate health personnel’s time allocated to activity categories, the number and duration of consultations for different health conditions, and the reasons for patient’s visits in nine primary health centers in Moldova. 24 family doctors and 24 medical assistants were observed for five consecutive working days, covering in total 233 workdays and 4,916 consultations. Results: Family doctors used 49.2% of their time on direct patient care, 20.4% on administrative tasks and 9.8% on outreach activities. Medical assistants spent 33.6% on administration tasks, 30.9% on direct patient care and 13.6% on outreach activities. Of their direct patient care time, family doctors and medical assistants used 49.8% and 51.7%, respectively, on non-communicable disease consultations. The median duration of doctors’ consultations was 8.55 minutes, whereas medical assistants’ consultations lasted 5.65 minutes. Hypertensive disease and pediatric visits were the most frequent and time-consuming consultations. Health personnel contracted for 1.5 full-time equivalents worked over 10 hours per week shorter than required by their working contracts. Conclusions: Family doctors used nearly half of their work time on direct patient care, while medical assistants spent less than one third, with administrative tasks taking up most of medical assistants’ time. Consultation durations were short for both cadres, especially among medical assistants, reflecting the high workload in primary health care in Moldova. Additionally, health personnel contracted for 1.5 full-time equivalents worked consistently fewer hours than required by their contracts, indicating this system does not improve patient access or resolve personnel shortages.