A new suite of 173 clinopyroxene grains from heavy-mineral concentrates of the diamondiferous Novinka kimberlite (Upper Muna field, Yakutia) has been analyzed for major and minor elements with an electron microprobe to perform a thermobarometric study and model the thermal structure of the Archean Upper Muna lithospheric mantle. Scrupulous evaluation of propagation of analytical uncertainties on pressure estimates revealed that (1) the single-clinopyroxene geobarometer can be very sensitive to analytical uncertainties for particular clinopyroxene compositions, and that (2) most clinopyroxenes from Novinka have compositions that are sensitive to analytical uncertainties, notwithstanding their apparent compositional suitability for single-clinopyroxene thermobarometry based on previously proposed application limits. A test on various mantle clinopyroxenes containing different proportions of the sensitive elements Cr, Na, and Al allowed us to identify clinopyroxene compositions that produce unacceptably high propagated errors and to define appropriate analytical conditions (i.e., higher beam currents and longer counting times for specific elements) that allow precise P-T estimates to be obtained for sensitive compositions. Based on the results of our analytical test, and taking into account the intrinsic limitations of the single-clinopyroxene thermobarometer, we have designed a new protocol for optimum thermobarometry, which uses partly revised compositional filters. The new protocol permits precise computation of the conductive paleogeotherm at Novinka with the single-clinopyroxene thermobarometer of Nimis and Taylor (2000). Thermal modeling of the resulting P-T estimates indicates a ~34 mW/m2 surface heat flow, a thermal lithosphere thickness of ~225 km, and an over 100 km thick “diamond window” beneath Novinka in the middle Paleozoic (344–361 Ma). We estimate that appropriate analytical conditions may extend the applicability of single-clinopyroxene thermobarometry to over 90% of clinopyroxene-bearing garnet peridotites and pyroxenites and to ~70% of chromian-diopside inclusions in diamonds. In all cases, application to clinopyroxenes with Cr/(Cr+Al)mol < 0.1 is not recommended. We confirm the tendency of the single-clinopyroxene barometer to progressively underestimate pressure at P > 4.5 GPa.
Garnet xenocrysts (n = 386) and associated mineral inclusions and intergrowths from the diamond-free Zagadochnaya kimberlite (Daldyn field, Yakutia) were studied to provide new insights into mantle processes beneath the central Siberian Craton. Electron microprobe analyses indicate that the great majority of the garnets follow the ‘lherzolitic’ trend in the CaO vs Cr2O3 diagram (Cr2O3 = 0·5–9·3 wt %, CaO = 3·2–10·3 wt %), with <10% falling in the wehrlitic field and <3% falling in a transitional region between the lherzolitic and harzburgitic fields. A representative subset of the garnets (n = 28) was further analysed for trace elements by laser ablation inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry. Based on both major and trace element data, three main compositional groups are distinguished: Group A garnets (Cr2O3 = 1·3–5·2 wt %) may contain inclusions of chromian diopside and are characterized by progressively increasing, chondrite (CI)-normalized rare earth element (REE) abundances from La to Lu; Group B garnets (Cr2O3 = 5·4–8·6 wt %) are less depleted in light REE (LREE) and show nearly flat patterns from Sm to Lu; Group C garnets (Cr2O3 = 7·3–8·4 wt %) are characterized by humped to strongly sinusoidal REE patterns, with Yb between 0·5 and 3·0 × CI. Numerical simulations of melt–rock interactions show that the wide spectrum of garnet REE compositions can be produced by a unique episode of melt injection and percolation through a refractory mantle column, whereby the melt progressively changes its composition owing to chromatographic ion exchange, fractional crystallization, and assimilation of peridotitic minerals, under decreasing melt/rock ratios. The calculated composition of the metasomatizing melt has a kimberlitic affinity, but is distinct from the composition of the host Zagadochnaya kimberlite. Most of the Group B and C garnets show replacement by a secondary mineral assemblage of (Ca, Cr)-poor garnet, chromian diopside, and chromite (± phlogopite ± amphibole). The (Ca, Cr)-poor garnets are enriched in almost all incompatible trace elements, and often show humped CI-normalized REE patterns. The textures and mineralogy of these secondary mineral assemblages, the calculated compositions of the melts in equilibrium with the secondary garnets and clinopyroxenes, and Ca concentration profiles across garnet zoning indicate deep-seated (100–130 km) pervasive reaction with melts related to the host kimberlite. The lack of mantle materials from depths greater than 130 km, the absence of diamond, the abundance of secondary mineral assemblages, and the high-Mg composition of the kimberlite are consistent with a relatively slow ascent of the melts to intermediate and shallow mantle depths (<130 km) and extensive melt–mantle interactions before eruption.
1 October 2016 in Earth and Planetary Science Letters