Ionized by solar radiation, the ionosphere causes a phase rotation or time delay to trans-ionospheric radio waves. Reconstruction of ionospheric electron density profiles with global navigation satellite system (GNSS) observations has become an indispensable technique for various purposes ranging from space physics studies to radio applications. This paper conducts a comprehensive review on the development of voxel-based computerized ionospheric tomography (CIT) in the last 30 years. A brief introduction is given in chronological order starting from the first report of CIT with simulation to the newly proposed voxel-based algorithms for ionospheric event analysis. The statement of the tomographic geometry and voxel models are outlined with the ill-posed and ill-conditioned nature of CIT addressed. With the additional information from other instrumental observations or initial models supplemented to make the coefficient matrix less ill-conditioned, equation constructions are categorized into constraints, virtual data assimilation and multi-source observation fusion. Then, the paper classifies and assesses the voxel-based CIT algorithms of the algebraic method, statistical approach and artificial neural networks for equation solving or electron density estimation. The advantages and limitations of the algorithms are also pointed out. Moreover, the paper illustrates the representative height profiles and two-dimensional images of ionospheric electron densities from CIT. Ionospheric disturbances studied with CIT are presented. It also demonstrates how the CIT benefits ionospheric correction and ionospheric monitoring. Finally, some suggestions are provided for further research about voxel-based CIT.
In computerized ionospheric tomography (CIT) with ground-based GNSS, the voxels without satellite-receiver ray traversing cannot be reconstructed directly. We present a CIT algorithm based on virtual reference stations (VRSs), called VRS–CIT, to decrease the number of unilluminated voxels and improve the precision of the estimated ionospheric electron density (IED). The VRSs are set at the nodes of grids with a 0.5° × 0.5° resolution in longitude and latitude. We generate the virtual observations with the observations from nearby six or three stations selected according to azimuths and distances. The generation utilizes multi-quadric surface fitting with six stations and triangular linear interpolation with three stations. With the virtual observations added, the IED distribution is reconstructed by the multiplicative algebraic reconstruction technique with the initial values obtained from IRI-2016. The performance of VRS–CIT is examined by using the data from 127 GNSS stations located in 24–46° N and 122–146° E to derive the IED every 30 min. The study focuses on April 29, 2014, with the adaptability of VRS–CIT analyzed by 12 days, evenly distributed around equinoxes and solstices of 2014. The accuracy of the virtual observation is about 1 TECU. Comparing to that derived from CIT with only real observations, the unsolvability of VRS–CIT declined by 4–12% for the whole region, and for the main area, the improvement can be up to 70%. Taking two IED profiles from radio occultation as reference measurements, the mean absolute error (MAE) of IED by VRS–CIT decreases by 6.88% and 8.43%, respectively. Comparing with slant total electron content (STEC) extracted from five additional GNSS stations, the MAE and the root mean square error of the estimated STEC can be reduced up to 17.24% and 33.81%, respectively.
Ground- and space-based Global Navigation Satellite System (GNSS) receivers can provide three-dimensional (3D) information about the occurrence of equatorial plasma bubbles (EPBs). For this study, we selected March 2014 data (during solar maximum of cycle 24) for the analysis. The timing and the latitudinal dependence of the EPBs occurrence rate are derived by means of the rate of the total electron content (TEC) index (ROTI) data from GNSS receivers in China, whereas vertical profiles of the scintillation index S4 are provided by COSMIC (Constellation Observing System for Meteorology, Ionosphere and Climate). The GNSS receivers of the low Earth orbit satellites give information about the occurrence of amplitude scintillations in limb sounding geometry where the focus is on magnetic latitudes from 20° S to 20° N. The occurrence rates of the observed EPB-induced scintillations are generally smaller than those of the EPB-induced ROTI variations. The timing and the latitude dependence of the EPBs occurrence rate agree between the ground-based and spaceborne GNSS data. We find that EPBs occur at 19:00 LT and they are mainly situated above the F2 peak layer which descended from 450 km at 20:00 LT to 300 km at 24:00 LT in the equatorial ionosphere. At the same time, the spaceborne GNSS data also show, for the first time, a high occurrence rate of post-sunset scintillations at 100 km altitude, indicating the coexistence of equatorial sporadic E with EPBs.
Global ionospheric total electron content (TEC) is generally derived with ground-based Global Navigation Satellite System (GNSS) observations based on mathematical models in a solar-geomagnetic reference frame. However, ground-based observations are not well-distributed. There is a lack of observations over sparsely populated areas and vast oceans, where the accuracy of TEC derivation is reduced. Additionally, the modified dip (modip) latitude is more suitable than geomagnetic latitude for the ionosphere. This paper investigates the improvement of global TEC with multi-source data and modip latitude, and a simulation with International Reference Ionosphere (IRI) model is developed. Compared with using ground-based observations in geomagnetic latitude, the mean improvement was about after the addition of space-based observations and the adoption of modip latitude. Nevertheless, the data from JASON-2 satellite altimetry and COSMIC occultation are sparsely-sampled, which makes the IRI TEC a reasonable estimation for the areas without observation. By using multi-source data from ground-based, satellite-based and IRI-produced observations, global TEC was derived in both geomagnetic and modip latitudes for 12 days of four seasons in 2014 under geomagnetic quiet conditions. The average root-mean-square error (RMSE) of the fitting was reduced by in modip latitude. The improvement was largest in March and smallest in June.