A spatiotemporal approach that simultaneously utilises both spatial and temporal relationships is gaining scientific interest in the field of traffic flow forecasting. Accurate identification of the spatiotemporal structure (dependencies amongst traffic flows in space and time) plays a critical role in modern traffic forecasting methodologies, and recent developments of data-driven feature selection and extraction methods allow the identification of complex relationships. This paper systematically reviews studies that apply feature selection and extraction methods for spatiotemporal traffic forecasting. The reviewed bibliographic database includes 211 publications and covers the period from early 1984 to March 2018. A synthesis of bibliographic sources clarifies the advantages and disadvantages of different feature selection and extraction methods for learning the spatiotemporal structure and discovers trends in their applications. We conclude that there is a clear need for development of comprehensive guidelines for selecting appropriate spatiotemporal feature selection and extraction methods for urban traffic forecasting.
Airport Benchmarking and Spatial Competition: A Critical Review During the last two decades the European airport industry is liberalised and turned to competitive market environment. This fact attracts an increasing scientific and practical interest to analysis of airport efficiency and its determinants, as well as different aspects of airport competition. This paper contains a critical review of existing researches in these two areas - airport efficiency and spatial competition among airports. We analysed modern approaches to airport benchmarking, their advantages and shortcomings, and systematised a wide range of related academic studies. We paid special attention to empirical researches of spatial competition as a factor affecting airport efficiency. Despite the fact of a well-developed theory of spatial competition and signs of its growing effects in the airport industry, we discovered a lack of studies devoted to the relationship between airport efficiency and spatial competition.
1 December 2021 in IEEE Transactions on Intelligent Transportation Systems
Spatiotemporal models that incorporate information about the relationships between traffic flows over space and time have recently become the mainstream of urban traffic forecasting. Many algorithms have been developed to learn the structure of spatiotemporal relationships - the travel time-based, cross-correlation, graphical lasso, mutual information, and random forest methods, among several others. In this paper, we address two issues of spatiotemporal relationship learning. First, we suggest the application of ensemble techniques (ranking- and voting-based) that combine the advantages of individual algorithms and allow more robust structures to be obtained for learning spatiotemporal relationships. Second, we propose strategies that enable discovery of their dynamics and provide extensive information on traffic flows for the responsive learning of spatiotemporal relationships. In addition to the widely used forecasting performance (estimated for the spatially regularised vector autoregression model, the spatiotemporal k-nearest neighbour algorithm, and the high-order graph convolutional artificial neural network), we compare the estimated spatiotemporal relationship structures using their complexity and stability metrics and demonstrate the importance of these characteristics. A multitude of numerical experiments using a large citywide traffic data set are conducted, and the results demonstrate the preferences of ensemble learning and the strengths of the proposed learning strategies.