Worldwide, academics and practitioners are developing ‘planning-oriented’ approaches to reduce the negative impacts of car traffic for more sustainable urban and transport development. One such example is the design of car-reduced neighborhoods, although these are controversial issues in the hegemonic ‘system’ of automobility. Despite the reduction of emissions and frequent recognition as ‘best practice examples’, ‘planning-critical’ research questions the underlying objectives and narratives of such sustainable developments. Our study contributes to this research perspective by improving the understanding of narratives that emerge along with car-reduced housing developments. For this purpose, we analyze two car-reduced neighborhoods in the City of Darmstadt (Germany) by conducting interviews with different actors involved in the planning and implementation processes. Our investigation reveals that the development of car-reduced neighborhoods (i) is consciously embedded in the context of sustainability, (ii) is characterized by power relations, (iii) follows normative indicators, and (iv) does not always correspond to lived realities. Altogether, the traced narratives of car-reduced neighborhoods are embedded in the overarching debate on sustainability, while at the same time revealing the dependence of society on the automobile. Thus, the hegemonic ‘system’ of automobility—although it is beginning to crack—continues to exist.
Während sich die Fernverkehrsangebote auf der Schiene über Jahrzehnte hinweg und im Laufe eines kontinuierlichen Infrastrukturausbaus entwickelten, muss sich die städtische Verkehrsplanung in kurzer Zeit auf die neuen Angebote des Fernbuslinienmarktes einstellen. Dabei sehen sich die Städte mit verschiedenen Herausforderungen konfrontiert: Sie müssen Verknüpfungspunkte in Form von Fernbus-terminals vorhalten und sie stehen vor der Aufgabe, die Fernbuslinienangebote in die regionalen Verkehrssysteme zu integrieren. Durch die dynamische Entwicklung des Fernbusmarktes nach seiner Liberalisierung, den schnellen Ausbau der Linienverbindungen und den unvorhergesehenen Anstieg der Fahrgastzahlen waren die lokalen Akteure bislang kaum in der Lage, fundiertes Erfahrungswissen im verkehrsplanerischen Umgang mit Fernbuslinienangeboten aufzubauen. Das Projekt „Integration von Fernbuslinienangeboten“ nimmt sich am Beispiel der Stadt Frankfurt am Main den Handlungsnotwendigkeiten der städtischen Verkehrsplanung an und formuliert auf Grundlage einer Fahrgastbefragung an zwei Standorten mögliche Optionen aus der Perspektive der Fahrgäste. Dabei stehen insbesondere die Anforderungen an und Handlungsoptionen für die städtebauliche und verkehrliche Integration der Fernbuslinienangebote in lokale Verkehrssysteme im Fokus.
As part of the social-ecological transformation of urban mobility, car-reduced neighbourhoods offer a promising approach for facilitating car-independent lifestyles. To foster sustainable transport, they implement ‘pull’ measures like subsidized shared mobility alongside ‘push’ measures such as parking space reduction and pricing to discourage car use and ownership. Because the effects of these car-reduced neighbourhoods on residents’ travel behaviour remain understudied, this paper evaluates their impact by examining car ownership levels and multimodal travel patterns. Using a case–control study, we compare residents of the car-reduced Lincoln neighbourhood in Darmstadt, Germany, with other recent movers within the same municipality (N = 952). To isolate the specific impact of residential location, the potential effects of residential self-selection and relocation are considered by incorporating travel-related attitudes, socio-demographic characteristics, and mobility tool ownership. Our findings indicate that living in a car-reduced neighbourhood significantly reduces multi-car ownership and, among residents who have a high affinity for sharing, also increases car-free households. Furthermore, residents of the car-reduced neighbourhood are more likely to adopt multimodal travel patterns that do not involve regular car use compared to those living in the inner city. The study underscores the potential of residential area design in fostering sustainable travel behaviour.
What impact can an integrated mobility concept have for a socio-ecological mobility transformation? This article provides answers based on four waves of a household survey, underpinned by insights from a real-world laboratory with Darmstadt's administration, planners, and the neighbourhood's residents.Academics and practitioners agree that mobility transformation requires a shift away from car dependence. However, the lasting impact of car-reducing measures on residents' mobility and liveability can only be observed in long-term studies, which are rare. With the Lincoln neighbourhood in Darmstadt, Germany, we analysed four waves of a quantitative household survey from 2020 to 2025 to examine the long-term effects of Lincoln's integrated mobility concept on residents' mobility, parking practices, and liveability. Additionally, we considered qualitative results, as well as reflections within the transdisciplinary project team and with Lincoln's residents. We found the following to be important for success: 1. both, car-restrictive and incentive-based measures to reduce car use and ownership, to promote car-independent mobility, and to increase liveability, 2. the participation of residents in the planning process, and 3. the monitoring and adjustment of the implementation by the municipal administration. However, even within the same city, challenges arise when attempting to transfer Lincoln's award-winning concept under changing political, social, and financial circumstances.