Quality-guided phase unwrapping is a widely used technique with different quality definitions and guiding strategies reported. It is thus necessary to do a detailed comparison of these approaches to choose the optimal quality map and guiding strategy. For quality maps, in the presence of noise, transform-based methods are found to be the best choice. However in the presence of discontinuities, phase unwrapping is itself unresolved and hence quality-guided phase unwrapping is not sufficient. For guiding strategies, classical, two-section, and stack-chain guiding strategies are chosen for comparison. If accuracy is the foremost criterion then the classical guiding strategy with a data structure of indexed interwoven linked list is best. If speed is of essence then the stack-chain guiding strategy is the one to use.
1 February 2010 in Optics and Lasers in Engineering
The nonlinear intensity response of a digital fringe projection profilometry (FPP) system causes the captured fringe patterns to be nonsinusoidal waveforms and leads to an additional phase measurement error for commonly used three- and four-step phase-shifting algorithms. We perform theoretical analysis of the phase error owing to the nonsinusoidal waveforms. Based on the derived theoretical model, a novel and simple iterative phase compensation algorithm is proposed to compensate the nonsinusoidal phase error. Experiments show that the proposed algorithm can be used for effective phase error compensation in practical phase-shifting FPP.
The multi-frequency temporal phase unwrapping (MF-TPU) method, as a classical phase unwrapping algorithm for fringe projection techniques, has the ability to eliminate the phase ambiguities even while measuring spatially isolated scenes or the objects with discontinuous surfaces. For the simplest and most efficient case in MF-TPU, two groups of phase-shifting fringe patterns with different frequencies are used: the high-frequency one is applied for 3D reconstruction of the tested object and the unit-frequency one is used to assist phase unwrapping for the wrapped phase with high frequency. The final measurement precision or sensitivity is determined by the number of fringes used within the high-frequency pattern, under the precondition that its absolute phase can be successfully recovered without any fringe order errors. However, due to the non-negligible noises and other error sources in actual measurement, the frequency of the high-frequency fringes is generally restricted to about 16, resulting in limited measurement accuracy. On the other hand, using additional intermediate sets of fringe patterns can unwrap the phase with higher frequency, but at the expense of a prolonged pattern sequence. With recent developments and advancements of machine learning for computer vision and computational imaging, it can be demonstrated in this work that deep learning techniques can automatically realize TPU through supervised learning, as called deep learning-based temporal phase unwrapping (DL-TPU), which can substantially improve the unwrapping reliability compared with MF-TPU even under different types of error sources, e.g., intensity noise, low fringe modulation, projector nonlinearity, and motion artifacts. Furthermore, as far as we know, our method was demonstrated experimentally that the high-frequency phase with 64 periods can be directly and reliably unwrapped from one unit-frequency phase using DL-TPU. These results highlight that challenging issues in optical metrology can be potentially overcome through machine learning, opening new avenues to design powerful and extremely accurate high-speed 3D imaging systems ubiquitous in nowadays science, industry, and multimedia.
By using the least-squares fitting approach, the calibration procedure for fringe projection profilometry becomes more flexible and easier, since neither the measurement of system geometric parameters nor precise control of plane moving is required. With consideration of camera lens distortion, we propose a modified least-squares calibration method for fringe projection profilometry. In this method, camera lens distortion is involved in the mathematical description of the system for least-squares fitting to reduce its influence. Both simulation and experimental results are shown to verify the validity and ease of use of this modified calibration method.