Research summary: Using collective action and social movement theory, we investigate the potential incentives and ability of stakeholders to engage in collective action that can increase firm‐specific nonmarket risk of mining companies. We argue that proximity to the nearest environmentally sensitive water source increases the probability that local stakeholders will take collective actions that impose material costs on the focal mine. We hypothesize that stock markets recognize this nonmarket risk and apply a discount on announcements related to mines located near such areas, and that these risks are moderated by the type of mineral, the nature of the water source, and the strength of host country institutions. Using a unique data set and an event study method, we find support for most of our arguments. Managerial summary: We argue that mines located near environmentally sensitive water sources are subject to nonmarket risks arising from the potential collective actions of local stakeholders and their allies. Stakeholder mobilization can impose material costs on a mine in the form of delays, regulatory hurdles, and closure. We find that stock markets recognize these nonmarket risks and apply a discount on announcements by mining companies whose mines are located near environmentally sensitive water sources, particularly rivers. However, we also find that investor reaction is stronger in countries with strong institutions that support collective action. Thus, nonmarket risk management is important even in countries that are typically characterized by low political and institutional risks. We discuss the degree to which these results can be generalized beyond mining.
12 February 2023 in Business Ethics, the Environment & Responsibility
Although companies recognize the importance of social responsibility and community engagement, conflicts between companies and communities have been noticeably increasing. To better understand the role of institutional environments in company–community conflicts, we analyze two mining conflicts—Minera Yanacocha's Minas Conga extension project in Peru and Minera Los Pelambres' El Mauro Tailings Dam in Chile. Our findings imply that, to prevent negative consequences and alleviate company–community conflicts, mining companies should address underlying structural causes and pursue informal approaches in order to obtain and maintain their social license. We find that better formal institutional environments not only alleviate conflict intensity but also facilitate informal approaches through which companies and communities can cooperate to resolve conflicts. The best practice would be to start and continue dialogs between communities and companies, mediated by impartial governments, to understand the concerns of the counterparty and find means by which to address the causes.
In this study, we investigate how the relationship between corporate social performance (CSP) and corporate financial performance (CFP) can be moderated by national institutional characteristics of different countries. Because of data availability, most existing studies on the relationship between CSP and CFP have utilized information drawn from a single country. Following Scott (2008; 1994), we classify diverse national institutions into three pillars: regulative, normative, and cognitive and look into their moderating role in CSP-CFP relationship. Using comprehensive social performance data from 18 countries over the years 2002 through 2012, we find that regulative characteristics such as freedom of competition and political stability positively moderate the CSP-CFP relationship. Normative characteristics such as NGO activity and education level also turn out to have positive moderating effect. We find, however, limited evidence that cognitive characteristics have any moderating effect on the relationship. These findings can provide guidance to multinational firms in how to manage their corporate social responsibility (CSR) operations based on the institutional characteristics of the host country and achieve strategic advantage.