Immune cells survey and patrol throughout the body and sometimes take residence in niche environments with distinct cellular subtypes and nutrients that may fluctuate from those in which they matured. Rooted in immune cell physiology are metabolic pathways and metabolites that not only deliver substrates and energy for growth and survival, but also instruct effector functions and cell differentiation. Unlike cancer cells, immune cells are not subject to a “Darwinian evolutionary pressure” that would allow them to adapt to developing tumors but are often irrevocably affected to local nutrient deprivation. Thus, immune cells must metabolically adapt to these changing conditions in order to perform their necessary functions. On the other hand, there is now a growing appreciation that metabolic changes occurring in cancer cells can impact on immune cell functionality and contribute to tumor immune evasion, and as such, there is a considerable and growing interest in developing techniques that target metabolism for immunotherapy. In this review, we discuss the metabolic plasticity displayed by innate and adaptive immune cells and highlight how tumor-derived lactate and tumor acidity restrict immunity. To our knowledge, this review outlines the most recent insights on how tumor microenvironment metabolically instructs immune responsiveness.

A defining hallmark of tumor phenotypes is uncontrolled cell proliferation, while fermentative glycolysis has long been considered as one of the major metabolic pathways that allows energy production and provides intermediates for the anabolic growth of cancer cells. Although such a vision has been crucial for the development of clinical imaging modalities, it has become now evident that in contrast to prior beliefs, mitochondria play a key role in tumorigenesis. Recent findings demonstrated that a full genetic disruption of the Warburg effect of aggressive cancers does not suppress but instead reduces tumor growth. Tumor growth then relies exclusively on functional mitochondria. Besides having fundamental bioenergetic functions, mitochondrial metabolism indeed provides appropriate building blocks for tumor anabolism, controls redox balance, and coordinates cell death. Hence, mitochondria represent promising targets for the development of novel anti-cancer agents. Here, after revisiting the long-standing Warburg effect from a historic and dynamic perspective, we review the role of mitochondria in cancer with particular attention to the cancer cell-intrinsic/extrinsic mechanisms through which mitochondria influence all steps of tumorigenesis, and briefly discuss the therapeutic potential of targeting mitochondrial metabolism for cancer therapy.

Hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) is a metabolically heterogeneous cancer and the use of glucose by HCC cells could impact their tumorigenicity. Dt81Hepa1-6 cells display enhanced tumorigenicity compared to parental Hepa1-6 cells. This increased tumorigenicity could be explained by a metabolic adaptation to more restrictive microenvironments. When cultured at high glucose concentrations, Dt81Hepa1-6 displayed an increased ability to uptake glucose (P<0.001), increased expression of 9 glycolytic genes, greater GTP and ATP (P<0.001), increased expression of 7 fatty acid synthesis-related genes (P<0.01) and higher levels of Acetyl-CoA, Citrate and Malonyl-CoA (P<0.05). Under glucose-restricted conditions, Dt81Hepa1-6 used their stored fatty acids with increased expression of fatty acid oxidation-related genes (P<0.01), decreased triglyceride content (P<0.05) and higher levels of GTP and ATP (P<0.01) leading to improved proliferation (P<0.05). Inhibition of lactate dehydrogenase and aerobic glycolysis with sodium oxamate led to decreased expression of glycolytic genes, reduced lactate, GTP and ATP levels (P<0.01), increased cell doubling time (P<0.001) and reduced fatty acid synthesis. When combined with cisplatin, this inhibition led to lower cell viability and proliferation (P<0.05). This metabolic-induced tumorigenicity was also reflected in human Huh7 cells by a higher glucose uptake and proliferative capacity compared to HepG2 cells (P<0.05). In HCC patients, increased tumoral expression of Glut-1, Hexokinase II and Lactate dehydrogenase correlated with poor survival (P = 2.47E⁻⁵, P = 0.016 and P = 6.58E⁻⁵). In conclusion, HCC tumorigenicity can stem from a metabolic plasticity allowing them to thrive in a broader range of glucose concentrations. In HCC, combining glycolytic inhibitors with conventional chemotherapy could lead to improved treatment efficacy.

Metabolite profiling identifies a signature of tumorigenicity in hepatocellular carcinoma Metabolite profiling identifies a signature of tumorigenicity in hepatocellular carcinoma

The liver plays a key role in maintaining physiological homeostasis and hepatocytes are largely responsible for this. The use of isolated primary hepatocytes has become an essential tool for the study of nutrient physiology, xenobiotic metabolism and several liver pathologies. Since hepatocytes are removed from their normal environment, the isolation procedure and in vitro culture of primary hepatocytes is partially known to induce undesired metabolic changes. We aimed to perform a thorough metabolic profiling of primary cells before, during and after isolation using state-of-the-art techniques. Extensive metabolite measurements using HPLC were performed in situ in the liver, during hepatocyte isolation using the two-step collagenase perfusion method and during in vitro cell culture for up to 48 hours. Assessment of mitochondrial respiratory capacity and ATP-linked respiration of isolated primary hepatocytes was performed using extracellular flux analysis. Primary hepatocytes displayed a drastic decrease in antioxidative-related metabolites (NADPH, NADP, GSH and GSSG) during the isolation procedure when compared to the in situ liver (P<0.001). Parallel assessment of citric acid cycle activity showed a significant decrease of up to 95% in Acetyl-CoA, Isocitrate/Citrate ratio, Succinate, Fumarate and Malate in comparison to the in situ liver (P<0.001). While the levels of several cellular energetic metabolites such as Adenosine, AMP, ADP and ATP were found to be progressively reduced during the isolation procedure and cell culture (P<0.001), higher ATP/ADP ratio and energy charge level were observed when primary cells were cultured in vitro compared to the in situ liver (P<0.05). In addition, a significant decrease in the respiratory capacity occurred after 24 hours in culture. Interestingly, this was not associated with a significant modification of ATP-linked respiration. In conclusion, major metabolic alterations occur immediately after hepatocytes are removed from the liver. These changes persist or increase during in vitro culture. These observations need to be taken into account when using primary hepatocytes for the study of metabolism or liver physiopathology.

There are limited numbers of models to study hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) in vivo in immunocompetent hosts. In an effort to develop a cell line with improved tumorigenicity, we derived a new cell line from Hepa1-6 cells through an in vivo passage in C57BL/6 mice. The resulting Dt81Hepa1-6 cell line showed enhanced tumorigenicity compared to Hepa1-6 with more frequent (28±12 vs. 0±0 lesions at 21 days) and more rapid tumor development (21 (100%) vs. 70 days (10%)) in C57BL/6 mice. The minimal Dt81Hepa1-6 cell number required to obtain visible tumors was 100,000 cells. The Dt81Hepa1-6 cell line showed high hepatotropism with subcutaneous injection leading to liver tumors without development of tumors in lungs or spleen. In vitro, Dt81Hepa1-6 cells showed increased anchorage-independent growth (34.7±6.8 vs. 12.3±3.3 colonies; P<0.05) and increased EpCAM (8.7±1.1 folds; P<0.01) and β-catenin (5.4±1.0 folds; P<0.01) expression. A significant proportion of Dt81Hepa1-6 cells expressed EpCAM compared to Hepa1-6 (34.8±1.1% vs 0.9±0.13%; P<0.001). Enriched EpCAM⁺ Dt81Hepa1-6 cells led to higher tumor load than EpCAM^- Dt81Hepa1-6 cells (1093±74 vs 473±100 tumors; P<0.01). The in vivo selected Dt81Hepa1-6 cell line shows high liver specificity and increased tumorigenicity compared to Hepa1-6 cells. These properties are associated with increased expression of EpCAM and β-catenin confirming that EpCAM⁺ HCC cells comprise a subset with characteristics of tumor-initiating cells with stem/progenitor cell features. The Dt81Hepa1-6 cell line with its cancer stem cell-like properties will be a useful tool for the study of hepatocellular carcinoma in vivo.