Synthetic rock mass (SRM) models commonly represent fractures as planar surfaces, potentially oversimplifying the complex geometries observed in natural rock masses. This study investigates whether incorporating large-scale fracture undulations significantly affects predicted rock-mass strength compared to conventional flat joint representations. Using the Finite-Discrete Element Method (FDEM), we analyzed multiple discrete fracture network (DFN) configurations under uniaxial and biaxial loading conditions, comparing models with geometrically simplified planar fractures against those incorporating conceptual undulated surfaces. Results reveal counterintuitive and inconsistent patterns across different DFN geometrical realizations, demonstrating that network topology and connectivity patterns govern overall behaviour more than individual fracture geometry. These findings challenge assumptions that geometric simplification can be systematically compensated through parameter adjustments. However, given that detailed fracture characterization data are typically unavailable until design completion, and even accessible rock outcrops provide only limited 2D surface exposures of inherently 3D fracture networks, pursuing sophisticated geometric representations may be impractical. Instead, engineering practice should focus on quantifying inherent variability bounds.
Synthetic rock mass (SRM) models are an invaluable component of rock engineering. Thus far, joints are implicitly modelled by adjusting rock mass properties, while flat joints are adopted for discontinuum models. This paper does not question the fundamental validity of these well-established methods for characterizing discontinuity shear strength under controlled laboratory conditions. The implicit assumption underlying this application is that surface undulation has a negligible impact on rock mass interlocking mechanisms and, consequently, on overall modelled rock mass strength. Compelling evidence suggests this assumption requires careful reconsideration. The difference in rock mass behaviour between explicitly undulated models and flat joints did not appear to exhibit any consistent patterns. Rough and flat joints did not, in the findings of this article, result in any consistent rock mass peak strength. Therefore, engineers may ascertain rock mass behaviour and strength without the use of explicit rock fracture undulations.