Risks have been classically understood as a probability of damage or a potential hazard resulting in appropriate management strategies. However, research on environmental issues such as pollutants in the aquatic environment or the impacts of climate change have shown that classical management approaches do not sufficiently cover these interactions between society and nature. There have been several attempts to develop interdisciplinary approaches to risk that include natural as well as social science contributions. In this paper, the authors aim at developing a social-ecological perspective on risk by drawing on the concept of societal relations to nature and the model of provisioning systems. This perspective is used to analyze four cases, pharmaceuticals, microplastics, semicentralized water infrastructures and forest management, with regard to risk identification, assessment and management. Finally, the paper aims at developing a perspective on risks which takes into account non-intended side-effects, system interdependencies and uncertainty.
Die Digitalisierung in der Siedlungswasserwirtschaft kann dazu beitragen, die Aufgaben, die sich für Wasserversorgung und Abwasserbeseitigung aufgrund des demografischen und klimatischen Wandels ergeben, besser anzugehen. Gleichzeitig können sich durch Cyberangriffe die Risiken für einen Ausfall dieser Kritischen Infrastrukturen vergrößern. Aspekte der Cybersicherheit werden im Wassersektor jedoch noch nicht hinreichend berücksichtigt. Entsprechende Regularien und Maßnahmen zielen alleine auf die Ausfallsicherheit der Infrastrukturen ab und vernachlässigen dabei die Versorgungssicherheit der Bevölkerung. Die Aufmerksamkeit der Politik auf große Wasserunternehmen und Versorgungsgebiete ignoriert Sicherheitslücken bei kleinen und mittleren Betrieben. Kooperationen zwischen mehreren Wasserunternehmen könnten ein geeignetes Mittel sein, diesbezüglich Synergieeffekte zu erzeugen.
25 November 2020 in Journal of Water Reuse and Desalination
Advanced wastewater treatment is often used to produce one single water quality. In recent years, technologies have been developed that allow the production of different qualities that are fit for their purpose. These technology bundles are still not being marketed, and market requirements are unclear. Two constellations in West Basin, California and in Oman were analysed to shed light on the different constellations of actors, resource situations and institutions. The first led to the industrial reuse of several water qualities, while the second produced an application in holiday resorts, leisure and food production. A hypothetical solution was contrasted with an historical case. The analysis of the constellations showed that multi-sectoral investments and dependencies require strong cooperation arrangements and long-term agreements. Governmental institutions were revealed to be suitable for coordinating the process, especially during the initial phase, but also in view of security of supply. A (comparative) examination allows an initial, still provisional systematic overview of other constellations that favour systems with recycled water of different qualities. Further research is required to understand the welfare and distribution effects of multimodal water pricing policies and the feasibility of co-financing of agricultural irrigation and opportunities for more sustainable water reuse.
This article examines the causes and addresses the prevention of unintended interconnections, particularly cross-connections, in novel urban water systems using the example of Qingdao, where a Resource Recovery Centre for the reuse of greywater and blackwater has been established for 12,000 inhabitants. With respect to cross-connections, this work incorporated both social-scientific and technical error analyses. The social-scientific error analysis systematically focused on the planning, implementation, and operational phases of the project. Organisational shortcomings were identified in four areas: (A) Coordination and consensus between the commissioned design institutes, (B) information in tenders, expertise, and awareness, (C) ownership by investors, and (D) time management. Based on empirical evidence, this article derives and discusses (eight) recommendations for good management, integrating technical and organisational measures aimed at preventing cross-connections. The pursuit of such measures is appropriate in order to prevent most types of misconnections—not just for the case under discussion, but for other novel urban water systems as well.