In order to understand current dynamics of religious diversity, a focus on the tangible presence of religion and the co-existence of new and longstanding religious buildings, sites and artifacts in urban spaces is a fruitful starting point. Launching the notion of iconic religion, this introduction seeks to contribute to developing a scholarly framework for the nexus of religion and the city from a spatial, material, aesthetic and semiotic angle. Situated in the interface between matter and religious meaning, religious icons are not simply carriers of meaning, but make it present.
Religious traditions – although socially constructed – are distinguishable as distinct, practiced entities having pragmatic effects. Religion is not a purely scholarly invention. Correspondencies between empirical data and scientific concepts, or, between object language and metalanguage, have to be found beyond essentialism and reification. Consequently, there is a shift in parts of the study of religion towards approaches that counteract essentialism and reification by explaining subject-matters through relationality. A relational paradigm is beyond the alternative of a naïve realism and positivism on the one hand or a radical constructivism or deconstructivism on the other hand. Against this background, the article draws attention to relations in the study of religion, especially between cognition, experience, action, and materiality, between semantics and social structure, and between structure and process. The article argues for a synthesis of different approaches in the study of religion, namely cognitive and material approaches, and experience- and action-orientated theories and methodologies.
Hat Religion in der modernen Gesellschaft an Bedeutung verloren? Oder erfährt sie derzeit vielmehr eine Renaissance? - Fragen, die nicht nur in den Geistes-, Kultur- und Sozialwissenschaften kontrovers diskutiert werden. Anhand von Fallstudien zu religiöser Erfahrung, zum pastoralen und sozialpolitischen Handeln der christlichen Großkirchen, zur Relevanz von Religion im Deutschland des 20. Jahrhunderts sowie zu religiösen Elementen in biographischen Entwürfen, Politik und Kunst zeichnet Volkhard Krech Entwicklungspfade von Religion in der Moderne nach, die diesseits der Alternativen von Systemzwang und Diffusion sowie Säkularisierung und Wiederkehr liegen.
The following is a marginally edited version of the conceptual considerations presented in the proposal for the establishment of Collaborative Research Center (CRC) “Metaphors of Religion: Religious Meaning-Making in Language Use”. The CRC has been established by the German Research Foundation in 2022 at Ruhr University Bochum (RUB) and Karlsruhe Institute of Technology (KIT). To start our working paper series Metaphor Papers, we wish to present the CRC’s conceptual framework to a broader scholarly community. Our CRC starts from the assumption that religious meaning-making occurs in and through metaphors. In metaphors, meaning is transferred from one semantic domain to another. Religion, which can never put its ultimate subject (the transcendent) directly into words, is especially dependent on this procedure. Religious meaning-making thus occurs as religion draws from its semantic environment and transfers meaning to its own domain. The CRC seeks to more thoroughly understand this process theoretically and grasp it methodologically to be able to research its semantic forms empirically and comparatively. In this way, the shapes religion takes as a socio-cultural phenomenon can be better understood and central developments within specific religious traditions become much more tangible. The CRC thus contributes to the historiography of religions, on the one hand, and to answering systematic questions in the comparative study of religions, on the other. While extensive research on metaphors in religious texts exists, the CRC’s novel approach lies in its systematic focus on metaphoricity as the central principle of religious meaning-making. This is based on a shared understanding of religion as communication and metaphor as a fundamental principle of language. We understand religion to be the form of communication that has the function of coping with ultimate contingency by means of the transcendence/immanence-distinction. In this paradoxical process, the metaphor with its simultaneousness of ‘is like’ and ‘is not’ is used to infer the unknown (target domain) from known means (source domain) and in this way creates religious meaning.
Vielfach wird heute die Meinung vertreten, Religion gehöre aufgrund der sog. SäkularisieÝ rung zu den »Verlierern« gesellschaftlicher Modernisierung. Demgegenüber steht die AnÝ nahme, dass Religion eine Transformation erfahren und sich in Bezug auf Inhalte, SozialforÝ men und Funktion(en) gewandelt habe. Diese paradigmatische Differenz zieht sich durch die Soziologie seit ihrer akademischen Etablierung und kennzeichnet auch noch die gegenwärtige Religionssoziologie. Der Forschungsüberblick zeigt allerdings, dass man es keineswegs mit unilinearen und homogenen Prozessen zu tun hat. Dass Aussagen über die Relevanz von Religion nur unter Berücksichtigung je spezifischer gesellschaftlicher Kontexte getroffen werden können, ist eine der Thesen des Beitrags.