Sulfur tells tectonic secrets: Plate tectonics dominates how the surface of Earth is shaped over geologic time; however, we do not know when this important process started on Earth. Smit et al. used sulfur isotopes in diamonds to show that atmospheric sulfur was entering the mantle 3 billion years ago through plate subduction. Older diamonds do not have this signature, constraining when plate tectonics started on Earth to around 3 billion years ago. Science , this issue p. 383