Limonene and linalool are among the most common fragrance terpenes used in everyday products. They are pre‐haptens, forming hydroperoxides (Lim‐OOHs, Lin‐OOHs) upon oxidation and inducing frequent positive patch test reactions in patients with dermatitis, and yet they are not routinely tested in Europe. This review evaluates current patch testing with Lim‐OOHs and Lin‐OOHs by asking whether hydroperoxide patch testing is warranted, examining the difficulties or challenges related to reading and interpreting hydroperoxide patch test results with currently available material, and assessing their relevance. Studies are increasingly pointing to high percentages of positive reactions in patients consecutively patch tested with these oxidized products. An association between a positive clinical history and a strong patch test reaction has been described, but problems with doubtful/irritant reactions have also been reported. Considering the high frequency of relevant positive reactions, the incorporation of Lim‐OOHs 0.3% and Lin‐OOHs 1% in the baseline series may be justified. Since exposure, sensitization, and elicitation limits of Lim‐OOHs and Lin‐OOHs in the products still need to be better determined, an assessment of previous exposure, possible sensitizations, and reactions may help to improve the clinical assessment.
Summary: Background: Methylisothiazolinone (MI) [with methylchloroisothiazolinone (MCI) in a ratio of 1:3, a well‐recognized allergenic preservative] was released as an individual preservative in the 2000s for industrial products and in 2005 for cosmetics. The high level of exposure to MI since then has provoked an epidemic of contact allergy to MI, and an increase in MI/MCI allergy. There are questions concerning the MI/MCI cross‐reaction pattern.Objectives: To bring a new perspective on the MI/MCI cross‐reactivity issue by studying their in situ chemical behaviour in 3D reconstructed human epidermis (RHE).Methods: MI and MCI were synthesized with 13C substitution at positions C‐4/C‐5 and C‐5, respectively. Their in situ chemical behaviours in an RHE model were followed by use of the high‐resolution magic angle spinning nuclear magnetic resonance technique.Results: MI was found to react exclusively with cysteine thiol residues, whereas MCI reacted with histidines and lysines. The reaction mechanisms were found to be different for MI and MCI, and the adducts formed had different molecular structures.Conclusion: In RHE, different MI/MCI reactions towards different nucleophilic amino acids were observed, making it difficult to explain cross‐reactivity between MI and MCI.
The first step in the development of skin sensitisation to a chemical, and in the elicitation of further allergic contact dermatitis (ACD), is the binding of the allergen to skin proteins after penetrating into the epidermis. The so-formed antigenic adduct is then recognised by the immune system as foreign to the body. Sensitising organic hydroperoxides derived from autoxidation of natural terpenes are believed to form antigens through radical-mediated mechanisms, although this has not yet been established. So far, in vitro investigations on reactive radical intermediates derived from these skin sensitisers have been conducted in solution, yet with experimental conditions being far away from real-life sensitisation. Herein, we report for the first time, the potential use of EPR spin-trapping to study the in situ generation of free radicals derived from cumene hydroperoxide CumOOH in a 3D reconstructed human epidermis (RHE) model, thus much closer to what may happen in vivo. Among the undesirable effects associated with dermal exposure to CumOOH, it is described to cause allergic and irritant dermatitis, being reported as a significant sensitiser. We considered exploiting the usage of spin-trap DEPMPO as an extensive view of all sort of radicals derived from CumOOH were observed all at once in solution. We showed that in the EpiskinTM RHE model, both by incubating in the assay medium and by topical application, carbon radicals are mainly formed by redox reactions suggesting the key role of CumOOH-derived carbon radicals in the antigen formation process.
18 November 2020 in British Journal of Dermatology
Background Skin sensitisation to hydroperoxides (R‐OOHs) of the commonly used fragrance terpenes limonene, linalool and citronellol is frequently reported. R‐OOHs are believed to initiate the process leading to sensitisation and allergic contact dermatitis (ACD) through mechanisms involving radical intermediates. Thus, radical intermediates, keratinocytes and dendritic cells (DC) may act in concert to initiate the process. Objectives To evaluate individual DC activation profiles in the context of keratinocytes by R‐OOHs with regard to frequency, specificity and magnitude of upregulation. Methods 2D and 3D cocultures with keratinocytes/reconstructed human epidermis (RHE) and DC to evaluate cell surface levels of the costimulatory molecules CD86, CD80 and the adhesion molecule CD54 on cocultured DC. Analysis of radical formation from limonene hydroperoxides in RHE by EPR‐ST. Results R‐OOHs induce donor‐dependent DC activation. Major differences were found between the limonene‐OOHs. Limonene‐1‐OOH was stronger with respect to both, frequency and magnitude of responses. Using a 3D coculture model, no DC activation was detected after topical application of 0.2% limonene‐OOHs (20 µg/cm2), while 1.2% limonene‐1‐OOH or 2% limonene‐2‐OOH induced DC activation. Furthermore, we demonstrated differences in the formed carbon and oxygen radicals from the limonene‐OOHs using RHE, mimicking what may happen in vivo. Conclusions We report clear individual differences in DC maturation by the most important hydroperoxides. Both, response rates and magnitude of response indicate that very small structural alterations in the hydroperoxides are translated into specific DC responses. In addition, we provide more insights into the amounts of hydroperoxides that are able to activate DC and induce sensitisation.