Ol'ha Brovarets'

Dr. Ol'ha Brovarets'

Institute of Molecular Biology & Genetics of the NAS of Ukraine
orcid

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

17Years (2010-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
6 February 2013 in Journal of Biomolecular Structure and Dynamics
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
OBOl'ha Brovarets'
Ol'ha Brovarets'
DHDmytro Hovorun
Dmytro Hovorun
Trying to answer the question posed in the title, we have carried out a detailed theoretical investigation of the biologically important mechanism of the tautomerization of the A·T Watson–Crick DNA base pair, information that is hard to establish experimentally. By combining theoretical investigations at the MP2 and density functional theory levels of QM theory with quantum theory of atoms in molecules analysis, the tautomerization of the A·T Watson–Crick base pair by the double proton transfer (DPT) was comprehensively studied in vacuo and in the continuum with a low dielectric constant (ϵ = 4) corresponding to a hydrophobic interfaces of protein–nucleic acid interactions. Based on the sweeps of the electron-topological, geometric, and energetic parameters, which describe the course of the tautomerization along its intrinsic reaction coordinate (IRC), it was proved that the A·T → A∗·T∗ tautomerization through the DPT is a concerted (i.e. the pathway without an intermediate) and asynchronous (i.e. protons move with a time gap) process. The limiting stage of this phenomenon is the final PT along the N6H⋯O4 hydrogen bond (H-bond). The continuum with ϵ = 4 does not affect qualitatively the course of the tautomerization reaction: similar to that observed in vacuo, it proceeds via a concerted asynchronous process with the same structure of the transition state (TS). For the first time, the nine key points along the IRC of the A·T base pair tautomerization, which could be considered as electron-topological “fingerprints” of a concerted asynchronous process of the tautomerization via the DPT, have been identified and fully characterized. These nine key points have been used to define the reactant, TS, and product regions of the DPT in the A·T base pair. Considering the energy dependence of each of the three H-bonds, which stabilize the Watson–Crick and Löwdin’s base pairs, along the IRC of the tautomerization, it was found that all these H-bonds in the А·Т base pair are cooperative, reinforcing each other, whereas the C2H⋯O2 H-bond in the А∗·Т∗ base pair behaves anticooperatively, in other words it gets weakened while two others get strengthened. From a quantum-mechanical point of view, the A∗·T∗ Löwdin’s base pair appeared to be dynamically unstable because the electronic energy of the back-reaction barrier of the A·T → A∗·T∗ tautomerization does not exceed zero-point vibrational energy associated with the mode for which vibrational frequency becomes imaginary in the TS of tautomerization. Additionally, it was demonstrated using the conductor-like polarizable continuum model that the effects of biomolecular environment (ϵ = 4) cannot ensure dynamic stabilization of the A∗·T∗ Löwdin’s base pair. These findings, together with data available from the literature, indicate that the tautomerization of the A·T Watson–Crick base pair to the A∗·T∗ Löwdin’s base pair through the DPT cannot be a source of spontaneous point errors that occur during DNA replication.

3 June 2013 in Journal of Biomolecular Structure and Dynamics
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
OBOl'ha Brovarets'
Ol'ha Brovarets'
YYYevgen P. Yurenko
Yevgen P. Yurenko
DHDmytro Hovorun
Dmytro Hovorun
This study aims to cast light on the physico-chemical nature and energetic of the non-conventional CH···O/N H-bonds in the biologically important natural nucleobase pairs using a comprehensive quantum-chemical approach. As a whole, the 36 biologically important pairs, involving canonical and rare tautomers of nucleobases, were studied by means of all available up-to-date state-of-the-art quantum-chemical techniques along with quantum theory "Atoms in molecules" (QTAIM), Natural Bond Orbital (NBO) analysis, Grunenberg's compliance constants theory, geometrical and vibrational analyses to identify the CH···O/N interactions, reveal their physico-chemical nature and estimate their strengths as well as contribution to the overall base-pairs stability. It was shown that all the 38 CH···O/N contacts (25 CH···O and 13 CH···N H-bonds) completely satisfy all classical geometrical, electron-topological, in particular Bader's and "two-molecule" Koch and Popelier's, and vibrational criteria of H-bonding. The positive values of Grunenberg's compliance constants prove that the CH···O/N contacts in nucleobase pairs are stabilizing interactions unlike electrostatic repulsion and anti-H-bonds. NBO analysis indicates the electron density transfer from the lone electron pair of the acceptor atom (O/N) to the antibonding orbital corresponding to the donor group σ(∗)(CH). Moreover, significant increase in the frequency of the out-of-plane deformation modes γ (CH) under the formation of the CH···O (by 17.2÷81.3/10.8÷84.7 cm(-1)) and CH···N (by 32.7÷85.9/9.0÷77.9 cm(-1)) H-bonds at the density functional theory (DFT)/second-order Møller-Plesset (MP2) levels of theory, respectively, and concomitant changes of their intensities can be considered as reliable indicators of H-bonding. The strengths of the CH···O/N interactions, evaluated by means of Espinosa-Molins-Lecomte formula, lie within the range 0.45÷3.89/0.62÷4.10 kcal/mol for the CH···O H-bonds and 1.45÷3.17/1.70÷3.43 kcal/mol for the CH···N H-bonds at the DFT/MP2 levels of theory, respectively. We revealed high linear mutual correlations between the H-bond energy and different physico-chemical parameters of the CH···O/N H-bonds. Based on these observations, the authors asserted that the most reliable descriptors of the H-bonding are the electron density ρ at the СН···О/N H-bond critical points and the NBO calculated stabilization energy E((2)). The linear dependence of the H-bond energy ECH···O/N (in kcal/mol) on the electron density ρ (in atomic units) was established (DFT/MP2): ECH···O = 248.501[Formula: see text]ρ-0.367/260.518[Formula: see text]ρ-0.373 and ECH···N = 218.125[Formula: see text]ρ-0.339/243.599[Formula: see text]ρ-0.441. Red-shifted and blue-shifted CH···O/N H-bonds behave in a similar way and can be described with the same fit parameters. It was found that the A-U HH2 and U-U3 nucleobase pairs are stabilized solely by the CH···O/N H-bonds. At the same time, in the A-U HH1, A-U HH2, A-Asyn 1, A-Asyn 2, A-Asyn 3, A-A4, A-G1, A-G2, G-U1, G-U2, G-U3, G-C HH1, U-U1, U-U2, U-U3 and A-C nucleobase pairs the CH···O/N H-bonds play a prominent role (>30%) in their stabilization. We suppose that unconventional CH···O/N H-bond plays the role of the third "fulcrum", ensuring structurally dynamic similarity of the isomorphic base pairs of different origin, which are incorporated equally well into the structure of the DNA double helix.

2 August 2013 in Journal of Biomolecular Structure and Dynamics
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
OBOl'ha Brovarets'
Ol'ha Brovarets'
DHDmytro Hovorun
Dmytro Hovorun
The ground-state tautomerization of the G·C Watson–Crick base pair by the double proton transfer (DPT) was comprehensively studied in vacuo and in the continuum with a low dielectric constant (ϵ = 4), corresponding to a hydrophobic interface of protein–nucleic acid interactions, using DFT and MP2 levels of quantum-mechanical (QM) theory and quantum theory “Atoms in molecules” (QTAIM). Based on the sweeps of the electron-topological, geometric, polar, and energetic parameters, which describe the course of the G·C ↔ G∗·C∗ tautomerization (mutagenic tautomers of the G and C bases are marked with an asterisk) through the DPT along the intrinsic reaction coordinate (IRC), it was proved that it is, strictly speaking, a concerted asynchronous process both at the DFT and MP2 levels of theory, in which protons move with a small time gap in vacuum, while this time delay noticeably increases in the continuum with ϵ = 4. It was demonstrated using the conductor-like polarizable continuum model (CPCM) that the continuum with ϵ = 4 does not qualitatively affect the course of the tautomerization reaction. The DPT in the G·C Watson–Crick base pair occurs without any intermediates both in vacuum and in the continuum with ϵ = 4 at the DFT/MP2 levels of theory. The nine key points along the IRC of the G·C base pair tautomerization, which could be considered as electron-topological “fingerprints” of a concerted asynchronous process of the tautomerization via the DPT, have been identified and fully characterized. These key points have been used to define the reactant, transition state, and product regions of the DPT reaction in the G·C base pair. Analysis of the energetic characteristics of the H-bonds allows us to arrive at a definite conclusion that the middle N1H⋯N3/N3H⋯N1 and the lower N2H⋯O2/N2H⋯O2 parallel H-bonds in the G·C/G∗·C∗ base pairs, respectively, are anticooperative, that is, the strengthening of the middle H-bond is accompanied by the weakening of the lower H-bond. At that point, the upper N4H⋯O6 and O6H⋯N4 H-bonds in the G·C and G∗·C∗ base pairs, respectively, remain constant at the changes of the middle and the lower H-bonds at the beginning and at the ending of the G·C ↔ G∗·C∗ tautomerization. Aiming to answer the question posed in the title of the article, we established that the G∗·C∗ Löwdin’s base pair satisfies all the requirements necessary to cause point mutations in DNA except its lifetime, which is much less than the period of time required for the replication machinery to forcibly dissociate a base pair into the monomers (several ns) during DNA replication. So, from the physicochemical point of view, the G∗·C∗ Löwdin’s base pair cannot be considered as a source of point mutations arising during DNA replication.

28 October 2014 in Journal of Biomolecular Structure and Dynamics
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
OBOl'ha Brovarets'
Ol'ha Brovarets'
YYYevgen P. Yurenko
Yevgen P. Yurenko
DHDmytro Hovorun
Dmytro Hovorun
This paper is a logical continuation of the theoretical survey of the CH⋯O/N specific contacts in the nucleobase pairs using a wide arsenal of the modern methods, which was initiated in our previous study [J. Biomol. Struct. & Dynam., 2014, 32, 993-1022]. It was established that 34 CH⋯O and 7 CH⋯N interactions, that were detected by quantum-chemical calculations in the 39 biologically important pairs involving modified nucleobases, completely satisfy all geometrical, vibrational, electron-topological, in particular Bader's and "two-molecule" Koch and Popelier's, Grunenberg's compliance constants theory and natural bond orbital criteria indicating that they can be identified as true H-bonds. The geometrical criteria of the H-bond formation are fulfilled for all considered CH⋯O/N H-bonds without any exception. It was shown that the classical rule of the stretching vibration shifts does not work in the ~95% cases of the CH⋯O/N H-bonds. Furthermore, significant increase in the frequency of the out-of-plane deformation modes γ(CH) under the formation of CH⋯O/N H-bonds and corresponding changes of their intensities can be also considered as reliable indicators of the H-bonding. We revealed high linear mutual correlations between the electron density, Laplacian of the electron density, H-bond energy at the (3, -1) bond critical points of the CH⋯O/N H-bonds, and different physico-chemical parameters of the CH⋯O/N H-bonds. We suggested that the electron density ρ and the interaction energy E((2)) of the lone orbital pairs are the most reliable descriptors of the H-bonding. The linear dependence of the H-bond energy ECH⋯O/N on the electron density ρ was established: ECH⋯O = 250.263∙ρ - .380/258.255∙ρ - .396 and ECH⋯N = 196.800∙ρ - .172/268.559∙ρ - .703 obtained at the density functional theory (DFT)/Møller-Plesset (MP2) levels of theory, respectively. The studies of the interaction energies show that the contribution of the CH⋯O and CH⋯N H-bonds into the base pairs stability varies from 3.0/4.2 to 35.1/31.2% and from 3.0/4.3 to 44.4/46.5% at the DFT/MP2 levels of theory, accordingly. Energy decomposition analysis performed for all base pairs involving canonical and modified nucleobases defines the electrostatic attraction and Pauli repulsion as dominant stabilizing forces in all complexes. This observation was additionally confirmed by the results of the QTAIM delocalization indexes analysis. The studies reported here advance our understanding of the biological role of the weak CH⋯O/N H-bonds, that dictates the requirements for the structural and dynamical similarity of the canonical and mismatched pairs with Watson-Crick (WC) geometry, which facilitates their enzymatic incorporation into the DNA double helix during DNA replication. Thus, these H-bonds in the base pairs with WC geometry may be also considered as "the last drop" at the transmission of the electronic signal that launches the chemical incorporation of the incoming nucleoside triphosphate into DNA.

23 June 2014 in Journal of Biomolecular Structure and Dynamics
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
OBOl'ha Brovarets'
Ol'ha Brovarets'
DHDmytro Hovorun
Dmytro Hovorun
This study provides the first accurate investigation of the tautomerization of the biologically important guanine*·thymine (G*·T) DNA base mispair with Watson–Crick geometry, involving the enol mutagenic tautomer of the G and the keto tautomer of the T, into the G·T* mispair (∆G = .99 kcal mol−1, population = 15.8% obtained at the MP2 level of quantum-mechanical theory in the continuum with ε = 4), formed by the keto tautomer of the G and the enol mutagenic tautomer of the T base, using DFT and MP2 methods in vacuum and in the weakly polar medium (ε = 4), characteristic for the hydrophobic interfaces of specific protein–nucleic acid interactions. We were first able to show that the G*·T↔G·T* tautomerization occurs through the asynchronous concerted double proton transfer along two antiparallel O6H···O4 and N1···HN3 H-bonds and is assisted by the third N2H···O2 H-bond, that exists along the entire reaction pathway. The obtained results indicate that the G·T* base mispair is stable from the thermodynamic point of view complex, while it is dynamically unstable structure in vacuum and dynamically stable structure in the continuum with ε = 4 with lifetime of 6.4·10−12 s, that, on the one side, makes it possible to develop all six low-frequency intermolecular vibrations, but, on the other side, it is by three orders less than the time (several ns) required for the replication machinery to forcibly dissociate a base pair into the monomers during DNA replication. One of the more significant findings to emerge from this study is that the short-lived G·T* base mispair, which electronic interaction energy between the bases (−23.76 kcal mol−1) exceeds the analogical value for the G·C Watson–Crick nucleobase pair (−20.38 kcal mol−1), “escapes from the hands” of the DNA replication machinery by fast transforming into the G*·T mismatch playing an indirect role of its supplier during the DNA replication. So, exactly the G*·T mismatch was established to play the crucial role in the spontaneous point mutagenesis.

1 August 2013 in Journal of Biomolecular Structure and Dynamics
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
OBOl'ha Brovarets'
Ol'ha Brovarets'
DHDmytro Hovorun
Dmytro Hovorun
The molecular structures, relative stability order, and dipole moments of a complete family of 21 planar hypoxanthine (Hyp) prototropic molecular–zwitterionic tautomers including ylidic forms were computationally investigated at the MP2/6–311++G(2df,pd)//B3LYP/6–311++G(d,p) level of theory in vacuum and in three different surrounding environments: continuum with a low dielectric constant (ϵ = 4) corresponding to a hydrophobic interface of protein–nucleic acid interactions, dimethylsulfoxide (DMSO), and water. The keto-N1HN7H tautomer was established to be the global minimum in vacuum and in continuum with ϵ = 4, while Hyp molecule exists as a mixture of the keto-N1HN9H and keto-N1HN7H tautomers in approximately equal amounts in DMSO and in water at T = 298.15 K. We found out that neither intramolecular tautomerization by single proton transfer in the Hyp base, nor intermolecular tautomerization by double proton transfer in the most energetically favorable Hyp·Hyp homodimer (symmetry C 2h ), stabilized by two equivalent N1H…O6 H-bonds, induces the formation of the enol tautomer (marked with an asterisk) of Hyp with cis-oriented O6H hydroxyl group relative to neighboring N1C6 bond. We first discovered a new scenario of the keto–enol tautomerization of Hyp · Hyp homodimer (C 2h ) via zwitterionic near-orthogonal transition state (TS), stabilized by N1+H…N1− and O6+H…N1− H-bonds, to heterodimer Hyp∗ · Hyp (C s ), stabilized by O6H…O6 and N1H…N1 H-bonds. We first showed that Hyp∗ · Thy mispair (C s ), stabilized by O6H…O4, N3H…N1, and C2H…O2 H-bonds, mimicking Watson–Crick base pairing, converts to the wobble Hyp · Thy base pair (C s ), stabilized by N3H…O6 and N1H…O2 H-bonds, via high- and low-energy TSs and intermediate Hyp · Thy∗, stabilized by O4H…O6, N1H…N3, and C2H…O2 H-bonds. The most energetically favorable TS is the zwitterionic pair Hyp+ · Thy− (C s ), stabilized by O6+H…O4−, O6+H…N3−, N1+H…N3−, and N1+H…O2− H-bonds. The authors expressed and substantiated the hypothesis, that the keto tautomer of Hyp is a mutagenic compound, while enol tautomer Hyp∗ does not possess mutagenic properties. The lifetime of the nonmutagenic tautomer Hyp∗ exceeds by many orders the time needed to complete a round of DNA replication in the cell. For the first time purine–purine planar H-bonded mispairs containing Hyp in the anti-orientation with respect to the sugar moiety – Hyp · Ade syn , Hyp · Gua∗ syn , and Hyp · Gua syn , that closely resembles the geometry of the Watson–Crick base pairs, have been suggested as the source of transversions. An influence of the surrounding environment (ϵ = 4) on the stability of studied complexes and corresponding TSs was estimated by means of the conductor-like polarizable continuum model. Electron-topological, structural, vibrational, and energetic characterictics of all conventional and nonconventional H-bonds in the investigated structures are presented. Presented data are key to understanding elementary molecular mechanisms of mutagenic action of Hyp as a product of the adenine deamination in DNA.