The ‘middle sort of people’ is a social group that has been the subject of increased historical research in the last decade. Many studies have been written, and many definitions offered of the group, its identity, and its membership. As a result, these overlapping groups and contrasting methods of definition have caused the nature and identity of the group to remain elusive. This study charts the evolution of the historiography of the ‘middle sort’, and the many attempts to produce positive and accurate definitions of the group. It suggests that the identity of the ‘middle sort’ may, in fact, be more complex than is allowed for by existing studies, with different identities being adopted according to social context. It concludes that while the term ‘middle sort of people’ is an appropriate contemporary collective term for use by historians, it is much more problematic as a description of an active, cohesive social group in the early modern period.
This is one of the first in-depth studies of masculinity within a particular social group – the landed gentry – over a time span of several hundred years. This research is based on approximately 4,100 letters drawn from 19 landed families across England between c. 1680 and c. 1900, based upon a three-year research project funded by the Arts and Humanities Research Council. Its purpose was to move beyond the study of printed conduct literature, which had dominated earlier accounts, by examining the values expressed in family correspondence in order to get closer to social practices. Letters between parents, children, siblings and other relatives reveal the ways in which masculine norms were produced through everyday interactions and judgements, and help us reconstruct the subjective experiences of elite masculinity in this period. The book concentrates on four important periods in the life-course for the reproduction of these masculine values: schooling, university, foreign travel and marriage and family life. These illustrate that there is only limited evidence of sharp-edged differences in values between generations in these families, and that these changes appear not to correspond to the deep ‘hegemonic shifts’ so often emphasized in existing accounts. The study suggests that the fundamental distributions of power and authority within Gentry families remained fairly constant. Conventional ideas of male honour, virtue, reputation and autonomy were remarkably tenacious, and the continued stress on family heritage, dynastic traditions and the future security of the family patrimony acted as a brake on changes in the training of young English gentlemen.
(2008). ‘Upon your entry into the world’: masculine values and the threshold of adulthood among landed elites in England 1680–1800. Social History: Vol. 33, No. 4, pp. 402-422.
The quantitative study of English land markets in the three centuries after the close of the middle ages is still in its infancy. The medievalists, exploiting the conveyances of customary tenants recorded in manorial court rolls, have shown how issues such as the devolution of land within families, the frequency with which land was sold and the behaviour of the land market at moments of demographic or economic stress can be addressed by the analysis of such data either aggregatively or by looking at the landholding histories of individual participants in the land market. Early modernists have invariably approached the study of the land market in a non-quantitative fashion, usually as part of an attempt to make observations about some other characteristic of English history. Stone looked at the land market in the sixteenth and early seventeenth centuries as part of his campaign to prove that the aristocracy was in decline, Macfarlane to show that the property-holding behaviour of the English was ‘individualistic’, Habbakuk to explore the strategies by which the English aristocracy maintained its supremacy and Mingay and others to settle the debate about the effect of enclosure on the small landowner. The early modern land market has rarely, if ever, been seen as worthy of discussion in its own right.