Germ cell number during ovarian organogenesis is regulated through programmed cell death. We investigated the expression of germ-cell-specific VASA protein, apoptosis-related proteins BAX and BCL-2 and DNA fragmentation in developing human ovaries from gestation week 12 to term. Human fetal ovaries from 13 women undergoing spontaneous abortion were fixed, paraffin-embedded and processed for immunohistochemistry to analyse temporal and cellular localization of VASA, BCL-2 and BAX, and to detect apoptosis by TUNEL assay. VASA showed a differential pattern of expression throughout the differentiation and proliferative phase and prophase I to finally associate with Balbiani's body in primordial and primary follicles. BCL-2 was detected from week 12 to 17 and became undetectable thereafter. Strong BAX signal was detected in oogonia and oocytes from week 12 to term. Low levels (≤10%) of TUNEL positive germ cells were detectable throughout gestation with a higher incidence (around 20%) at 18–20 weeks. VASA was specifically expressed in germ cells and displayed a stage-specific intracellular localization enabling one to follow oogenesis throughout gestation. Apoptosis-inhibiting BCL-2 was associated with the germ cell proliferative phase and prophase I, whereas BAX remained positive throughout gestation. The highest incidence of apoptotic germ cells was coincident with the lack of detectable BCL-2 protein, and when primordial follicle formation became widespread.
How do apoptosis-related BCL2 and BAX genes, known to regulate death or survival of germ cells in fetal and adult life, and germ-cell-specific VASA protein behave from birth to puberty in the human ovary? In resting primordial follicles in both infant and pubertal ovaries, BCL2 family members and germ-cell-specific VASA behave as in fetal life. After birth, once follicles leave the resting reserve to enter the growing follicular pool, detection of apoptosis-related genes moves from the germ cell to granulosa cells and VASA expression is lost. In the human ovary, around 85% of the 7 × 106 potential oocytes produced at mid-gestation are lost before birth, an extra 10% before puberty, and loss continues throughout reproductive life until germinal exhaustion of the ovary. Oocyte loss is mainly driven through a balanced expression of BCL2 gene family members. Apoptosis-inducing BAX gene shows a sustained expression throughout fetal and adult life, whereas apoptosis-inhibiting BCL2 is detectable during the proliferative stage of primordial germ cells and oogonia in the fetal ovary and proliferation of granulosa cells in growing follicles in the adult ovary. The germ-cell marker VASA is detectable in the fetal ovary from early oogenesis and is conspicuously expressed in primordial follicles, where in late pregnancy it is associated with the Balbiani's vitelline space. VASA expression is not detectable in the adult ovary. This is a qualitative analysis involving infant/pubertal paraffin-embedded human ovaries screened for apoptosis-related proteins, DNA fragmentation and germ-cell identity. Ovaries from 13 patients ranging in age from 4 to 16 years, undergoing gynaecological surgical procedures due to benign pathology, were studied. Tissues were fixed in 10% formalin, paraffin-embedded and processed for immunohistochemistry to screen the temporal and cellular localization of germ-cell-specific VASA protein and BCL2 and BAX apoptosis-related proteins. In addition, a terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase-mediated deoxiuridinetriphosphate nick-end labelling (TUNEL) assay was performed to detect DNA fragmentation. General histology and tissue integrity were assessed by haematoxylin–eosin staining. VASA showed a differential pattern of expression; in the resting primordial follicle reserve in infant and pubertal ovaries, it was associated with the Balbiani's body space in the germ cell. VASA remained detectable in primary follicles leaving the resting reserve, but once follicles entered the growing pool it became undetectable. This pattern of VASA expression is the same as in the fetal ovary. BAX was expressed both in the resting primordial reserve and in the pool of growing follicles, whereas BCL2 was detected only in granulosa cells in antral follicles in the growing pool. Apoptosis-related protein expression moved from the germ cell to the somatic stratum when primordial follicles left the resting reserve to enter the pool of growing follicles, irrespective of female age. Most TUNEL-positive cells were detected in the granulosa cells of antral follicles. No TUNEL-positive cells were found in resting primordial follicles. The study was limited by the qualitative nature of the immuno-histochemical analysis and the TUNEL assay. The results neither quantify the levels of germ-cell death nor exclude other concurrent cell death mechanisms that could act in the regulation of female germ-cell number. This study provides missing knowledge about apoptosis and germ-cell-specific VASA expression in the human ovary between birth and puberty and the participation of BCL2 and BAX genes in the balance between death and survival throughout female germ-line development. Intracellular localization of VASA in resting follicles emerges as a possible marker with prognostic value that needs further investigation, especially in infant patients entering ovarian cryo-preservation programmes. This knowledge will be valuable in optimizing the rescue and clinical use of germ cells to restore fertility in women. No external funding was obtained for this study. The authors have no conflicts of interest to declare. Not applicable.
It has been widely accepted that mammalian females are born with a non-renewing, finite pool of oocytes that will be continuously cleared by atresia, with only a small proportion of them reaching ovulation. Apoptosis regulates this mass germ cell death, especially through the balance between pro- and anti-apoptotic proteins encoded by the BCL-2 gene family. The caviomorph rodent Lagostomus maximus, the South American plains viscacha, displays the highest ovulation rate known for a mammal releasing 400–800 eggs per cycle. We tested the hypothesis that in L. maximus massive polyovulation is a consequence of reduced apoptosis resulting in suppressed follicular atresia. We found that anti-apoptotic BCL-2 gene is markedly expressed in all kind of follicles from primordial to fully mature antral stages in the adult ovary of L. maximus. On the other hand, pro-apoptotic BAX gene showed weak signals or was undetectable by immunohistochemical examination. Western blot against both proteins confirmed immunohistochemical results. Screening for DNA fragmentation by TUNEL assay was conspicuously negative in ovaries from both pregnant and non-pregnant females. In addition, α-oestrogen receptor also showed an enhanced expression from primordial stage to fully mature antral follicles. Our results show that natural preferential expression of BCL-2 and restricted BAX expression greatly suppresses apoptosis in the ovary of L. maximus. This prevents the decline of the oocyte reserve by abolishing follicular atresia and enables the highest ovulation rate known for a mammal, 400–800 or more eggs per cycle. Abstract It has been widely accepted that mammalian females are born with a non-renewing, finite pool of oocytes that will be continuously cleared by atresia, with only a small proportion of them reaching ovulation. Apoptosis regulates this mass germ cell death, especially through the balance between pro- and anti-apoptotic proteins encoded by the BCL-2 gene family. The caviomorph rodent Lagostomus maximus, the South American plains viscacha, displays the highest ovulation rate known for a mammal releasing 400–800 eggs per cycle. We tested the hypothesis that in L. maximus massive polyovulation is a consequence of reduced apoptosis resulting in suppressed follicular atresia. We found that anti-apoptotic BCL-2 gene is markedly expressed in all kind of follicles from primordial to fully mature antral stages in the adult ovary of L. maximus. On the other hand, pro-apoptotic BAX gene showed weak signals or was undetectable by immunohistochemical examination. Western blot against both proteins confirmed immunohistochemical results. Screening for DNA fragmentation by TUNEL assay was conspicuously negative in ovaries from both pregnant and non-pregnant females. In addition, α-oestrogen receptor also showed an enhanced expression from primordial stage to fully mature antral follicles. Our results show that natural preferential expression of BCL-2 and restricted BAX expression greatly suppresses apoptosis in the ovary of L. maximus. This prevents the decline of the oocyte reserve by abolishing follicular atresia and enables the highest ovulation rate known for a mammal, 400–800 or more eggs per cycle.
Mammalian testis undergoes deep changes in their architecture and function during photoregression conditions in seasonal breeders. Particularly, the testicular mechanisms that regulate the transition between the active (functional) and inactive (regression) stage vary between species. The aim of the present study was to analyze the incidence of proliferation, apoptosis and autophagy in the testicular seminiferous ephitelium of a seasonal breeder, Lagostomus maximus, during the annual reproductive cycle. We observed that proliferating spermatogonia increased from the active testis until reaching the maximum peak in the activating testis. During the annual reproductive cycle, the quantity of apoptotic-TUNEL positive spermatogonia and meiotic germ cells was constant and this might be regulated by the members of the BCL2 family. Only in the activating testis, apoptosis of germ cells was almost undetectable. The analysis of the autophagic-related proteins BECN1 and LC3 showed their localization in Leydig cells and the germ cells in the active and activating testis. In the inactive testis, BECN1 and LC3 ceased to be immunolocalized within the seminiferous tubules and the mRNA expression of both regulators decreased. Moreover, the expression of BECN1 and LC3 and also the apoptotic index were up regulated in testicular cultures subjected to nutritional stress. These results suggest a possible interaction between apoptosis and autophagy in the active and activating testis (characterized by high metabolic requirement and nutrient), where autophagy could promote survival over cell death. In the inactive testis, the absence of autophagic-related proteins might explain the massive loss of germ cells, suggesting that autophagy plays new and key role in the alterations of the seminiferous epithelium during photoregression.