Cesarean section is frequently performed for breech presentation; however, external cephalic version (ECV) is recommended as an alternative strategy to increase the likelihood of vaginal birth. Tocolytics agents are commonly administrated to improve ECV success, yet the comparative effectiveness of different regimes remains inadequately characterized. To systematically evaluate and compare the efficacy and safety of various tocolytic agents in facilitating successful ECV through a Bayesian network meta-analysis. Bayesian network meta-analysis. Bayesian network meta-analysis was performed using the "gemtc" package in R 4.1.1. Treatment effects were quantified by calculating odds ratios (ORs) with corresponding 95% credible intervals (CrIs). Surface under the cumulative ranking curve values were used to rank tocolytic agents according to ECV success rates, maternal outcomes, and adverse events. A total of sixteen RCTs encompassing 2,817 participants and six distinct tocolytic agents met the inclusion criteria. Compared with placebo, terbutaline (OR: 2.7, 95% CrI: 1.1-6.4) and ritodrine (OR: 2.2, 95% CrI: 1.4-3.9) were associated with significantly higher ECV success rates. Additionally, terbutaline was linked to an increased likelihood of vaginal delivery (OR: 2.0, 95% CrI: 1.0-2.9). Maternal adverse effects, including tachycardia, palpitations, hypotension, nausea, dizziness, and flushing, were more frequently reported with terbutaline, nifedipine, and nitroglycerin than with placebo. No statistically significant differences in fetal heart rate abnormalities were detected among the elevated interventions. Terbutaline and ritodrine appear to offer superior efficacy in improving ECV success compared with alternative tocolytic agents, albeit with a higher incidence of maternal side effects. Consequently, clinical decision-making regarding tocolytic use should be informed by a comprehensive assessment of the associated benefits and potential risks.
Background: External cephalic version (ECV) has been proved effectively in reducing the cesarean section rates, but the success rates of the procedure are uneven. Experiences of ECV with high success rate were concluded in this paper. And in order to evaluate the efficiency of the applied tocolytic agents, a corresponding bayesian-network meta-analysis was conducted.Methods: Through retrospective analysis of eighty-four single pregnant women with breech presentation near or at term who received ECV from Dalian Maternal and Child Health Care Hospital from April 2017 to November 2019, influence factors associated with the success rate of ECV were analyzed. Meanwhile, a bayesian-network meta-analysis including sixteen eligible randomized controlled trials (RCTs) about comparisons of five common tololytic agents and placebo with 3468 participants searched from Pubmed, Cochrane library and Embase databases until May 20, 2019 was conducted to identify the efficiency of ritodrine and terbutaline applied in the authors’ procedures. Results: The ECV procedures were conducted by a skilled obstetrician through strict selection of the candidates. Oral ritodrine, intravenous terbutaline in combination with epidual analgesia were applied as interventions. Success rate of ECV reached 90.48% (76/84) and the overall vaginal delivery rate is up to 88.16% (67/76). Only one patient reverted to breech presentation due to loose of the bellyband. Among the possible variables, amniotic fluid index were identified to have significantly relationship with the success rate of ECV. As the bayesian network meta-analysis proved: terbutaline, salbutamol and ritodrine played more important roles than nitroglycerine and nifedipine on the success rate of ECV. But salbutamol was found to have more common side effects than terbutaline and ritodrine.Conclusions: We conclude that factors influencing the success rate of ECV mainly include: 1. characteristics of the mothers and fetuses, 2. interventions, 3. skills of the surgeon. During ECV process, selection of patients with enough amniotic fluid and proper stature with no contraindications is essential. And a more detailed scoring standard according to the possible influence indicators of the mothers and fetuses for the feasibility of ECV should be set up in the future. Besides, application of terbutaline and ritodrine as tocolytic agents during ECV procedure were considered to be effective for increasing successful versions.