Dengue fever (DF) is one of the world's most disabling mosquito-borne diseases, with a variety of approaches available to model its spatial and temporal dynamics. This paper aims to identify and compare the different spatial and spatio-temporal Bayesian modelling methods that have been applied to DF and examine influential covariates that have been reportedly associated with the risk of DF. A systematic search was performed in December 2017, using Web of Science, Scopus, ScienceDirect, PubMed, ProQuest and Medline (via Ebscohost) electronic databases. The search was restricted to refereed journal articles published in English from January 2000 to November 2017. Thirty-one articles met the inclusion criteria. Using a modified quality assessment tool, the median quality score across studies was 14/16. The most popular Bayesian statistical approach to dengue modelling was a generalised linear mixed model with spatial random effects described by a conditional autoregressive prior. A limited number of studies included spatio-temporal random effects. Temperature and precipitation were shown to often influence the risk of dengue. Developing spatio-temporal random-effect models, considering other priors, using a dataset that covers an extended time period, and investigating other covariates would help to better understand and control DF transmission.
Spatial models are becoming more popular in time-to-event data analysis. Commonly, the intrinsic conditional autoregressive prior is placed on an area level frailty term to allow for correlation between areas. We considered a range of Bayesian Weibull and Cox semiparametric spatial models to describe a dataset on hospitalisation of dengue. This paper aimed to extend these two models, to evaluate the suitability of these models for estimation and prediction of the length of stay, compare different spatial priors, and determine factors that significantly affect the duration of hospital stay for dengue fever patients in the case study location, namely Wahidin hospital in Makassar, Indonesia. We compared two different models with three different spatial priors with respect to goodness of fit and generalisability. For all models considered, the Leroux prior was preferred over the intrinsic conditional autoregressive and independent priors, but Cox and Weibull versions had similar predictive performance, model fit, and results. Age and platelet count were negatively associated with the length of stay, while red blood cell count was positively associated with the length of stay of dengue patients at this hospital. Using appropriate Bayesian spatial survival models enables identification of factors that substantively affect the length of stay.
Stunting continues to be a significant health issue, particularly in developing nations, with Indonesia ranking third in prevalence in Southeast Asia. This research examined the risk of stunting and influencing factors in Indonesia by implementing various Bayesian spatial conditional autoregressive (CAR) models that include covariates. A total of 750 models were run, including five different Bayesian spatial CAR models (Besag-York-Mollie (BYM), CAR Leroux and three forms of localised CAR), with 30 covariate combinations and five different hyperprior combinations for each model. The Poisson distribution was employed to model the counts of stunting cases. After a comprehensive evaluation of all model selection criteria utilized, the Bayesian localised CAR model with three covariates were preferred, either allowing up to 2 clusters with a variance hyperprior of inverse-gamma (1, 0.1) or allowing 3 clusters with a variance hyperprior of inverse-gamma (1, 0.01). Poverty and recent low birth weight (LBW) births are significantly associated with an increased risk of stunting, whereas child diet diversity is inversely related to the risk of stunting. Model results indicated that Sulawesi Barat Province has the highest risk of stunting, with DKI Jakarta Province the lowest. These areas with high stunting require interventions to reduce poverty, LBW births and increase child diet diversity.
Stunting remains a persistent public health issue in Indonesia, exhibiting significant spatial and temporal variation. To address this, we employed a hierarchical Bayesian spatio-temporal localized Conditional Autoregressive (CAR) model that includes a clustering component to identify risk factors and estimate relative risk (RR) across 34 provinces from 2020 to 2022. A total of 480 models were evaluated, encompassing three variants of the Bayesian spatio-temporal localized CAR model, 32 covariate combinations, and five hyperprior settings. Assuming a Poisson likelihood for stunting counts, the optimal model was estimated using Markov Chain Monte Carlo methods and included two covariates, namely the poverty rate and the incidence of low birth weight, with up to five spatial clusters. Higher poverty levels and increased prevalence of low birth weight were significantly associated with elevated stunting risk among children under five. Spatio-temporal clustering patterns and the estimated relative risks of stunting varied across Indonesian provinces from 2020 to 2022. Nusa Tenggara Timur consistently ranked among the top three provinces with the highest risk (RR = 2.421 in 2020; 2.384 in 2021; 2.676 in 2022). The highest risk was observed in Sulawesi Barat in 2022 (RR = 2.768), while DKI Jakarta consistently showed the lowest (RR = 0.004).
30 May 2022 in Journal of Mathematics, Computations and Statistics
Indonesia merupakan negara dengan prevalensi balita stunting yang tinggi. Salah satu provinsi di Indonesia yang memiliki kasus stunting yang cukup tinggi adalah Provinsi Sulawesi Selatan. Penelitian mengenai kasus stunting dan faktor penyebabnya telah dilakukan. Namun, penelitian tersebut belum mengimplementasikan model Bayesian spasial Conditional Autoregressive (CAR). Penelitian ini bertujuan untuk mengetahui faktor yang mempengaruhi kejadian stunting di Provinsi Sulawesi Selatan dengan mengimplementasikan berbagai model Bayesian spasial CAR Leroux tanpa kovariat dan dengan memasukkan kovariat dalam model. Hasil penelitian menunjukkan bahwa model terbaik dalam memodelkan kasus stunting di Provinsi Sulawesi Selatan tahun 2020 adalah model Bayesian spasial CAR Leroux dengan hyperprior Inverse-Gamma IG(0,5;0,0005) dengan memasukkan kovariat persentase kemiskinan dan persentase balita 0-59 bulan gizi kurang. Persentase kemiskinan dan persentase balita 0-59 bulan gizi kurang berpengaruh positif terhadap kejadian stunting. Semakin tinggi persentase kemiskinan dan persentase balita 0-59 bulan dengan gizi kurang di suatu wilayah, semakin tinggi risiko stunting di wilayah tersebut. 50% kabupaten/kota di Provinsi Sulawesi Selatan berada dalam kategori risiko tinggi stunting. Kota Parepare merupakan kota dengan nilai risiko relatif (RR) tertinggi stunting, diikuti oleh Kabupaten Toraja dan Enrekang. Sebaliknya, Kabupaten Wajo merupakan kabupaten dengan RR terendah, diikuti oleh Kabupaten Luwu Timur dan Bone.Kata Kunci: Stunting, Bayesian, spasial CAR, Leroux Indonesia is a country with a high prevalence of stunting. One of the provinces in Indonesia that has a fairly high number of stunting cases is South Sulawesi Province. Research on stunting cases and their causes has been done. However, these researches have not implemented the Bayesian Spatial Conditional Autoregressive (CAR) model. This study aims to determine the factors that influence the incidence of stunting in South Sulawesi Province by implementing various Bayesian spatial CAR Leroux models with and without covariates included in the model. The results showed that the best model for modeling stunting cases in South Sulawesi Province in 2020 is the Bayesian spatial CAR Leroux model with hyperprior Inverse-Gamma IG (0.5;0.0005) by including the covariates of the percentage of poverty and the percentage of children under five 0-59 months of malnutrition. The percentage of poverty and the percentage of children under five 0-59 months of malnutrition have a positive effect on the incidence of stunting. The higher the percentage of poverty and the percentage of children aged 0-59 months with malnutrition in an area, the higher the risk of stunting in that area. 50% of districts/cities in South Sulawesi Province are in the high-risk category of stunting. Parepare City is the city with the highest Relative Risk (RR) value for stunting, followed by Toraja and Enrekang Regencies. On the other hand, Wajo Regency is the district with the lowest RR, followed by Luwu Timur and Bone Regencies.Keywords: Stunting, Bayesian, spatial CAR, Leroux
The Covid-19 has exploded in the world since late 2019. South Sulawesi Province has the highest number of Covid-19 cases outside Java Island in Indonesia. This paper aims to determine the most suitable Bayesian spatial conditional autoregressive (CAR) localised models in modeling the relative risk (RR) of Covid-19 in South Sulawesi Province, Indonesia. Bayesian spatial CAR localised models with different hyperpriors were performed adopting a Poisson distribution for the confirmed Covid-19 counts to examine the grouping of Covid-19 cases. All confirmed cases of Covid-19 (19 March 2020-18 February 2021) for each district were included. Overall, Bayesian CAR localised model with G = 5 with a hyperprior IG (1, 0.1) is the preferred model to estimate the RR based on the two criteria used. Makassar and Toraja Utara have the highest and the lowest RR, respectively. The group formed in the localised model is influenced by the magnitude of the mean and variance in the count data between areas. Using suitable Bayesian spatial CAR localised models enables the identification of high-risk areas of Covid-19 cases. This localised model could be applied in other case studies.