The number of published papers about membrane distillation (MD) has been growing exponentially and many evaluation and performance criteria are used to measure it; but, there is no established tradition or evaluation standard for them. This makes the evaluations difficult to compare, or even incomplete. This paper presents therefore a comprehensive critical review and clarification of the major evaluation criteria for the MD components and systems, aimed to offer some recommendations for their more uniform usage, provide clearer quantitative goals in research and industrial use, and to facilitate more correct and honest representations and comparisons. General description and models of MD are presented first, followed by criteria used to characterize the membranes, and performance criteria to evaluate the distillate production rate, product quality, energy efficiency (including conventional energy performance criteria and exergy performance criteria), transport process, and long-time operation. Since exergy analysis of the process is less known, a detailed example is presented.
An experimental desalination system coupling a vacuum membrane distillation (VMD) unit and a vacuum tube solar heat collection (SHC) unit was developed and tested. The parametric sensitivity of the VMD unit performance was investigated first using an electric heater as the heat source, and then the whole system was examined using solar heat. It was revealed that hot feed temperatures higher than 65°C and cold-side absolute pressure lower than 0.02 MPa are favorable for high trans-membrane flux. The startup time of the SHC-VMD system was very short, less than 10 min. The VMD unit ran intermittently for 305 h in five months, individually or together with the solar heat system, showing good suitability to unsteady solar energy and to the intermittent off-and-on operation mode. The average trans-membrane flux in the experiments of SHC-VMD combined system was about 4 kg/(m2 h), and the specific heat consumption was around 750 kWh/m3.
Enhanced geothermal systems (EGS) extract heat from underground hot dry rock (HDR) by first fracturing the HDR and then circulating a geofluid (typically water) into it and bringing the heated geofluid to a power plant to generate electricity. This study focuses on analysis, examination, and comparison of leading geothermal power plant configurations with a geofluid temperature from 200 to 800 °C, and also analyzes the embodied energy of EGS surface power plants. The power generation analysis is focused on flash type cycles for using subcritical geofluid (374 °C). Key findings of this study include: (i) double-flash plants have 24.3%–29.0% higher geofluid effectiveness than single-flash ones, and 3%–10% lower specific embodied energy; (ii) the expansion type plants have geofluid effectiveness > 750 kJ/kg, significantly higher than flash type plants (geofluid effectiveness < 300 kJ/kg) and the specific embodied energy is lower; (iii) to increase the turbine outlet vapor fraction from 0.75 to 0.90, we include superheating by geofluid but that reduces the geofluid effectiveness by 28.3%; (iv) for geofluid temperatures above 650 °C, double-expansion plants have a 2% higher geofluid effectiveness and 5%–8% lower specific embodied energy than single-expansion ones.