Long-term water planning is increasingly challenging, since hydrologic conditions appear to be changing from the recently observed past and water needs in many locales are highly relative to existing and easily developed supplies. Globally coordinated policymaking to address climate change also faces large uncertainties regarding underlying conditions and possible responses, making traditional prediction-based planning approaches to be inadequate for the purpose. Methods for Decision Making under Deep Uncertainty (DMDU) can be useful for addressing long-term policy challenges associated with multifaceted, nonlinear, natural and socio-economic systems. This chapter presents two case studies using Robust Decision Making (RDM). The first describes how RDM was used as part of a seven-state collaboration to identify water management strategies to reduce vulnerabilities in the Colorado River Basin. The second illustrates how RDM could be used to develop robust investment strategies for the Green Climate Fund (GCF)—an international global institution charged with making investments supporting a global transition toward more sustainable energy systems that will reduce GHG emissions. Both case studies describe the development of robust strategies that are adaptive, in that they identify both near-term decisions and guidance for how these responses should change or be augmented as the future unfolds.
1 November 2016 in Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management
Best management practices (BMPs) such as bioretentions, dry and wet ponds, porous pavement, and many other methods are widely used to reduce the runoff volume and the concentration of sediments and nutrients in the runoff. Numerical models are used to develop and assess water quality management plans that, among others, include BMPs. Those models need to take into account the BMP effectiveness to remove pollutants, being a function of the volume of daily runoff, in order to estimate their performance under a range of different climate scenarios. Circumventing the lack of monitoring data, this study used the Environmental Protection Agency’s system for urban stormwater treatment and analysis integration model (SUSTAIN) to run 22 years (1984–2005) of runoff data from the Patuxent River (Maryland) through seven types of BMPs. It was found that BMP effectiveness decreases sooner, steeper, and deeper with increasing sizes of storm events than assumed in the Chesapeake Bay Phase 5 watershed model. At a ...
Climate change may affect water quality implementation plans, but uncertainty complicates any appropriate response. This study explores how Robust Decision Making (RDM) can help make water quality plans more resilient to climate and other changes.
The North-America Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) has brought together the economies of Canada, Mexico, and the US into forming one of the largest trading blocs worldwide (within the top CO2 emitters). However, the current global protectionist discourse threatens the agreement. This paper analyzes the energy and energy-related CO2 emission relationships between NAFTA countries in 2014 to gain insights into the climate change implications of current integration and the possible cancelation of the agreement. The analysis is performed with a multi-regional version of the multi-factor energy input–output model. The results show that NAFTA has not built a single integrated energy system, though it has helped reduce energy-related CO2 emissions. Moreover, if NAFTA is not revoked, further integration would depend on the capacity of the Mexican energy sector to converge to the performance of its trade partners’ energy sectors. Conversely, a broken deal would induce negative environmental externalities.
This report describes insights about exposures from natural hazards now and in the future, as well as gaps in data that, if filled, could improve the nation's ability to assess infrastructure risk and improve infrastructure resilience.