Grate firing is the most common technology used for combustion of municipal solid waste. The more recently developed fluidized bed (FB) combustion is rarely employed for this purpose. The present work compares the technical properties of the two devices to find out why FB has not been more used, considering the recent importance of waste-to-energy. Several drawbacks of FB, the need for fuel preparation and bed material consumption, play a role, but these features also have advantages: combustion is improved by the sorted fuel and less ashes. Silica sand as a bed material has the positive property of being an alkali scavenger. If replaced by an oxygen carrier (e.g. ilmenite) the scavenging effect increases, and, in addition, oxygen carriers even out the non-combusted gaseous fields in the furnace, which improves combustion and allows higher steam data at a given corrosion level. There are other advantages of FB, such as end-superheaters in the circulation loop, heated by the bed material. However, also the environmental performance and energy efficiency of grate firing has been improved, and several advanced solutions have been proposed. In conclusion, it is not clear which of the devices that is the better one. An economic evaluation is made, based on available literature information, but still there is no clear winner.
Chemical looping combustion (CLC) has unique potential for avoiding the large costs and energy penalties of existing CO2 capture technologies. Oxygen is transferred to the fuel using an oxygen carrier, thus avoiding contact between air and fuel. Consequently, the combustion products, CO2 and H2O, come in a separate stream, and more or less pure CO2 is obtained after condensation of H2O. CLC is normally conceived as a dual fluidized bed process, with high gas velocities in an air reactor driving the circulation, similar to circulating fluidized beds (CFBs), except that the material is led to a fuel reactor before being returned to the air reactor. Crucial for the process is the properties of the oxygen carrier and that circulation is sufficient to transfer needed oxygen and heat to the fuel reactor. Comprehensive literature shows successful use of many oxygen carriers in sustained pilot operation. In contrast, the need for reaching adequate circulation in an industrial-scale system has been given little consideration. Normally, a system similar to CFB boilers is assumed to give sufficient circulation. However, literature data indicate that circulation in CFB boilers is 5–50% of what is needed. Measures to provide sufficient circulation may cause difficulties, such as erosion or bed material loss in the cyclone. Here, a circulation system based on collection of the downflow of particles along the walls is proposed, and a design of a 200 MWth combined CLC–CFB boiler based on this principle is presented. Further, operational strategies and the need for flexibility are discussed. The design is focused on making an industrial-scale demonstration boiler, which can be used in CLC operation with different oxygen carriers and different fuels and that can explore different operational strategies to find optimal conditions. It is recommended that the upscaling of the technology aims directly at the industrial scale.
A summary is given on the development of fluidized bed conversion (combustion and gasification) of solid fuels. First, gasification is mentioned, following the line of development from the Winkler gasifier to recent designs. The combustors were initially bubbling beds, which were found unsuitable for combustion of coal because of various drawbacks, but they proved more useful for biomass where these drawbacks were absent. Instead, circulating fluidized bed boilers became the most important coal converters, whose design now is quite mature, and presently the increments in size and efficiency are the most important development tasks. The new modifications of these conversion devices are related to CO2 capture. Proposed methods with this purpose, involving fluidized bed, are single-reactor systems like oxy-fuel combustion, and dual-reactor systems, including also indirect biomass gasifiers.