Successful upstream collusion must satisfy both the incentive constraint (keeping cartel members in line) and the compensation constraint (preventing lawsuits from downstream firms). Our analysis shows that there is a non-monotonic and inverted U-shaped relationship between cartel incidence and upstream market concentration when both constraints are taken into account. Furthermore, the inverted U-shape becomes more pronounced as compensation for downstream firms increases. Although compensation reduces the harm of upstream collusion to social welfare and consumer surplus, a small amount of compensation facilitates upstream collusion. These findings have important implications for antitrust policy and market regulation.