Significance: This article concerns the control of competence for bacterial genetic transformation. Competence is transient in the human pathogen Streptococcus pneumoniae , involving the specific expression of ∼100 genes that are turned ON suddenly and OFF almost as abruptly. Although the mechanism rendering all cells in a culture simultaneously competent is well understood, how competence stops has remained unknown. Here, we unravel the mechanism of shut-off, describing the discovery that a key recombination protein, DprA, exerts a negative control on competence through direct, physical interaction with the master regulator of competence, the response regulator ComE, to abolish transcription from ComE-activated promoters.

Phosphorylated Spo0A is a master regulator of stationary phase development in the model bacterium Bacillus subtilis, controlling the formation of spores, biofilms, and cells competent for transformation. We have monitored the rate of transcription of the spo0A gene during growth in sporulation medium using promoter fusions to firefly luciferase. This rate increases sharply during transient diauxie-like pauses in growth rate and then declines as growth resumes. In contrast, the rate of transcription of an rRNA gene decreases and increases in parallel with the growth rate, as expected for stable RNA synthesis. The growth pause-dependent bursts of spo0A transcription, which reflect the activity of the spo0A vegetative promoter, are largely independent of all known regulators of spo0A transcription. Evidence is offered in support of a “passive regulation” model in which RNA polymerase stops transcribing rRNA genes during growth pauses, thus becoming available for the transcription of spo0A. We show that the bursts are followed by the production of phosphorylated Spo0A, and we propose that they represent initial responses to stress that bring the average cell closer to the thresholds for transition to bimodally expressed developmental responses. Measurement of the numbers of cells expressing a competence marker before and after the bursts supports this hypothesis. In the absence of ppGpp, the increase in spo0A transcription that accompanies the entrance to stationary phase is delayed and sporulation is markedly diminished. In spite of this, our data contradicts the hypothesis that sporulation is initiated when a ppGpp-induced depression of the GTP pool relieves repression by CodY. We suggest that, while the programmed induction of sporulation that occurs in stationary phase is apparently provoked by increased flux through the phosphorelay, bet-hedging stochastic transitions to at least competence are induced by bursts in transcription. A hallmark of the intensively studied model organism Bacillus subtilis is its ability to enter developmental pathways: forming spores, acquiring the ability to take up environmental DNA, and the formation of biofilms. These pathways are dependent on the transcription factor Spo0A. All are expressed heterogeneously across populations of cells and exhibit characteristic rates of transition to the developmental pathways depending on environmental signals. We have monitored the rate of transcription of spo0A during growth and have detected unexpected fluctuations that correlate with pauses in the growth rate. We present support for a model in which the release of RNA polymerase from transcription of ribosomal RNA genes during the growth pauses permits increased transcription of spo0A. We show that these bursts in transcription increase the still-rare probability of transition to the transformable state, suggesting that this transition is limited by the transcription rate of spo0A. In contrast, it has been shown that the programmed development of spores is determined by the rate of phosphorylation of Spo0A. Thus there are two modes of developmental transition. We also show that a popular hypothesis for the initiation of spore formation by release of repression by the protein CodY is incorrect.

Bacterial Rap family proteins have been most extensively studied in Bacillus subtilis, where they regulate activities including sporulation, genetic competence, antibiotic expression, and the movement of the ICEBs1 transposon. One subset of Rap proteins consists of phosphatases that control B. subtilis and B. anthracis sporulation by dephosphorylating the response regulator Spo0F. The mechanistic basis of Rap phosphatase activity was unknown. Here we present the RapH-Spo0F X-ray crystal structure, which shows that Rap proteins consist of a 3-helix bundle and a tetratricopeptide repeat domain. Extensive biochemical and genetic functional studies reveal the importance of the observed RapH-Spo0F interactions, including the catalytic role of a glutamine in the RapH 3-helix bundle that inserts into the Spo0F active site. We show that in addition to dephosphorylating Spo0F, RapH can antagonize sporulation by sterically blocking phosphoryl transfer to and from Spo0F. Our structure-function analysis of the RapH-Spo0F interaction identified Rap protein residues critical for Spo0F phosphatase activity. This information enabled us to assign Spo0F phosphatase activity to a Rap protein based on sequence alone, which was not previously possible. Finally, as the ultimate test of our newfound understanding of the structural requirements for Rap phosphatase function, a non-phosphatase Rap protein that inhibits the binding of the response regulator ComA to DNA was rationally engineered to dephosphorylate Spo0F. In addition to revealing the mechanistic basis of response regulator dephosphorylation by Rap proteins, our studies support the previously proposed T-loop-Y allostery model of receiver domain regulation that restricts the aromatic “switch” residue to an internal position when the β4-α4 loop adopts an active-site proximal conformation. A phosphorelay signal transduction pathway regulates sporulation in numerous Bacillus species including the genetic model organism, B. subtilis, and the causative agent of anthrax, B. anthracis. Histidine kinases initiate the flow of phosphoryl groups along the phosphorelay pathway, which then shuttles them to a downstream response-regulator transcription factor called Spo0A. Ultimately, sporulation is governed by the cellular concentration of phosphorylated Spo0A. In numerous Bacillus species, Rap phosphatases function in opposition to the histidine kinases, inhibiting Spo0A activation by dephosphorylating an intermediate pathway protein called Spo0F. Here we present the structure of a Rap protein, RapH, in complex with Spo0F, as determined by X-ray crystallography. The RapH–Spo0F structure, along with biochemical and genetic studies, reveals the mechanism of Rap-protein-mediated Spo0F dephosphorylation. We used information gleaned from our structure–function analysis, first, to assign Spo0F phosphatase activity to an uncharacterized Rap protein, RapJ, on the basis of sequence alone, and, second, to engineer Spo0F phosphatase activity de novo into a non-phosphatase Rap protein, RapF. We found that in addition to dephosphorylating Spo0F, Rap proteins can inhibit the sporulation phosphorelay by sterically blocking the transfer of phosphoryl groups to and from Spo0F. Ultimately, new classes of drugs might be developed that disrupt the flow of phosphoryl groups along phosphotransfer signaling pathways by mimicking the antagonistic effects of Rap proteins on response regulators.

Summary: Since 1996, induction of competence for genetic transformation of Streptococcus pneumoniae is known to be controlled by the ComD/ComE two‐component regulatory system. The mechanism of induction is generally described as involving ComD autophosphorylation, transphosphorylation of ComE and transcriptional activation by ComE∼P of the early competence (com) genes, including comX which encodes the competence‐specific σ^X. However, none of these features has been experimentally established. Here we document the autokinase activity of ComD proteins in vitro, and provide an estimate of the stoichiometry of ComD and ComE in vivo. We report that a phosphorylmimetic mutant, ComE^D58E, constructed because of the failure to detect transphosphorylation of purified ComE in vitro, displays full spontaneous competence in ΔcomD cells, an that in vitro ComE^D58E exhibits significantly improved binding affinity for P_comCDE. We also provide evidence for a differential transcriptional activation and repression of P_comCDE and P_comX. Altogether, these data support the model of ComE∼P‐dependent activation of transcription. Finally, we establish that ComE antagonizes expression of the early com genes and propose that the rapid deceleration of transcription from P_comCDE observed even in cells lacking σ^X is due to the progressive accumulation of ComE, which outcompetes ComE∼P.

Transformation promotes genome plasticity in bacteria via RecA-driven homologous recombination. In the Gram-positive human pathogen Streptococcus pneumoniae, the transformasome a multiprotein complex, internalizes, protects, and processes transforming DNA to generate chromosomal recombinants. Double-stranded DNA is internalized as single strands, onto which the transformation-dedicated DNA processing protein A (DprA) ensures the loading of RecA to form presynaptic filaments. We report that the structure of DprA consists of the association of a sterile alpha motif domain and a Rossmann fold and that DprA forms tail-to-tail dimers. The isolation of DprA self-interaction mutants revealed that dimerization is crucial for the formation of nucleocomplexes in vitro and for genetic transformation. Residues important for DprA-RecA interaction also were identified and mutated, establishing this interaction as equally important for transformation. Positioning of key interaction residues on the DprA structure revealed an overlap of DprA-DprA and DprA-RecA interaction surfaces. We propose a model in which RecA interaction promotes rearrangement or disruption of the DprA dimer, enabling the subsequent nucleation of RecA and its polymerization onto ssDNA.