Construction operations are becoming increasingly complex, necessitating a greater need for collaboration. Building information modeling (BIM) aids enhanced project visualization and collaboration. The extant literature has mainly focused on model ownership, intellectual property, and data security issues with regard to contractual issues associated with BIM implementation. There has been a lack of focus on the expectations set out in engineering, procurement, and construction (EPC) contracts with regard to envisaged BIM uses (dimensions), making BIM implementation superficial rather than purposive. This study identified BIM dimension-specific contract provisions (BDSCP) to address this gap. To accomplish this, a literature review was undertaken; this was followed by a qualitative inductive study involving 12 international experts from industry and academia to identify BDSCPs. The resulting 28 BDSCPs highlight focus areas with regard to drafting contracts and will assist stakeholders in realizing the benefits of BIM implementation.
1 February 2024 in Journal of Legal Affairs and Dispute Resolution in Engineering and Construction
Purpose: This study aims to analyze and understand mutual relationships between lean and agile enabling factors in the context of the construction domain and put forth the most driving and dependent enablers for a hybrid lean–agile system (HLAS). Design/methodology/approach: A threefold research flow is adopted. First, the content analysis of literature stemmed from the identification of preliminary enablers (n = 26). Second, a questionnaire survey (n = 101) is administered to downsize enablers to ten using the relative importance index. Further, in the third phase, interpretive structural modeling (ISM) and the cross-impact matrix multiplication applied to classification analysis were performed amid the ten key enablers through pairwise interactions from subject matter experts (n = 19). Hierarchical representation of enablers has been presented, which facilitates a conceptual model for application in the construction industry. Findings: The ISM model demonstrates a three leveled classification structure that showcases direct and transitive relationships among various enablers. “Use of project management tools” is the driving enabler, followed by “collaborative and common data platform working” and “institution of team training” are critical enablers to HLAS adoption. Originality/value: A structured way of identification of interdependent among lean–agile is a vital unique contribution to this study. The results serve as a knowledge base for practical adoption of HLAS and may prove to be influential in developing a framework for easier adoption in developing countries.
6 June 2022 in Construction Economics and Building
This study aims to identify the crucial barriers to interface management and understand the interdependencies in Large Infrastructure Construction Projects (LICP). Three-pronged sequential explanatory mixed methods research is adopted comprising a structured survey of experts (n=102) and semi-structured interviews (n=13). Subsequently, interpretive structural modelling (ISM) integrated with fuzzy protocol is used to analyse pairwise interrelationships among these factors. A ‘Multi-layered IM barrier’ model is developed with ‘Process related issues,’ 'Misaligned incentives among project stakeholders' and 'Frequent Change Orders' as the manifested barriers. On the other hand, this study also prioritized the barriers and classified them as driving, linking, and independent. The outcome of this study presents the interdependence of barriers and classification of barriers, focusing on proactive action on driving barriers, which is crucial to the knowledge of interface management. The impact position of LICP with the identified project issues can be compared against ‘Multi-layered IM barriers’ and can help project teams better strategize IM by focusing on essential barriers. In addition, such exercises can improve the coordination among participants in construction projects. Using a structured approach to identifying interdependencies among barriers to IM is a significant original contribution by the study.
1 May 2022 in Journal of Legal Affairs and Dispute Resolution in Engineering and Construction
Building information modeling (BIM) can potentially enhance project visibility, improve productivity, and promote shared understanding among various construction project stakeholders. The benefits of BIM implementation in a construction project may remain a distant dream if there is no structured way to select a BIM-capable contractor. Existing studies have focused on identifying BIM prequalification (PQ) criteria in countries where BIM implementation is advanced. Therefore, considering the early stages of BIM adoption in many developing countries, this study identified the mandatory and desirable BIM-specific PQ criteria to be included in the short, medium, and long term, considering the perspectives of clients, contractors, consultants, and academicians in the context of engineering, procurement, and construction—turnkey (EPC–Turnkey) projects. Objectives were achieved by identifying the relevant BIM-specific PQ criteria through content analysis of the literature and interviews with experts predominantly from countries where BIM implementation is nascent. Following the literature review and interviews, a questionnaire survey of globally spread stakeholders assessed their extent of agreement or disagreement on including a criterion as a BIM-specific PQ criterion. The results showed that, while all the identified BIM-specific PQ criteria were rated on the agreement side, most respondents preferred including the criteria as desirable rather than mandatory, with their inclusion in the short and medium term (less than five years). In terms of stakeholder perspectives, there was no significant difference between the agreement levels of stakeholder groups. However, considering the overall responses, realizing the need to provide time for holistic BIM diffusion, the practitioners preferred a middle path to include the BIM-specific PQ criteria as desirable rather than mandatory within a timeline of the next five years. The study results can help project stakeholders assess bidders’ BIM implementation capability by considering the conflicting dual needs of BIM implementation urgency and the varying extents of BIM percolation among contractor organizations.
1 November 2022 in Journal of Legal Affairs and Dispute Resolution in Engineering and Construction
There is a long history of court judgments in the construction sector, providing a wealth of knowledge that can guide contract parties in preempting claims and disputes in construction projects. However, knowledge from case law findings does not seem to percolate to day-to-day contract management activities. This anecdotal statement needs empirical verification. Thus, the current study attempted to understand the extent of case-law-based legal knowledge percolation in day-to-day contract management and its impact on the dispute resolution climate. The study highlighted the gap between the need for and availability of case-law-based training/knowledge using data from India. There were four major observations from the research. First, questionnaire survey results highlighted the fact that engineers and managers in construction projects acknowledge the inevitability of legal awareness for day-to-day contract management. While about 72% of the respondents (76 out of 106) agreed that case-law-based training could have helped in managing disputes better, only 10% (11 out of 106 respondents) reported that their organizations offer regular case-law-based knowledge and training. Moreover, 65% of the respondents (69 out of 106) either confirmed that their organizations do not maintain a case-law learning repository or they are unaware of its availability. Therefore, the second observation is that there is a shortfall in avenues that help professionals gain case-law-based knowledge from training. Although pure experience-based learning can lead to a risky trial and error approach, opportunities for self-learning are also muted. Third, by highlighting a growing trend of expenses incurred for the arbitration and litigation of construction disputes—in other words, legalization—the study highlighted the importance of the development and administration of case-law-based professional training programs. Last, the study also illustrated the potential for case laws to guide engineers and managers in their day-to-day contract management activities. The findings from the study can help the construction industry collaborate closely with researchers and academicians to move a step closer to making legal knowledge easily accessible to contract managers and help them make decisions that can withstand legal scrutiny.