Recent portrayals of ancient Egypt in popular culture have renewed attention concerning the historical accuracy of how race and racism appear in representations of antiquity. Historians of the antiquity have robustly dismissed racist claims of whitewashing or blackwashing historical and cultural material in both scholarship and in popular culture. The 2017 video game Assassin’s Creed: Origins is a noteworthy site to examine this debate, as the game was designed with the assistance of historians and cultural experts, presenting players with an “historically accurate” ancient Egypt. Yet, if race is a fantasy, as Karen Fields and Barbara Fields’ “racecraft” articulates, then what historians have speculated in their study of race and racism are presentations of a proto-racecraft, borrowing from historian Benjamin Isaac. This essay argues that Assassin’s Creed: Origins racecrafts through the paradigm of historical speculation. As historians have speculated on meanings and operations of “race” and racism in ancient Egypt, Origins has made those speculations visible through its depiction of a racially diverse Ptolemaic Egypt. Yet, this racecraft is paradoxically good, as the game does so to push back against the hegemony of whiteness and whitewashing in contemporary popular culture.
Dan Trachtenberg’s 2022 film Prey subverts the science fiction Predator film franchise by placing the infamous alien hunter in early 18th-century North America and reducing it to a secondary figure that interacts with indigenous wildlife, French fur trappers, and the Comanche people. Instead, Trachtenberg, alongside Indigenous cultural consultants, centers Prey on Naru — a young Comanche woman portrayed by Indigenous actress Amber Midthunder — on a transformative journey of Indigenous identity, self-sovereignty, and resistance against alien and human colonial forces. The film received widespread acclaim from audiences and critics, including Indigenous critics who praised its portrayal of Comanche ways of life. While some argue that Prey’s release on a streaming platform limits its potential to challenge mainstream Indigenous stereotypes, this study focuses on how the film disrupts cinematic conventions by centering Indigenous storymaking, authentic cultural practices, and resistance to colonial domination, offering a more nuanced and respectful portrayal of Indigeneity. Drawing on scholarship in film studies, Indigenous studies, and especially Indigenous science fiction, this study contends that Prey juxtaposes Indigeneity and Indigenous cultural elements with science fiction tropes, offering a creative reimagining of both past and present while providing a poignant commentary on the intersections of identity, storymaking, and resistance. This fusion is what makes the film so compelling: it tells a culturally grounded Indigenous story of a young woman overcoming challenges to become a warrior hunter, all within the action-packed universe of the Predator . By incorporating Indigenous storymaking within the SF framework, Prey becomes a powerful medium for subverting dominant cultural narratives and ideologies, representing a progressive step towards more inclusive and accurate storytelling in popular media.