Pentaerythritol tetranitrate (PETN) is a commonly used high explosive (HE) in detonators. Often, surrogate or “mock” materials are used in place of HE for mechanical tests, proofing out equipment, or developing new diagnostics. However, there is no commonly accepted mock for PETN. A good mock should match at least one physical property of the target material, and ideally mimic multiple thermal and mechanical properties. Here, we investigate several molecular crystals to evaluate their efficacy in mocking PETN density, melting point, elastic modulus, hardness, plastic deformation, and fracture behavior. Materials were tested with a combination of calorimetry and nanoindentation. Two materials, 2,4,6-trifluorobenzoic acid (246 TFBA) and mesoerythritol, were downselected for detailed indentation study after the initial round of screening experiments, both were found to mimic PETN mechanical behavior quite well, 246 TFBA closer to PETN in most properties (hardness, modulus, and density) than erythritol, but erythritol having advantages in relative cost and matching the onset of yield. Depending on the desired implementation of the mock, one material may be preferred over the other, but both have potential as generic mocks for PETN. Nanoindentation is demonstrated as a versatile tool to provide rapid screening of these materials’ mechanical properties.
Handling sensitivity is an important property to assess when working with explosive samples and can be measured using a variety of tests, including drop-weight impact sensitivity. There exists a longstanding interest in the explosives community on the importance of measurable chemical, physical, and mechanical properties of explosives in impact sensitivity. However, most recent work in this area has explored chemical attributes rather than physical and mechanical properties of explosives. In this study, we measure hardness of explosive samples of pentaerythritol tetranitrate and Sylgard binder (XTX) during the curing process. The samples have been characterized for particle morphology through scanning electron microscopy and handling sensitivity through drop-weight impact testing. The relative importance of states of cure, methods of curing, morphology, and age of material are discussed. The data indicate that although there is a notable difference in morphology and mechanical properties for the samples as the polymer-bonded mixtures cure, the resulting changes to mechanical properties have a minimal effect on the sensitivity of the XTX.
Handling sensitivity is the first property that must be evaluated in order to work safely with explosive samples, most commonly evaluated using drop-weight impact sensitivity. In addition to safety, there is a longstanding scientific interest in the explosives community to connect, if possible, chemical, physical, and mechanical properties to impact sensitivity. Most mechanical characterization of explosives has historically been done on plastic-bonded composites containing conventional explosives, but recently nanoindentation has been used to probe the mechanical response of pure explosive single crystals. In this study, we employ nanoindentation techniques to measure hardness and elastic modulus of a variety of explosives in order to search for correlations to drop-weight impact sensitivity. Both primary and secondary explosives are studied, along with mechanical behavior and sensitivity trends.
Creating or moving dislocations is the first step to dissipating mechanical energy via plastic deformation under contact loading. In molecular crystals there is both a lattice that defines crystal orientation and a relative orientation of the basis of the molecules. We define a normalization parameter which relates strain at yield, the hardness of the bulk crystal, and a distance parameter analogous to a Burgers vector that nominally predicts the relative ease of initiating plasticity in this broad class of materials. Analyzing the yield behavior of 10 different molecular crystals of varying space groups shows the inter-molecular orientation predicts the experimentally observed applied stress needed to nucleate dislocations. When molecules are oriented ‘parallel’ relative to one another the normalized maximum shear stress at the onset of plasticity is on the order of 3–5 times lower than when molecules within the crystal are ‘anti-parallel’, and molecules with a more equiaxed shape fall in between these bounds. This provides an initial indication of a structural feature which predicts the relative ease of initiating plasticity during contact loading in molecular crystals.
Due to the violent reaction potential of high explosives, in tests where a reaction is not desired, it can be safe and convenient to use an inert mock that can mimic relevant properties of the associated explosive. Use of mock materials is well-established in explosives work, but most existing mocks are generally meant to mimic only one or two properties of a given explosive, potentially failing to match the explosive in other critical ways. Recently, there has been interest in developing robust thermomechanical mocks for many common explosives. Here, eleven materials are systematically chosen and investigated as potential thermomechanical mocks for TATB, the explosive component of PBX 9502. DSC, nanoindentation, and compression testing are used to narrow down to most appropriate mocks and identify their advantages and limitations. Hardness and elastic modulus are reported for the first time for the molecular crystals iodoanthranilic acid, hexamine, melamine, and trithiolane dioxide, and the crystal structure is reported for the first time for the molecular crystals iodoanthranilic acid and iodosalicylic acid.