Scott Fernie

Dr. Scott Fernie


Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

24Years (2003-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
1 April 2003 in International Journal of Project Management
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
SFScott Fernie
Scott Fernie
SGStuart D Green
Stuart D Green
SWStephanie J Weller
Stephanie J Weller
RNRobert Newcombe
Robert Newcombe

1 March 2017 in Building Research & Information
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
ADAndrew Dainty
Andrew Dainty
Roine LeiringerRoine Leiringer
Roine Leiringer
SFScott Fernie
Scott Fernie
CHChris Harty
Chris Harty
The need for technological and administrative innovation is a recurrent theme in the UK construction-reform agenda, but generic improvement recipes are beginning to give way to a more focused prescription: building information modelling (BIM). The current strategy is to mandate the use of BIM for government projects as a way of integrating the design, construction and operation of publicly procured buildings. This aspiration represents a partial turn away from a focus on managerialist agendas towards a belief in the power of digital practices to achieve the aspiration of integrated working, collaboration and innovation, a trend that is being reflected globally in relation to both national and firm-level policy interventions. This paper subjects this so-called ‘BIM revolution’ to critical scrutiny. By drawing on theories of the digital divide, a critical discourse is developed around the ways in which political reform agendas centred on BIM might not stimulate innovation on a wider scale, but could act to disenfranchise small firms that are unable (or unwilling) to engage with them. This critical analysis presents important new research questions around the technocratic optimism that pervades the current reform discourse, the trajectory of industry development that it creates and the policy process itself.

1 July 2005 in Construction Management and Economics
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
SGStuart D. Green
Stuart D. Green
SFScott Fernie
Scott Fernie
SWStephanie Weller
Stephanie Weller
Current recipes for learning across business sectors too often fail to recognize the embedded and contextual nature of management practice. The existing literature gives little emphasis to the symbiotic relationship between supply chain management and the broader dynamics of context. The aerospace and construction sectors are selected for comparison on the basis that they are so different. The UK aerospace sector has undergone extensive consolidation as a result of the imperatives of global competitive pressures. In contrast, the construction industry has experienced decades of fragmentation and remains highly localized. An increasing proportion of output in the aerospace sector occurs within a small number of large, globally orientated firms. In contrast, construction output is dominated by a plethora of small firms with high levels of subcontracting and a widespread reliance on self‐employment. These differences have fundamental implications for the way that supply chain management is understood and implemented in the two sectors. Semi‐structured interviews with practitioners from both sectors support the contention that supply chain management is more established in aerospace than construction. The introduction of prime contracting and the increasing use of framework agreements within the construction sector potentially provide a much more supportive climate for supply chain management than has traditionally prevailed. However, progress depends upon an improved continuity of workload under such arrangements.

10 July 2007 in Engineering, Construction and Architectural Management
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
SFScott Fernie
Scott Fernie
ATAnthony Thorpe
Anthony Thorpe
Purpose – The purpose of the paper is to explore the process of change within organisations in the construction sector related to the content of change called for by reformers such as Egan, Latham, Constructing Excellence and the “rethinking construction” movement. The concept of supply chain management is used within the research to facilitate this kind of exploration. Design/methodology/approach – The broad framework adopted in the paper is contextual in nature and informed by structuration theory and new institutionalism. The approach followed is a case study method that looks for literal replication across a number of cases. Findings – Supply chain management is found to be both synonymous with the concept of partnering and particularly problematic for organisations to implement within the construction sector due to specific contextual factors. Research limitations/implications – All methodological positions have limitations. Like all research this piece of work is the product of choices that could have been different and achieved different outcomes. Originality/value – The findings support a view that contextual approaches provide greater insight into the problematic nature of change in the construction sector and concerns regarding the development of a robust, relevant and sustainable agenda for change within the sector.

1 March 2006 in Building Research & Information
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
SFScott Fernie
Scott Fernie
RLRoine Leiringer
Roine Leiringer
TTTony Thorpe
Tony Thorpe
Change within the construction sector has been a central concern of governments and a select few private-sector clients for a considerable time. The discourse of change emanating from organizations concerned with reform in the construction sector reflects these ongoing concerns for change in the sector. The underlying assumptions of the content of change and appropriate change mechanisms in the UK are critically examined and challenged. In particular, the limitations of measurement and best practice are explored. The allegiance to approaches based on measurement and best practice is acontextual, unreflective and insufficient in providing wholly reliable explanations for the relationship between practice and performance. Claims for the use of measurement and best practice by the reform movement must therefore be understood to have limitations and their use approached with caution. The emphasis on best practice is also understood to direct attention away from understanding the legitimacy of current practice and change within the UK construction sector. An agenda for change in the UK construction sector will need to engage with and be more reflective of current managerial practice and past change initiatives. Contextual approaches such as structuration theory offer a way in which to underpin a research framework that could support the reform movement in setting such an agenda. Depuis longtemps, les changements qui interviennent dans le secteur de la construction sont une préoccupation majeure pour les gouvernements et pour quelques clients sélectionnés du secteur privé. Le discours sur le changement émanant d'organisations préoccupées par la réforme dans la construction reflète l'inquiétude permanente causée par le changement dans ce secteur. Les hypothèses sous-jacentes portant sur le contenu et sur les mécanismes appropriés du changement au Royaume-Uni font l'objet d'un examen critique et sont mises en question. L'auteur analyse, en particulier, les limitations des mesures et des meilleures pratiques. Les positions en faveur d'approches basées sur les mesures et les meilleures pratiques sont hors contexte, non représentatives et insuffisantes puisqu'elles ne parviennent pas à fournir une explication totalement fiable des relations entre la pratique et la performance. Il est donc clair que lorsque le mouvement en faveur de la réforme encourage l'utilisation de mesures et des meilleures pratiques, celles-ci on des limites et leur utilisation doit être envisagée avec précaution. En mettant l'accent sur les meilleures pratiques, on détourne l'attention de la compréhension de la légitimité des pratiques actuelles et des changements dans le secteur de la construction au Royaume-Uni. Tout programme de changement dans le secteur de la construction au Royaume-Uni devra être associé à des pratiques de gestion plus réfléchies et tenir compte d'initiatives de changement prises dans le passé. Des approches contextuelles comme la théorie de la structuration offrent une méthode sur laquelle pourra s'appuyer un cadre de recherche qui pourrait apporter son soutien au mouvement de réforme en définissant un tel programme. Mots clés: analyse comparative, meilleures pratiques, gestion du changement, projets de démonstration, performances de l'industrie, innovation, indicateurs de performances clés, changement organisationnel, mouvement de réforme

10 October 2013 in Construction Management and Economics
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
SFScott Fernie
Scott Fernie
STStuart Tennant
Stuart Tennant
Largely taken for granted within the UK construction sector has been a view that supply chain management theory is robust, relevant and reliable. As such it has formed a substantial aspect of previous and contemporary policy and government funded research. Despite this, the general view of its development and diffusion over the last 15 years within the construction industry has been problematic. Coincidentally, prevailing debates within the supply chain management academic community point to the lack of unified theory, models of diffusion and strong connections to organization theory. Using Straussian grounded theory, iterations between data and organization theory provided a fresh perspective on the development and diffusion of supply chain management in construction. This inductive research provided contextually rich explanations for development and diffusion that explicitly connected with and drew upon robust, relevant and reliable theories of institutions, innovation diffusion, triads, quasifirms and mechanisms of organizational governance. These explanations challenge the simplistic assumption that chains and networks of organizations are holistically managed and controlled by any single organization or institution in the construction industry. The debate therefore shifts away from proselytizing supply chain management towards research that explores the rigour, relevance and reliability of supply chain management assumptions in construction. The gap between industry practice and policy is exposed and the question is posed: to what extent policy and practice do, or should, constitute a recursive relationship.