The growth of e-commerce has created increasing complexity in logistics services. To remain competitive, logistics and e-commerce companies are exploring new modes as supplements to traditional home delivery, one of which is the self-service parcel locker. This paper studies a parcel locker location problem where a company plans to introduce the locker service by locating locker facilities to attract customers. The objective is to maximize the profit, accounting for the revenue and the cost of facilities. To estimate the revenue, we use the threshold Luce model (TLM) to predict customers' likelihood of using the locker service. We then propose a combinatorial optimization model and develop exact solution methodologies that are practically implementable according to our extensive computational experiments. In effect, our modeling framework generalizes the traditional facility location problems based on the binomial logit model (BNL) and the multinomial logit model (MNL), both of which impose strong and strict assumptions on the customer's choice sets. That is, they assume that the choice sets will either contain only one facility or all facilities. In our numerical experiment, we demonstrate that using the BNL and the MNL in the locker location problem could lead to, respectively, pessimistic and optimistic revenue estimation. Consequently, the suggested location decisions will be either conservative or aggressive. Our proposed model, by contrast, can effectively relax these assumptions. Our results also reveal that the aggressive decision due to the use of the MNL will incur an unnecessarily high facility cost that cannot be compensated by the additional revenue, leading to profit loss that can be significant in various scenarios. Finally, we conduct sensitivity analysis on the input parameters and draw additional implications.
We study a variant of the competitive facility location problem, in which a company is to locate new facilities in a market where competitor's facilities already exist. We consider the scenario where only a limited number of possible attractiveness levels is available, and the company has to select exactly one level for each open facility. The goal is to decide the facilities' locations and attractiveness levels that maximize the profit. We apply the gravity-based rule to model the behavior of the customers and formulate a multi-ratio linear fractional 0-1 program. Our main contributions are the exact solution approaches for the problem. These approaches allow for easy implementations without the need for designing complicated algorithms and are "friendly" to the users without a solid mathematical background. We conduct computational experiments on the randomly generated datasets to assess their computational performance. The results suggest that the mixed-integer quadratic conic approach outperforms the others in terms of computational time. Besides that, it is also the most straightforward one that only requires the users to be familiar with the general form of a conic quadratic inequality. Therefore, we recommend it as the primary choice for such a problem.
One innovative solution to the last-mile delivery problem is the self-service locker system. Motivated by a real case in Singapore, we consider a POP-Locker Alliance who operates a set of POP-stations and wishes to improve the last-mile delivery by opening new locker facilities. We propose a quantitative approach to determine the optimal locker location with the objective to maximize the overall service provided by the alliance. Customer's choices regarding the use of facilities are explicitly considered. They are predicted by a multinomial logit model. We then formulate the location problem as a multi-ratio linear-fractional 0-1 program and provide two solution approaches. The first one is to reformulate the original problem as a mixed-integer linear program, which is further strengthened using conditional McCormick inequalities. This approach is an exact method, developed for small-scale problems. For large-scale problems, we propose a Suggest-and-Improve framework with two embedded algorithms. Numerical studies indicated that our framework is an efficient approach that yields high-quality solutions. Finally, we conducted a case study. The results highlighted the importance of considering the customers' choices. Under different parameter values of the multinomial logit model, the decisions could be completely different. Therefore, the parameter value should be carefully estimated in advance.