With growing recognition of mentoring as a critical means of supporting teacher learning and professional growth, concerns have emerged about traditional mentoring approaches that position mentees primarily as recipients of guidance and resources who emulate their mentors, rather than as active constructors of knowledge for teaching. Educative mentoring (EM) has emerged as an alternative approach that supports mentees’ development of student-centered, reform-oriented instruction by aligning mentoring with the constructivist principles underlying such teaching. However, despite growing interest in EM, its conceptualization remains fragmented across studies and its defining features insufficiently specified, limiting its application in research and practice. This review conceptualizes EM by synthesizing extant definitions and identifying its defining features in contrast to traditional mentoring approaches. Drawing on a broad corpus of studies across teacher education and professional development contexts, the review identifies five key components of EM: collaborative learning, situated inquiry, bifocal vision, reflective discourse, and a focus on student thinking. For each component, it further delineates six observable indicators that characterize how EM may be enacted in mentoring practices. By consolidating existing conceptualizations of EM into a coherent framework and operationalizing its components through practice-based indicators, this review offers a conceptual and methodological foundation for future research and evaluation of EM, as well as practical guidance for mentoring practice across educational contexts.