Academic peer review is at the heart of scientific quality control, yet the process is slow and time-consuming. Technology that can predict peer review outcomes may help with this, for example by fast-tracking desk rejection decisions. While previous studies have demonstrated that Large Language Models (LLMs) can predict peer review outcomes to some extent, this paper introduces two new contexts and employs a more robust method—averaging multiple ChatGPT scores. Averaging 30 ChatGPT predictions, based on reviewer guidelines and using only the submitted titles and abstracts failed to predict peer review outcomes for F1000Research (Spearman’s rho = 0.00). However, it produced mostly weak positive correlations with the quality dimensions of SciPost Physics (rho = 0.25 for validity, rho = 0.25 for originality, rho = 0.20 for significance, and rho = 0.08 for clarity) and a moderate positive correlation for papers from the International Conference on Learning Representations (ICLR) (rho = 0.38). Including article full texts increased the correlation for ICLR (rho = 0.46) and slightly improved it for F1000Research (rho = 0.09), with variable effects on the four quality dimension correlations for SciPost LaTeX files. The use of simple chain-of-thought system prompts slightly increased the correlation for F1000Research (rho = 0.10), marginally reduced it for ICLR (rho = 0.37), and further decreased it for SciPost Physics (rho = 0.16 for validity, rho = 0.18 for originality, rho = 0.18 for significance, and rho = 0.05 for clarity). Overall, the results suggest that in some contexts, ChatGPT can produce weak pre-publication quality predictions. However, their effectiveness and the optimal strategies for employing them vary considerably between platforms, journals, and conferences. Finally, the most suitable inputs for ChatGPT appear to differ depending on the platform.
Multi-drug delivery systems have gained increasing interest from the pharmaceutical industry. Alongside this is the interest in amorphous solid dispersions as an approach to achieve effective oral delivery of compounds with solubility-limited bioavailability. Despite this, there is limited information regarding predicting the behavior of two or more drugs (in amorphous forms) in a polymeric carrier and whether molecular interactions between the compounds, between each compound, and if the polymer have any effect on the physical properties of the system. This work studies the interaction between model drug combinations (two of ibuprofen, malonic acid, flurbiprofen, or naproxen) dispersed in a polymeric matrix of hypromellose acetate succinate (HPMCAS) using a solvent evaporation technique. Hildebrand and Hansen calculations were used to predict the miscibility of compounds as long as the difference in their solubility parameter values was not greater than 7 MPa1/2. It was observed that the selected APIs (malonic acid, ibuprofen, naproxen, and flurbiprofen) were miscible within the formed polymeric matrix. Adding the API caused depression in the Tg of the polymer to certain concentrations (17%, 23%, 13%) for polymeric matrices loaded with malonic acid, ibuprofen, and naproxen, respectively. Above this, large crystals started to form, and phase separation was seen. Adding two APIs to the same matrix resulted in reducing the saturation concentration of one of the APIs. A trend was observed and linked to Hildebrand and Hansen solubility parameters (HSP).
As data analytics increasingly rely on machine learning models for forecasting, classification, and prediction, effective visualisation becomes essential for transforming model outputs into practical insight. Yet the ways these outputs are visualised, and the evidence supporting those designs, remain fragmented across domains. This paper presents a systematic literature review of visualising machine learning model outputs in data analytics, focusing on how predicted outputs are communicated to end-users alongside performance and uncertainty information, and how these visual systems are evaluated in practice. Following PRISMA, we screened 330 articles from ACM Digital Library, IEEE Xplore, and PubMed and included 88 peer-reviewed studies published between Jan 2015 and July 2024. Across the corpus, we identify (1) recurring visual encoding and interaction patterns for interpreting predictions in temporal, spatio-temporal, and event-based settings; (2) common strategies for presenting model validation, calibration, and uncertainty; and (3) a wide range of evaluation approaches, from informal expert feedback to controlled user studies and deployments. The synthesis highlights persistent gaps in rigorous and comparable evaluation, challenges in supporting diverse user goals and expertise levels, and practical constraints that arise in operational contexts. We conclude by distilling practical implications for designing and assessing predictive visualisations, as well as outlining recommendations for future research and practice, with particular attention to improving uncertainty communication, strengthening evaluation rigour and comparability, and adopting evaluation methods that better reflect operational data analytics practice.