Societies go through complex challenges in the face of the vertiginous increase in disasters, mostly produced by the effects of extreme events. The lack of capacity to deal with disasters is evident, especially in developing countries, as in the case of Peru. Under such a premise, this paper contributes to strengthening the country’s capacities, through an evaluation of national disaster resilience to the El Niño-Southern Oscillation-driven hazards caused by the El Niño disaster event between 2016 and 2017 on the Peruvian coast. By reviewing the literature, various hazards were identified, such as heavy rainfalls and cascading hazards, such as floods and landslides. Even though risk assessments were carried out, 169 people died and essential infrastructure was severely impacted and lost. Through a 12-criteria resilience assessment framework sub-divided into sustainable development and disaster risk reduction, a diagnosis of national disaster resilience was carried out, along with a disaster risk management evaluation. Under such assessments, strategic recommendations were proposed to enhance the resilience of the country. The lack of resilience of the country is reflected in the evaluated criteria, the most negative being the built environment due to infrastructure system’s vulnerability to hazards, and the lack of social development, despite national economic growth in Peru. The research is extremely valuable because it bridges the knowledge gap on disaster resilience in Peru. In addition, the methodology, as well as the multi-topic assessment framework, can be used for other analyses, which are key to building greater capacity in nations around the globe.
Analysing the hydrological vulnerability of important structures such as bridges is essential to ensuring people’s safety. This research proposes a methodology to assess the hydrological vulnerability of riverine bridges through a case study of the Bajo Grau Bridge in the city of Arequipa, Peru. Topological and hydrometrical data collection play an important role in the study. A topographic surveying of the bridge and the streambed were carried out, followed by a series of annual maximum flow rates which were compiled, fitted with empirical and theoretical distribution functions, and used in a probability analysis. Based on this process, the flow rates were estimated for six scenarios based on different return periods and critical conditions. Once the hydrological study was completed, the system was modelled using HEC-RAS. The hydraulic simulation, as well as the soil mechanics study, provided the parameters to calculate the scour in the bridge substructure, the potential erosion in the deck, and the possibility of flooding in the superstructure. A hydrological vulnerability assessment matrix with ten criteria subdivided in environmental and physical vulnerabilities was designed and used to determine that the bridge has a high hydrological vulnerability. The proposed methodology can be adapted and transferred to assess other bridges with similar characteristics.
1 September 2024 in Infrastructure Asset Management
Ensuring the through-life quality of infrastructure systems is a fundamental instrument in providing economic development and enhancing the quality of life. The complexity of infrastructure networks themselves, the operations of the public entities that manage them and the governance systems that oversee them make this a challenging activity. This research uses the city of Arequipa in Peru as a case study to bridge the knowledge gap on the behaviour of such municipalities regarding the management of infrastructure systems. It employs qualitative system dynamics modelling through a methodology based on the V-model, with its emphasis on validation and verification, and framed in the systems thinking approach. First, 67 variables characterising the management of infrastructure systems in Arequipa are identified from the literature and semi-structured interviews with key actors. Second, a model of the system is constructed using causal loop diagrams. Within this model, 33 feedback loops are identified, formed from the causal influences between variables. Third, a diagnosis is carried out that unequivocally illuminates the failure patterns of the municipalities. Fourth, by identifying leverage points, a paradigm-shifting intervention is proposed along with tools that municipalities can implement to improve their performance. Finally, these proposals are validated with key actors through a focus group.
Rapid infrastructure growth in developing countries has intensified environmental challenges due to cost-prioritizing practices over sustainability. This study evaluates 21 identified sustainable-driving tools to improve the management of infrastructure throughout its life cycle, by interacting with 20 out of 36 key infrastructure system management variables (ISMVs). Using a systems thinking approach, a Sustainable Systems Dynamic Model (SSDM) is developed, comprising a nucleus representing the interconnected stages of the life cycle: planning and design (S1), procurement (S2), construction (S3), operation and maintenance (S4), and renewal and disposal (S5). The model incorporates a total of 12 balance (B) and 25 reinforcement (R) loops, enabling the visualization of critical interdependencies that influence the sustainability of the system. In addition, its analysis shows the interdependencies between variables and stages, demonstrating, for example, how the implementation of tools such as LCA, BIM, and Circular Economy principles in S1, or IoT and SHM in S4, significantly improve sustainability. A gap between theory and practice in the adoption of sustainable practices is identified, which is aggravated by the lack of knowledge in specific developing countries’ context. Hence, this study contributes to its closure by offering a model that facilitates the understanding of key interactions in infrastructure systems.
Heritage bridges constitute an integral feature of the urban landscape in numerous cities. However, it is common for these structures to surpass their life cycle, rendering them ill-equipped to withstand the dynamic demands of users and extreme events, particularly hydrological occurrences. This research presents a methodology for the assessment of heritage riverine bridges, with a focus on the Grau Bridge in Peru as a case study. The investigation commences with an exhaustive literature review, complemented by a historical examination, followed by a preliminary diagnosis. Subsequently, hydrological and hydraulic studies are presented, encompassing drone surveys of the riverbed and the bridge, soil analyses, and the application of 1D and 2D models in HEC-RAS. The outcomes of this comprehensive analysis reveal the high vulnerability of the Grau Bridge. Finally, strategic interventions for its conservation are recommended.
The modern civil engineering and construction sector requires collaborative work environments, learning and trust among all parties involved, qualities that are absent in the Peruvian reality. This study, which is based on an extensive literature review, investigates this challenge. The study reflects upon (i) the current situation of public works procurement in Peru and (ii) the New Engineering Contract (NEC), which has recently been implemented in Peruvian Special Public Infrastructure Projects. Comparisons are presented between the characteristics, documentation and roles of these two systems, with the purpose of understanding and representing the advantages, disadvantages and possibilities of integrating the good contractual management practices of the NEC4 Engineering and Construction Contract into the traditional Peruvian State Contracting Law (Ley de Contrataciones del Estado: LCE). The research is validated through the case study of a high-impact road infrastructure project in the city of Arequipa, Peru, which revealed five main deficiencies from Peruvian procurement processes which hinder good contractual management and, also, facilitated an initial assessment of the challenges and improvement opportunities in public infrastructure procurement. Thus, a contribution is made to closing the knowledge gap regarding the implementation of the NEC4 ECC in public sector works.