Restorative environments are known as places where human stress can be decreased through restoration of depleted psychological resources. Since the efficiency of natural environments in restoration is supported by the literature, designing a restorative built environment can be obtained by integrating natural objects into built environments. However, various factors may lead to the failure of design intentions in real restorative environments such as visual stimuli and their properties. In addition, previous literature has widely used images and immersive virtual environments (IVEs) to deliver restorative environments in the design stage, and the impact of the delivery methods on visual properties needs to be considered. Therefore, the key to this study is to investigate the impact of visual stimuli and their properties on restoration along with the type of delivery method. To achieve this objective, the authors performed a literature review in two main steps. During the first step, the authors reviewed restoration and visual studies separately to understand the restoration and visual processes. Then, the second step of the review was conducted based on the results from the first step to review studies investigating the impact of different visual stimuli and properties on restoration. The literature review was conducted by combining scientometric analysis with a systematic review. In total, 1608 publications were retrieved from the Web of Science for scientometric analysis after applying search criteria. Then, the authors explored cluster reports generated by scientometric analysis to find publications for a systematic review based on inclusion and exclusion criteria. According to the results from a systematic review of 65 publications, the authors developed a restoration pathway and a visual processing framework for the first step, and a framework of visual stimuli, visual properties, and restoration for the second step.
Green walls have been used in built environments as a natural element to bring various benefits, thus improving human health and well-being. However, in conventional virtual environments, the visual connection with a green wall is the only way that this natural element could benefit humans. Unfortunately, the impact of such visual connection on human thermal perception is still not well understood. Thus, we conducted an experimental study with 40 participants comparing the thermal state of two virtual sessions: biophilic (a room with a green wall) and non-biophilic (the same room without a green wall). Both sessions were conducted in a climate chamber under a slightly warm condition (28.89 °C and 50% relative humidity). Participants’ thermal state, skin temperature, and heart rate data were collected. According to the results, participants’ thermal comfort and hand skin temperature were significantly different between the two sessions, and their mean skin temperature was statistically increased over time. The study suggests that before the extent to which the impact of visual stimuli (e.g., green walls) on thermal perception is fully understood, researchers may need to control visual and thermal stimuli separately when using them in immersive virtual environments. Furthermore, the virtual exposure time should be an important consideration when designing experimental procedures.
Humans have an inherent connection to nature, and exposure to natural elements has been shown to reduce stress, improve mood, and support cognitive performance, forming the basis of biophilic design in the built environment. However, existing biophilic design guidance remains largely conceptual and offers limited evidence-based direction on how design properties should be applied. This scoping review addresses this gap by systematically mapping and synthesizing empirical evidence on indoor biophilic design interventions and their properties. Following PRISMA-ScR guidelines, 136 studies published between 2000 and 2025 were reviewed across seven intervention types, including green walls, indoor plants, window views, natural light, natural materials, water features, and nature-inspired visual references. Cross-category analyses identified design properties most consistently associated with restorative outcomes and human cognitive and physiological responses. The findings highlight the importance of moderate greenery levels, high-visibility placement, multi-sensory integration, and the enhanced restorative effects of combining multiple interventions. Contextual factors such as exposure duration and user characteristics were found to influence effectiveness. Based on these findings, the study introduces the Biophilic Intensity Matrix (BIMx), a matrix-based decision-support framework that supports early-stage design by helping designers select biophilic intervention types and compare their relative scale and intensity ranges according to exposure duration.
Biophilic design, incorporating natural elements, is known to enhance stress recovery. Immersive virtual environments (IVEs) are increasingly utilized for biophilic design validation and research, but their efficacy in replicating the restorative effects of real environments remains uncertain. Varying responses to virtual settings suggest that specific design factors may affect their effectiveness. This study provides a novel comparison of the stress recovery and restoration effect between real and virtual green walls in a controlled climate chamber. Sixty-three participants were exposed to either a real or virtual green wall for seven minutes after a 5 min stressor task. Physiological stress responses, including heart rate (HR), heart rate variability (HRV), electrodermal activity (EDA), and skin temperature (ST), were recorded, alongside self-reported restoration and thermal comfort surveys. The findings showed that the real green wall provided significantly greater stress recovery, with reduced HR and EDA and increased HRV. The virtual green wall produced similar recovery effects only when considering procedural factors and specific exposure durations. Participants also reported greater restoration and comfort in the real setting. By identifying critical procedural factors and exposure durations, this study advances the application of IVEs in biophilic design, offering a pathway to enhance well-being in built environments through virtual interventions.