Although hyperthermophilic archaea arguably have a great need for efficient DNA repair, they lack members of several DNA repair protein families broadly conserved among bacteria and eukaryotes. Conversely, the putative DNA repair genes that do occur in these archaea often do not generate the expected phenotype when deleted. The prospect that hyperthermophilic archaea have some unique strategies for coping with DNA damage and replication errors has intellectual and technological appeal, but resolving this question will require alternative coping mechanisms to be proposed and tested experimentally. This review evaluates a combination of four enigmatic properties that distinguishes the hyperthermophilic archaea from all other organisms: DNA polymerase stalling at dU, apparent lack of conventional NER, lack of MutSL homologs, and apparent essentiality of homologous recombination proteins. Hypothetical damage-coping strategies that could explain this set of properties may provide new starting points for efforts to define how archaea differ from conventional models of DNA repair and replication fidelity.

In order to determine the biological relevance of twoS. acidocaldariusproteins to the repair of UV photoproducts, the corresponding genes (Saci_1227 and Saci_1096) were disrupted, and the phenotypes of the resulting mutants were examined by various genetic assays. The disruption used integration by homologous recombination of a functional but heterologouspyrEgene, promoted by short sequences attached to both endsviaPCR. The phenotypic analyses of the disruptants confirmed that ORF Saci_1227 encodes a DNA photolyase which functionsin vivo, but they could not implicate ORF Saci_1096 in repair of UV- or other externally induced DNA damage despite its similarity to genes encoding UV damage endonucleases. The success of the gene-disruption strategy, which used 5^′extensions of PCR primers to target cassette integration, suggests potential advantages for routine construction ofSulfolobusstrains.

In order to analyze in molecular terms howSulfolobusgenomes diverge, damage-induced mutations and natural polymorphisms (PMs) were identified in laboratory constructs and wild-type isolates, respectively, ofSulfolobus acidocaldarius. Among wild-type isolates drawn from one local population, pairwise nucleotide divergence averaged 4 × 10⁻⁶, which is about 0.15% of the corresponding divergence reported forSulfolobus islandicus. The most variable features of wild-typeS. acidocaldariusgenomes were homopolymer (mononucleotide) tracts and longer tandem repeats, consistent with the spontaneous mutations that occur under laboratory conditions. Natural isolates, however, also revealed large insertions/deletions and inversions, which did not occur in any of the laboratory-manipulated strains. Several of the large insertions/deletions could be attributed to the integration or excision of mobile genetic elements (MGEs), and each MGE represented a distinct system of site-specific recombination. The mode of recombination associated with one MGE, a provirus related toSulfolobus turreted icosahedral virus, was also seen in certain chromosomal inversions. Artificially induced mutations, non-MGE insertions/deletions, and small PMs exhibited different distributions over the genome, suggesting that large-scale patterning ofSulfolobusgenomes begins early in the divergence process. Unlike induced mutations, natural base pair substitutions occurred in clusters, and one cluster exhibited properties expected of nonreciprocal recombination (gene conversion) between dispersed imperfect repeats. Taken together, the results identify simple replication errors, slipped-strand events promoted by tandem repeats, homologous recombination, and rearrangements promoted by MGEs as the primary sources of genetic variation for this extremely acidophilic archaeon in its geothermal environment.IMPORTANCEThe optimal growth temperatures of hyperthermophilic archaea accelerate DNA decomposition, which is expected to make DNA repair especially important for their genetic stability, yet these archaea lack certain broadly conserved types of DNA repair proteins. In this study, the genome of the extreme thermoacidophileSulfolobus acidocaldariuswas found to be remarkably stable, accumulating few mutations in many (though not all) laboratory manipulations and in natural populations. Furthermore, all the genetic processes that were inferred to diversify these genomes also operate in mesophilic bacteria and eukaryotes. This suggests that a common set of mechanisms produces most of the genetic variation in all microorganisms, despite the fundamental differences in physiology, DNA repair systems, and genome structure represented in the three domains of life.

Local populations of Sulfolobus islandicus diverge genetically with geographical separation, and this has been attributed to restricted transfer of propagules imposed by the unfavorable spatial distribution of acidic geothermal habitat. We tested the generality of genetic divergence with distance in Sulfolobus species by analyzing genomes of Sulfolobus acidocaldarius drawn from three populations separated by more than 8000 km. In sharp contrast to S. islandicus, the geographically diverse S. acidocaldarius genomes proved to be nearly identical. We could not link the difference in genome conservation between the two species to a corresponding difference in genome stability or ecological factors affecting propagule dispersal. The results provide the first evidence that genetic isolation of local populations does not result primarily from properties intrinsic to Sulfolobus and the severe discontinuity of its geothermal habitat, but varies with species, and thus may reflect biotic interactions that act after propagule dispersal.