Detection of developmental phenotypes in zebrafish embryos typically involves a visual assessment and scoring of morphological features by an individual researcher. Subjective scoring could impact results and be of particular concern when phenotypic effect patterns are also used as a diagnostic tool to classify compounds. Here we introduce a quantitative morphometric approach based on image analysis of zebrafish embryos. A software called FishInspector was developed to detect morphological features from images collected using an automated system to position zebrafish embryos. The analysis was verified and compared with visual assessments of 3 participating laboratories using 3 known developmental toxicants (methotrexate, dexamethasone, and topiramate) and 2 negative compounds (loratadine and glibenclamide). The quantitative approach exhibited higher sensitivity and made it possible to compare patterns of effects with the potential to establish a grouping and classification of developmental toxicants. Our approach improves the robustness of phenotype scoring and reliability of assay performance and, hence, is anticipated to improve the predictivity of developmental toxicity screening using the zebrafish embryo.
Disinfection by-products are contaminants produced during drinking water disinfection. Several DBPs have been implicated in a variety of toxic effects, mainly carcinogenic and genotoxic effects. Moreover, DBPs exposure has also been associated with an increased risk of developmental effects. In this study, the developmental toxicity and genotoxicity of 10 DBPs (four trihalomethanes [THMs], five haloacetic acids [HAAs] and sodium bromate) in the zebrafish embryo model were evaluated. Embryos exposed for 72 hours were observed for different endpoints such as growth, hatching success, malformations and lethality. THMs exposure resulted in adverse developmental effects and a significant reduced tail length. Two HAAs, tribromoacetic acid and dichloroacetic acid, along with sodium bromate were found to cause a significant increase in malformation rate. Chloroform, chlorodibromomethane and sodium bromate produced a weak induction of DNA damage to whole embryos. However, developmental effects occurred at a range of concentrations (20–100 μg/mL) several orders of magnitude above the levels that can be attained in fetal blood in humans exposed to chlorinated water. In conclusion, the teratogenic and genotoxic activity observed by some DBPs in zebrafish reinforce the view that there is a weak capacity of disinfection products to cause developmental effects at environmentally relevant concentrations.
9 October 2019 in Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry
No Observed Effect Concentrations (NOECs) are used in environmental hazard classification and labeling of chemicals and their environmental risk assessment. They are typically obtained using standard tests such as the fish early‐life stage (FELS) toxicity test, the chronic Daphnia reproduction test, and the algae growth inhibition test. Given the demand to replace and reduce animal tests we explored the impact of the FELS test on the determination of effect concentrations by comparing the FELS test, Daphnia and algae acute or chronic toxicity tests. Lowest observed effect concentrations (LOECs) were used instead of NOECs for better comparison with LC50 or EC50 data. A database of FELS data for 223 compounds was established. Corresponding Daphnia and algae toxicity tests were identified using established databases (US EPA ECOTOX, OECD QSAR toolbox, eChemPortal, EnviroTox and OpenFoodTox database). About 9.5 percent of the investigated compounds showed a 10‐fold higher sensitivity in FELS in comparison to the lowest effect concentrations obtained with any of the other tests. Some of these compounds were known or discussed as endocrine disrupting or other non‐narcotic chemicals indicating that the higher sensitivity in the FELS test is related to a specific mechanism of action. Targeting these mechanisms by alternative test systems or endpoints, for instance using fish embryos, may allow reduction or replacement of the FELS test or prioritize compounds for conduction of the FELS test.