This study explores parallels between systemic hypoxia adaptation in high-altitude populations and tumorigenesis. We identified EPAS1, a gene critical for hypoxia adaptation in populations such as Tibetans and Sherpas, as playing a similar adaptive role in tumors arising under hypoxic conditions. Tumors from patients with chronic hypoxia displayed impaired DNA repair and frequent emergence of EPAS1 variants, with frequencies reaching up to 90%, echoing the positive selection seen in high-altitude dwellers. Mechanistically, EPAS1 gain-of-function mutations promote COX4I2 expression, reducing cellular oxygen consumption and supporting tumor proliferation in hypoxia. Analysis of clinical data from patients with hypoxia revealed tissue-specific and time-sensitive tumorigenic effects, particularly impacting oxygen-sensitive cells in the postnatal period. Our findings suggest that EPAS1-driven adaptation mechanisms in high-altitude populations provide a model for understanding tumor evolution under hypoxic stress, highlighting how genetic adaptations to diverse stressors in natural populations may yield insights into tumorigenesis and cancer progression. Significance: This study reveals a broad convergence in genetic adaptation to hypoxia between natural populations and tumors, suggesting that insights from natural populations could enhance our understanding of cancer biology and identify novel therapeutic targets. See related commentary by Lee, p. 875
Hypoxia-inducible factors (HIF) 2α and 1α are the major oxygen-sensing molecules in eukaryotic cells. HIF2α has been pathogenically linked to paraganglioma and pheochromocytoma (PPGL) arising in sympathetic paraganglia or the adrenal medulla (AM), respectively. However, its involvement in the pathogenesis of paraganglioma arising in the carotid body (CB) or other parasympathetic ganglia in the head and neck (HNPGL) remains to be defined. Here, we retrospectively analyzed HIF2α by immunohistochemistry in 62 PPGL/HNPGL and human CB and AM, and comprehensively evaluated the HIF-related transcriptome of 202 published PPGL/HNPGL. We report that HIF2α is barely detected in the AM, but accumulates at high levels in PPGL, mostly (but not exclusively) in those with loss-of-function mutations in VHL and genes encoding components of the succinate dehydrogenase (SDH) complex. This is associated with upregulation of EPAS1 and the HIF2α-regulated genes COX4I2 and ADORA2A. In contrast, HIF2α and HIF2α-regulated genes are highly expressed in CB and HNPGL, irrespective of VHL and SDH dysfunctions. We also found that HIF2α and HIF1α protein expressions are not correlated in PPGL nor HNPGL. In addition, HIF1α-target genes are almost exclusively overexpressed in VHL-mutated HNPGL/PPGL. Collectively, the data suggest that involvement of HIF2α in the physiology and tumor pathology of human paraganglia is organ-of-origin-dependent and HIF1α-independent.
Metabolic changes involving the tricarboxylic acid (TCA) cycle have been linked to different non-metabolic cell processes. Among them, apart from cancer and immunity, emerges the DNA damage response (DDR) and specifically DNA damage repair. The oncometabolites succinate, fumarate and 2-hydroxyglutarate (2HG) increase reactive oxygen species levels and create pseudohypoxia conditions that induce DNA damage and/or inhibit DNA repair. Additionally, by influencing DDR modulation, they establish direct relationships with DNA repair on at least four different pathways. The AlkB pathway deals with the removal of N-alkylation DNA and RNA damage that is inhibited by fumarate and 2HG. The MGMT pathway acts in the removal of O-alkylation DNA damage, and it is inhibited by the silencing of the MGMT gene promoter by 2HG and succinate. The other two pathways deal with the repair of double-strand breaks (DSBs) but with opposite effects: the FH pathway, which uses fumarate to help with the repair of this damage, and the chromatin remodeling pathway, in which oncometabolites inhibit its repair by impairing the homologous recombination repair (HRR) system. Since oncometabolites inhibit DNA repair, their removal from tumor cells will not always generate a positive response in cancer therapy. In fact, their presence contributes to longer survival and/or sensitization against tumor therapy in some cancer patients.
15 January 2021 in Pflügers Archiv - European Journal of Physiology
Supplementary Tables Supplementary Table S1. Clinical and Tumoral Data from CCHD-PPGL patients. Supplementary Table S2. Selection inference in the PPGL (TCGA, non-CCHD) and CCHD-PPGL cohort. Supplementary Table S3. Cancer Cell Fraction of EPAS1 mutations in CCHD-PPGL and PPGL patients. Supplementary Table S4. Clonal Clustering of CCHD-PPGL tumor mutations, highlighting EPAS1 mutation, using Conipher. Supplementary Table S5. Clonal Clustering of PPGL tumor mutations (TCGA), highlighting EPAS1 mutation, using Conipher. Supplementary Table S6. Parallelism of EPAS1 genetic variant selection in high-altitude populations and human tumors. Supplementary Table S7. EPAS1 Frequencies of Denisovan AGGAA haplotype from 4,000 Han Chinese Population (https://www.biosino.org/pgghan2/index) compared with gnomAD cohort around the world. Supplementary Table S8. Genetic Instability Characteristics (MSI, CNA, TMB) from CCHD-PPGL and PPGL (TCGA) tumors. Supplementary Table S9. Data of 354 differentially expressed mitochondrial genes (from Human Mitocarta Database) between EPAS1MUT and EPAS1WT samples in patients with PPGL (TCGA). Supplementary Table S10. Gene expression profiling analysis from patients with hemoglobin disorders and 52 paragangliomas with various genotypes including 19 EPAS1 (including one tumor in duplicate), 6 SDHx, 2 SLC25A11, 6 VHL, 3 RET, 3 NF1, 1 MAX, 1 MAML3 and 11 unmutated paragangliomas (Mancini M et al. Br J Haematol, 2023). Supplementary Table S11. RNAseq Raw Counts from PC12 Cell line cultured under normoxia/hypoxia conditions. Supplementary Table S12. Tumor type and hypoxia onset in patients with CCHD-PPGL. Supplementary Table S13. O2 Saturation in CCHD patients with or without PPGL tumors. Supplementary Table S14. Heart surgery influence in tumor development in patients with CCHD-PPGL. Supplementary Table S15. Clinical features of tumors developed under hypoxia (CCHD-PPGL) and normoxia (non-CCHD-PPGL). Supplementary Table S16. Representation of clinical variables in patients with PPGL and CCHD-PPGL.