Selecting suitable locations for the disposal of medical waste is a serious matter. This study aims to propose a novel approach to selecting the optimal landfill for medical waste using Multi-Criteria Decision-Making (MCDM) methods. For better considerations of the uncertainty in choosing the optimal landfill, the MCDM methods are extended by spherical fuzzy sets (SFS). The identified criteria affecting the selection of the optimal location for landfilling medical waste include three categories; environmental, economic, and social. Moreover, the weights of the 13 criteria were computed by Spherical Fuzzy Step-Wise Weight Assessment Ratio Analysis (SFSWARA). In the next step, the alternatives were analyzed and ranked using Spherical Fuzzy Weighted Aggregated Sum Product Assessment (SFWASPAS). Finally, in order to show the accuracy and validity of the results, the proposed approach was compared with the IF-SWARA-WASPAS method. Examination of the results showed that in the IF environment the ranking is not complete, and the results of the proposed method are more reliable. Furthermore, ten scenarios were created by changing the weight of the criteria, and the results were compared with the proposed method. The overall results were similar to the SF-SWARA-WASPAS method.
17 July 2019 in International Journal of Management Science and Engineering Management
In this paper, Base-criterion method (BCM) is proposed to solve multi-criteria decision-making problems. According to BCM, instead of executing a pairwise comparisons between all criteria or executing a pairwise comparisons between each of the best and worst criteria to other criteria, one of the criteria is chosen by the decision-maker as a base-criterion (e.g. preferential, selective) and then pairwise comparisons between base-criterion and other criteria are obtained. Then, a max-min problem is formulated and solved to determine the weight of the criteria. In this way, the pairwise comparisons to obtain weights of the criteria are fully consistent. In other ability of BCM, we find the lost pairwise comparisons by using the BCM framework so that the pairwise comparisons matrix remains consistent. To illustrate the reliability of the proposed method and evaluate its performance to determine the weights, we have used two numerical examples. The outcomes of numerical examples indicate that the BCM has high accuracy and better consistency ratio than the other multi-criteria decision-making(MCDM) methods. The cause of high consistency ratio in the BCM is the dependency of pairwise comparisons between criteria. Moreover, we have used two other numerical examples to illustrate the function of the BCM in order to find out the missing comparisons in incomplete pairwise comparison matrix. We have shown the BCM framework able to find lost comparisons in the worst terms of the incomplete pairwise comparison matrix. The outcomes of the proposed article show that BCM performance is significantly better than AHP and BWM methods with respect to the consistency ratio, and it requires fewer comparison data and has the ability to calculate missing pairwise comparisons.
Due to the complexity of real-world multi-criteria decision-making (MCDM) issues, analyzing different opinions from a group of decision makers needs to ensure appropriate decision making. The group decision-making methods collect preferences of the decision makers and present the best preferences using mathematical equations. The best–worst method (BWM) is one of the recently introduced MCDM methods that requires fewer pairwise comparisons to obtain the criteria weights than the other MCDM methods. In this research, we develop a novel approach to group decision-making problems based on the BWM called G-BWM. This approach helps us to analyze the preferences of decision makers to carry out democratic decision making using the BWM structure. In order to assess the applicability of the proposed methodology and represent its novelty, two numerical examples from the literature with the application to supply chain management (SCM) (i.e., green supplier selection and supplier development/segmentation) are examined and discussed. The results demonstrate the performance of our proposed G-BWM for group decision making in terms of a large number of decision makers, ease of use and achieving democratic decisions in the decision-making process.
Accurately recognizing potential failures in the early stages of providing products or services can prevent the loss of investment and time and reduce the risk of safety hazards. Failure mode and effects analysis (FMEA) is a conventional approach for detecting and prioritizing the probable failures of a product’s design or production process. Nevertheless, the traditional risk priority number (RPN) method has come under criticism for its deficiencies. This paper proposes a modified FMEA method based on fuzzy Multi-Criteria Decision Making (MCDM) techniques to cope with the weaknesses of the previous methodologies and improve the primary method. The concept of spherical fuzzy sets (SFS) is utilized to address the vagueness and impreciseness of the information that allows the experts to have more freedom in making decisions by including membership, non-membership, and hesitation of fuzzy sets. Initially, the procedure of assigning weights to the RPN criteria is implemented with SFS step-wise weight assessment ratio analysis (SWARA). Then, the failure modes are ranked by the SFS combined compromise solution (CoCoSo) method. The effectiveness and practicality of the suggested approach are illustrated through a case study on the Manjil wind farm in Iran. Results show that the suggested model is more reliable and realistic to be utilized in the prioritization of failures than the common FMEA method or other integrated MCDM approaches.
28 December 2023 in Expert Systems with Applications