On the outperformance of responsible investing (RI) which incorporates environmental, social, and governance (ESG) into investment decisions, the empirical evidence to date is inconsistent from the viewpoint of ex-post performance. This paper tries to explain the nature of return differential between RI and conventional investing within the well-known risk-return paradigm. From the viewpoint of ex-ante equity risk premium, the five factor model of Fama and French [2015. “A Five-factor Asset Pricing Model.” Journal of Financial Economics 116: 1–22] combined with a ESG-related factor applies to returns on 1,425 US open-end equity funds for the period from April 2009 to December 2016. Empirical findings include that US open-end equity funds tend to hedge the ESG-related systematic risk, and that the exposure to ESG-related systematic risk is significantly priced in the market. The result implies that RI provides the downside protection against ESG-related systematic risk which is not reduced even through extensive diversification.
2 October 2020 in Journal of Sustainable Finance & Investment
Constructing ESG-screened portfolios aims to reduce the aggregate ESG-risk at the portfolio level by excluding low ESG-score constituents from the selection universe. But ESG-screening imposes limits on potential diversification as well as alters risk exposures to systematic factors. To investigate ESG-screening’s impact on the factor-risk-adjusted performance of portfolios, we construct ESG-screened portfolios consisting of US equity mutual funds according to their returns-based ESG-scores. The result of performance contribution analysis for the sample period from 1999 to 2018 suggests that investors need to treat the concentration level of ESG-screening as a search parameter to balance the costs and benefits of ESG-screening.
24 February 2022 in The Journal of Portfolio Management
Investors can regard passive environment, social, and governance (ESG) investing as a cost-effective strategy to manage systematic ESG risk. This analysis aims to explain the expected performance of passively following an ESG-screened index within the risk–return paradigm. The author formulates the ESG factor surprise by subtracting returns on ESG-screened indexes from returns on their parent indexes. This approach reveals many intriguing aspects of passive ESG investing. The empirical result of the index model for the sample period from 2011 to 2020 shows that the daily returns of ESG-screened indexes (constructed through negative screening without portfolio skews) have a beta coefficient lower than 1. The EGARCH analysis confirms that ESG factor surprise has a lower long-run level, higher persistence, and minor asymmetry compared with market factor surprise. These empirical findings show that passive ESG investing may be suitable for value-based investors. If investors want to enhance their risk-adjusted return through passive ESG investing, they may need to seek alternative indexes with more ESG exposure deviation.
29 August 2022 in The Journal of Portfolio Management
The author suggests an alternative environmental, social, and governance (ESG) integration framework for portfolio optimization to reflect that systematic ESG risk can account for joint movement in security prices. The author’s framework consists of the double-index model, the two-layer grouping, and the extended-criteria decision rule for optimal portfolio selection. The author’s approach clearly shows how institutional investors can manage systematic ESG risk, rather than individual ESG risk, during portfolio optimization. The framework also provides a simple decision rule, a practical complement for complicated nonlinear programming algorithms, and clearly shows the security characteristics that make it desirable. Applying the framework to US equity mutual funds indicates that the approach can help investors understand how systematic ESG risk is relevant to future risks or returns, strategically manage systematic ESG risk, and improve the portfolio’s risk-adjusted return. Thus, the author’s framework can provide a tractable empirical method compatible with recent theoretical analyses on ESG factor investing.
This paper presents an analytical framework to assess the probability of achieving nationally determined contributions (NDC). The prediction model based on the Kaya identity is used to simulate the pathway of carbon emission until the target year. Applying the modified STIRPAT framework (named CO-STIRPAT) to data observed in South Korea shows that the probability that the predicted pathway with existing climate technology will stay above the NDC target pathway is significantly high. The result suggests that it is necessary to design a climate policy to improve energy intensity and carbon intensity by accelerating the advance in climate technology.
12 January 2017 in Journal of Sustainable Finance & Investment
This paper presents the necessity of having sufficient finances to implement measures contained within Nationally Determined Contributions (NDCs). Based on a dynamic model to capture the link between emissions and government budget balance, our analysis estimates the cost associated with implementing emission-reducing policy. It also measures the gap between what is likely to be funded through existing resources, and what needs to be supplemented through climate finance. For that purpose, an international comparison analysis has been conducted to quantify public climate finance needs for each country. Using panel data for 40 countries over the period of 1998–2012, the empirical results show that economic growth and commensurate greenhouse gas emissions generate budgetary surpluses, and that these surpluses must be offset by public climate finance if countries are to reduce emissions commensurate with their NDCs. It further suggests that this is particularly a challenge for developing countries (notably, the BRIICS). The approach of this paper provides a method for determining the actual amount of public finance required to offset the budgetary shortfall from the climate finance pledged under the Paris Agreement. It is imperative to quantify the extent to which each of the developing countries needs to receive international financial support.