Species misidentification in the field of natural products is an acknowledged problem. These errors are especially widespread in sponge studies, albeit rarely assessed and documented. As a case study, we aim to revisit reports of isomalabaricane triterpenes, isolated from four demosponge genera: Jaspis, Geodia, Stelletta and Rhabdastrella. From a total of 44 articles (1981–2022), 27 unique vouchers were listed, 21 of which were accessed and re-examined here: 11 (52.4%) of these were misidentified. Overall, 65.9% of the studies published an incorrect species name: previously identified Jaspis and Stelletta species were all in fact Rhabdastrella globostellata. We conclude that isomalabaricane triterpenes were isolated from only two Rhabdastrella species and possibly one Geodia species. In addition to shedding a new light on the distribution of isomalabaricane triterpenes, this study is an opportunity to highlight the crucial importance of vouchers in natural product studies. Doing so, we discuss the impact of species misidentification and poor accessibility of vouchers in the field of sponge natural products. We advocate for stricter voucher guidelines in natural product journals and propose a common protocol of good practice, in the hope of reducing misidentifications in sponge studies, ensure reproducibility of studies, and facilitate follow-up work on the original material.
Marine sponges are among the oldest animals to have emerged on Earth. They are metazoan holobionts that host diverse microbial symbionts, which constitute more than 40% of their biomass. Despite their morphological simplicity, sponges exhibit complex genetic architecture, unquestionably encoding ribosomally synthesised and post-translationally modified peptides (RiPPs) and proteins, essential for their biological functions. In addition to host-derived compounds, the associated microbiota also produce RiPPs, introducing further complexity in distinguishing the origin of these molecules. To date, marine sponge RiPPs research is confined to species within the class Demospongiae, with peptidomic, transcriptomic and genomic approaches employed for their discovery. This review provides a comprehensive account of current research on ribosomal peptides in marine sponges and associated microsymbionts, emphasising the need for expanded discovery efforts. Unravelling the genetic basis and biosynthetic pathways of these peptides will deepen our understanding of sponge biology and open new opportunities for peptide-based drug discovery.