Maira Kemelbek

Ms. Maira Kemelbek

Artificial Intelligence, Abai Kazakh National Pedagogical University, Almaty, Kazakhstan
orcid

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

2Years (2025-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
22 July 2025 in Bulletin of Kh.Dosmukhamedov Atyrau University
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
ASA. E. Sagymbayeva
A. E. Sagymbayeva
AZA. B. Zhamkeeva
A. B. Zhamkeeva
AZA. E. Zhaksylikov
A. E. Zhaksylikov
Maira KemelbekMaira Kemelbek
Maira Kemelbek
The article discusses the development of an assessment system designed to enhance students' programming skills within the programming course. The purpose of the study is to create a descriptor-based evaluation framework that enables fair and effective assessment of students’ cognitive, practical, and algorithmic competencies in programming.Based on a comprehensive analysis, the following key sections of the programming course were identified for objective assessment: variables and data types, conditional statements, loop structures, functions and parameters, error handling, and input/output operations. Evaluation criteria and a five-level descriptor system were developed, aligned with the cognitive levels of Bloom’s taxonomy.This approach provides a comprehensive assessment of not only theoretical knowledge but also students’ ability to make practical decisions, construct logical structures, and demonstrate algorithmic thinking. The descriptors are adaptable to different languages, ensuring consistency in assessment across various programming languages.The system assists instructors in organizing the evaluation process systematically and helps students clearly understand learning objectives, develop personalized learning paths, and prepare effectively for subsequent stages of their education.

1 March 2025 in Bulletin of Physics & Mathematical Sciences
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
АКА.а. Канатбекова
А.а. Канатбекова
Maira KemelbekMaira Kemelbek
Maira Kemelbek
МБМ.б. Береке
М.б. Береке
РШР.а. Шералиева
Р.а. Шералиева
СЕС.к. Есиркеп
С.к. Есиркеп
В последние годы технологии искусственного интеллекта (ИИ) стали неотъемлемой частью образовательного процесса, предоставляя студентам новые возможности для обучения и самореализации. Популярность ИИ-программ среди студентов объясняется их способностью упрощать доступ к учебным материалам, автоматизировать рутинные задачи и персонализировать процесс обучения. В данной статье представлен анализ наиболее востребованных ИИ-инструментов, таких как ChatGPT, Grammarly, Quizlet, Canva и Duolingo, которые активно используются студентами для написания эссе, подготовки к экзаменам, изучения иностранных языков и создания мультимедийного контента. Исследование выявляет, какие программы чаще всего выбираются студентами, их основные функции, преимущества и ограничения. Результаты работы позволяют понять, как ИИ-программы влияют на эффективность обучения, а также очертить перспективы их дальнейшего применения в образовательной среде.

7 October 2026 in Frontiers in Education
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
ZNZhanat Nurbekova
Zhanat Nurbekova
Maira KemelbekMaira Kemelbek
Maira Kemelbek
ASAinur Sagimbayeva
Ainur Sagimbayeva
AZAsset Zhaxylykov
Asset Zhaxylykov
AZAikenzhe Zhamkeeva
Aikenzhe Zhamkeeva
RARakhimzhan Abduvaliyev
Rakhimzhan Abduvaliyev
Introduction: The widespread adoption of generative AI tools has created new methodological challenges for the validity of assessment in higher education. If a neural network can write code, how can a student's actual knowledge be assessed objectively? This study proposes a multifactor AI-assisted assessment model for the fair evaluation of AI-supported learning practices in programming courses and examines its alignment with instructor assessment. Methods: The study involved 187 undergraduate students from three universities in Kazakhstan. In Phase 1, student submissions were evaluated using a traditional one-dimensional approach focused on functional correctness, and the results produced by instructors and by three large language models (GPT, Claude and Gemini) were compared. In Phase 2, a multifactor assessment model incorporating functional correctness, explanation quality and AI-use level was introduced, and the same submissions were re-evaluated with all three models. Results: The baseline analysis showed that AI-assisted assessment assigned systematically higher scores than instructors and demonstrated only moderate agreement with instructor evaluation. Under the multifactor model, agreement with instructor assessment improved significantly for one of the three models (Claude: r = 0.478 →0.647; ρ = 0.449 →0.690; MAE = 18.32 →7.34), while a second model (Gemini) showed a significant reduction in prediction error without a change in rank-order agreement, and a third (GPT) showed no significant change on any measure and reversed the direction of its systematic bias. Even in the best case, agreement remained moderate (approximately 42% of shared variance with instructor scores). Discussion: The findings indicate that the effectiveness of AI-assisted assessment depends on the structure of the assessment framework and on the underlying language model, and that a richer rubric does not benefit all models equally. By extending evaluation beyond code correctness toward explanation quality and transparent AI-supported problem solving, the proposed model offers a more balanced and pedagogically grounded approach to assessing undergraduate programming competencies.

13 October 2026 in Information
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
Maira KemelbekMaira Kemelbek
Maira Kemelbek
ZNZhanat Kunapianovna Nurbekova
Zhanat Kunapianovna Nurbekova
ASAinur Sagimbayeva
Ainur Sagimbayeva
Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly used in education, but evidence on their performance comes mainly from high-resource languages. We evaluated five commercial LLMs in Kazakh in a zero-shot setting: sentiment classification on 300 class-balanced KazSAnDRA reviews and question answering (QA) on the same 300 randomly sampled KazQAD questions with and without the gold supporting passage. Exact McNemar tests with Holm correction found no significant pairwise differences on sentiment classification, one with supporting context, and nine without context under the Containment criterion. For OpenAI and Anthropic, the higher-tier model had a larger advantage over its lower-tier counterpart when the supporting passage was removed (tier-by-regime interaction: OR = 1.92, 95% CI [1.52, 2.43]). Closed-book scores were affected by output format, inflectional morphology, and answer length. Human evaluation of 500 QA responses showed that string-based metrics substantially underestimated closed-book accuracy (0.55 by human judgement versus 0.26 by Containment). Under human judgement, the three higher-scoring models did not differ significantly from one another. Access to a relevant passage narrowed differences between models, although this oracle-context condition did not test a retrieval system. These findings support task-specific evaluation of Kazakh-language educational assistants and the use of answer-matching criteria checked against human judgement.