This study examines analyst forecast bias during the initial coverage of a firm using a sample of 631,660 firm-quarter analyst forecasts from 2007 to 2022. Estimating OLS regressions with firm, analyst, and time fixed effects, we find that analysts’ initial EPS forecasts are closer to the consensus than ongoing coverage forecasts. Our results suggest that ESG considerations influence analysts’ initial assessments of the firm. Higher ESG disclosure scores attenuate this tendency to issue consensus-aligned forecasts, particularly for analysts with a more favorable assessment of the firms than the consensus. We observe this effect when EPS forecast dispersion is high, indicating that ESG disclosures influence analysts’ initial assessments when uncertainty and disagreement among analysts are high. Our findings are robust to restricting the sample to small brokerage firms where analyst coverage assignments are more likely to be exogenous. We also find that analysts issue more optimistic price target estimates for firms with higher ESG disclosure scores.
26 June 2026 in Journal of Real Estate Practice and Education
We examine whether the sentiments that financial analysts express during the unscripted Q&A sessions of M&A conference calls convey information about deal quality that acquirer announcement returns only partially capture. Using large language models (LLMs), we score analyst sentiment along four dimensions (optimism, excitement, anxiety, and fear) for 2,604 U.S. acquisitions announced between 2003 and 2023. We report evidence that conference call returns rise with analyst optimism and fall with analyst anxiety and fear, with the market response to negative sentiment exceeding that to positive sentiment. Additional analysis shows that anxiety and fear predict deal failure, longer completion times, and long-run underperformance, particularly for deals where the market initially reacted favorably, and that the sentiment-return relation intensifies for informationally opaque deals. Collectively, our results show that investors recognize, yet underweight, analyst concerns. This aligns with the view that analysts' negative signals provide highly credible information about deal quality.