Gorney RM, June SG, Stainbrook KM, Smith AJ. 2023. Detections of cyanobacteria harmful algal blooms (cynanoHABs) in New York State, United States (2012–2020). Lake Reserv Manage. XX:XXX–XXX. Patterns in frequency, intensity, and duration of cyanobacteria harmful algal blooms (cyanoHABs) were evaluated in New York State from 2012 to 2020. The dataset included information from formal monitoring efforts, beach closures, and public reports. The total dataset included more than 24,000 records from 655 waterbodies and included cyanoHAB reports from 477 lakes. Nearly half of those lakes (49.6%) had only 1 year in which a cyanoHAB was documented. Less than 1% (6 lakes) had cyanoHABs documented in every year of the study. We noted a significant increase in the number of cyanoHABs reports each year (P < 0.001), but not an overall increase in intensity, based on evaluation of chlorophyll levels in mid-lake samples collected on a routine basis. The analysis indicated that cyanoHABs duration did not lengthen over the study period, based on beach closure data captured on a daily observation basis. This study addresses the limitations of monitoring data for analysis of patterns in cyanoHABs, based on the structure of the programs and frequency of observations. We provide retrospective feedback on the design of monitoring programs to improve future data collection and our ability to evaluate cyanoHABs in a wide range of waterbodies.
Cyanobacterial blooms are a concern in oligotrophic lakes because these systems are often used for multiple purposes (i.e., recreation and public water supplies). Monitoring cyanobacteria impacts is challenging in such cases because of low and heterogeneous concentrations over time, space, and depth. Canandaigua Lake (New York State) is oligotrophic, but has been impacted by blooms since at least the early 2000s, with limited quantification. This study integrated data from established shoreline surveillance and inter‐agency monitoring programs to connect lake processes and evaluate use impacts. Surveys at open‐water locations were conducted to investigate the origination, timing, and magnitude of cyanobacterial bloom development. Impacts on recreation and source water were caused by blooms originating in the epilimnion that moved to shorelines and intake depths. The integration of multiple monitoring programs was critical to understanding impacts. The methods developed here can be adopted to other cases of large, deep, low‐nutrient lakes.
30 December 2021 in Journal of Contemporary Water Research & Education
Lake Champlain is a treasured resource for recreation, tourism, and drinking water situated in New York, Vermont (U.S.), and Québec (Canada). Because its shores span two states and two countries, management strategies for the lake require strong cross‐boundary partnerships and cooperation. In recent decades, increased prevalence of harmful cyanobacteria blooms has impacted public health and recreation. A lake‐wide cyanobacteria monitoring program was established in 2001 with an emphasis on water sample collection and analysis to inform management strategies. In 2012, this program transitioned from laboratory‐based analyses at a limited number of locations to a visual assessment protocol validated by water samples. This transition opened the door to more effective and widespread monitoring, communication, and inclusion of a greater number of monitoring locations and stakeholders. Today, through a unique partnership of community scientist volunteers, public beach managers, nonprofit organizations, and state and federal agencies, a comprehensive network of trained cyanobacteria monitors generates timely data on water quality conditions to relay critical public health information. The majority of these reports are provided by trained community scientist volunteers, strengthening the geographic coverage of the program and the environmental literacy of lake users. This program now trains hundreds of community scientists, documents thousands of water quality condition reports annually, and communicates cyanobacteria conditions to the public via an online Cyanobacteria Tracker map. In this article, we describe the evolution of this successful program, discuss key findings from analysis of these volunteer‐collected data, and suggest how similar programs could be effectively developed in other regions.
The Lake in Central Park (LCP) and Prospect Park Lake (PPL) in New York City (NYC), USA, are lakes within two of the most visited parks in the USA. Five years of nearshore sampling of these systems revealed extremely elevated levels of cyanobacteria and the toxin, microcystin, with microcystin levels averaging 920 µg L−1 and chlorophyll a from cyanobacterial (cyano-chla) populations averaging 1.0 × 105 µg cyano-chla L−1. Both lakes displayed elevated levels of orthophosphate (DIP) relative to dissolved inorganic nitrogen (DIN) during summer months when DIN:DIP ratios were < 1. Nutrient addition and dilution experiments revealed that N consistently limited cyanobacterial populations but that green algae were rarely nutrient limited. Experimental additions of public drinking water that is rich in P and, to a lesser extent N, to lake water significantly enhanced cyanobacterial growth rates in experiments during which N additions also yielded growth enhancement. Collectively, this study demonstrates that the extreme microcystin levels during blooms in these highly trafficked lakes represent a potential human and animal health threat and that supplementation of these artificial lakes with public drinking water to maintain water levels during summer may promote the intensity and N limitation of blooms.
Prestigiacomo AR, June SG, Gorney RM, Smith AJ, Clinkhammer AC. 2022. An evaluation of a spectral fluorometer for monitoring chlorophyll a in New York State lakes. Lake Reserv Manage. XX:XXX–XXX. The quantification of chlorophyll a in surface waters through sampling and laboratory extraction methods has limitations, including the lack of phytoplankton composition analysis and delayed analysis time. Recently, automated instruments have been developed to quickly provide estimation of total chlorophyll a and characterize phytoplankton composition into functional groups. Here, we analyzed a dataset of paired, laboratory-extracted chlorophyll a samples (Chl-a) and chlorophyll a estimated from a spectrofluorometer (FluoroProbe, bbe Moldaenke; FPChl-a) for comparability at several time scales. We found that FPChl-a was highly correlated to Chl-a (r > 0.8) but overestimated Chl-a by 1.5–2 times on average. Summer average FPChl-a was higher than summer average Chl-a, resulting in incorrect lake evaluations against selected thresholds. Linear least squares regression of Chl-a/FPChl-a was highly significant (P < 0.01) and demonstrated a good fit (r2 > 0.75) but had high variability, consistent with FPChl-a performance values reported in the scientific literature. Factors such as FPChl-a magnitude and algal dominance were statistically important factors affecting the Chl-a/FPChl-a relationship. We developed a multiple linear regression method for postcalibrating FPChl-a to equivalent Chl-a values (adjusted FPChl-a) and applied it to the FPChl-a dataset. Adjusted FPChl-a values were unbiased and compared well with Chl-a (mean residual equal to 0 µg/L). Adjusted FPChl-a summer averages resulted in correct waterbody evaluation in more than 90% of lakes. We propose that the FluoroProbe, properly postcalibrated to adjusted FPChl-a, can be used as a surrogate of Chl-a in open water monitoring applications, reducing the need for traditional laboratory Chl-a samples for lake monitoring and management.