The development of wind turbine technology has led to higher and larger wind turbines with a higher sensitivity to dynamic effects. One of these effects is the aerodynamic damping, which introduces favorable damping forces in oscillating wind turbines. These forces play an important role in the turbine lifetime, but have not yet been studied systematically in detail. Consequently, this paper studies the plausibility of determining the aerodynamic damping of wind turbines systematically through wind tunnel experiments using the forced oscillation method. To this end, a 1:150 scale model of a prototype wind turbine has been fabricated considering Reynolds number effects on the blades through XFOIL calculations and wind tunnel measurements of airfoil 2D-section models. The resulting tower and wind turbine models have been tested for different operation states. The tower results are approximate and show low aerodynamic damping forces that can be neglected on the safe side. The measured aerodynamic damping forces of the operating turbine are compared to existing analytic approaches and to OpenFAST simulations. The measured values, although generally larger, show good agreement with the calculated ones. It is concluded that wind tunnel forced oscillations experiments could lead to a better characterization of the aerodynamic damping of wind turbines.
As wind turbines become larger and their towers more slender, aeroelastic effects play a bigger role in the wind turbine’s dynamic behavior. This study focuses on the along-wind aerodynamic damping of wind turbine towers, which has been determined by wind tunnel experiments using the forced oscillation method according to Steckley’s approach. Reynolds number scale effects have been considered through surface roughness modifications using sand paper and a dimple pattern, which have been described in detail. The wind tunnel measurements are performed in sub-critical, critical and trans-critical flow regimes, as well as in low- and high-turbulence conditions, which allows for an accurate description of the required relative roughness and Reynolds numbers for achieving trans-critical conditions. The resulting along-wind aerodynamic damping values according to Steckley’s and Holmes’ approaches are compared, and an analytical relation between them is established. Both approaches are then used in aeroelastic multi-body-simulations of an onshore 6 MW reference wind turbine and their impact on the wind turbine lifetime is evaluated through fatigue proofs at the tower base section. Holmes’ approach seems more appropriate for the application in aeroelastic multi-body simulations. A lifetime extension for the wind turbine tower of approximately 0.4% is achieved for the reference wind turbine tower, which roughly corresponds to 1 to 2 months for 20 years of operation. An analytical expression is given for the estimation of the tower’s aerodynamic damping in parked and operating conditions.
In order to improve the structural design of tubular and lattice towers for wind turbines, and in order to allow for detailed structural optimizations, a methodology is desirable which allows for quick and reliable considerations of the complex dynamic load situations. Whereat for the design of details for the machinery and the blade optimization time domain methods using multi-body-simulations are well established, their usage is often to extensive due to the needed level of detail to use them for an iterative tower design. Especially with regard to lattice towers, it is therefore desirable to investigate faster stochastic methods which focus on the overall dynamic behavior based on the probability of structural stresses within the tower construction. Lattice structures are difficult to optimize with respect to their shape and topology by manual methods. Therefore, the lattice has been formulated parametrically in order to allow for an automatic update of the geometrical appearance. Both, the positioning of nodes, bracings, trusses and the overall detailing of the lattice are part of the object oriented algorithm. Using both tools, an automatic structural optimization of the geometry of a lattice structure for an onshore wind turbine has been performed. The gained results of the optimized lattice tower are finally compared to a conventional tubular tower.
For the construction of wind towers with large hub heights up to 200m, the FOSTA research project P1392 HYTOWER [1] investigated a concept for a self-erecting wind energy plant with steel-steel hybrid tower. A tubular steel tower is lifted inside a lattice tower using a strand lifting system. During this process the tubular steel tower is stabilized by hydraulic cylinders. A specially developed transition piece is used to accommodate the lifting system during the lifting process and to finally connect the two tower parts. In this paper, the erection process as well as the development of the transition piece is presented.