This paper presents a systematic review of empirical research from 2020 to 2024 related to self-efficacy to illustrate the various roles of self-efficacy as an independent, mediating, and dependent variable in various aspects of university learning and teaching. Seventy-five peer-reviewed studies were selected following the PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) guideline and analysed through a combined narrative and thematic approach. The final findings reveal that various forms of self-efficacy, namely, academic, digital, research, and entrepreneurial, could consistently predict positive academic achievement, engagement, and self-regulation. Self-efficacy is a significant mediator between instructional design, pedagogical support, learning environments, individual motivation, and performance, although these connections have not been thoroughly explored. The improvement of self-efficacy is influenced by educational, technological, and social factors in the digital and post-pandemic environment. In theory, these findings suggest that self-efficacy should be embedded in larger motivational and situational frameworks. In practice, the importance of gaining experience, formative feedback, digital abilities, and supportive institutional atmospheres is emphasised. However, current literature is limited by cross-sectional methods, conceptual ambiguity between specific domain structures, and limited cross-cultural perspectives. Addressing these methodological, conceptual, and contextual gaps will provide a more comprehensive and integrated explanation for the development of self-efficacy and its interaction as a predictor, mediator, and outcome in higher education systems.