Fiber reinforced polymer (FRP) composite materials have been used in a variety of civil and infrastructure applications since the early1980s, including in wind turbine blades. The world is now confronting the problem of how to dispose of decommissioned blades in an environmentally sustainable manner. One proposed solution is to repurpose the blades for use in new structures. One promising repurposing application is in pedestrian and cycle bridges. This paper reports on the characterization of a 13.4-m long FRP wind blade manufactured by LM Windpower (Kolding, Demark) in 1994. Two blades of this type were used as girders for a pedestrian bridge on a greenway (walking and biking trail) in Cork, Ireland. The as-received geometric, material, and structural properties of the 27 year-old blade were obtained for use in the structural design of the bridge. The material tests included physical (volume fraction and laminate architecture) and mechanical (tension and compression) tests at multiple locations. Full-scale flexural testing of a 4-m long section of the blade between 7 and 11 m from the root of the blade was performed to determine the load-deflection behavior, ultimate capacity, strain history, and failure modes when loaded to failure. Key details of the testing and the results are provided. The results of the testing revealed that the FRP material is still in excellent condition and that the blade has the strength and stiffness in flexure to serve as a girder for the bridge constructed.
1 August 2021 in Journal of Composites for Construction
This paper focuses on the conceptual use of a fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) wind turbine blade that is repurposed for a second life as an electrical transmission pole. Thousands of tons of fiber-reinforced polymer composite wind turbine blades are currently coming out of service globally and are being landfilled or incinerated. These are not environmentally preferable disposal methods. This paper presents a detailed structural analysis of a Clipper C96, 46.7-m-long turbine blade used as an electrical pole. The analytical procedure needed to characterize the wind turbine blade for repurposing includes determining the external and internal geometry of the blade, identifying the types of materials and laminates used throughout the blade, and calculating effective moduli and section properties for structural analysis. Code-specified load combinations are then used to analyze the transmission line BladePole to determine internal forces and deformations and stresses. Maximum stresses were compared to those obtained from theoretical models. The results indicate that wind turbine blades can safely be used as electrical transmission poles.
This paper demonstrates the concept of adaptive repurposing of a portion of a decommissioned Clipper C96 wind turbine blade as a pole in a power transmission line application. The current research program is aimed at creating a path towards sustainable repurposing of wind turbine blades after they are removed from service. The present work includes modelling and analysis of expected load cases as prescribed in ASCE 74 and NESC using simplified boundary conditions for tangent pole applications. Load cases involving extreme wind, concurrent ice and wind, extreme ice, differential ice, broken conductor, and broken shield have been analyzed and governing load cases for bending, shear, and torsion have been examined. Relative stiffnesses of different parts forming the wind blade’s cross section (i.e., shell, web, and spar cap) are determined. The corresponding stresses associated with each part under the governing loads are compared to allowable strength values which are determined from composite laminate theory and modelling of the known laminate structure of the E-Glass FRP material. Stresses and deflections obtained are compared with governing reliability-based design criteria and code requirements. The results of the structural analysis indicate that the wind blade can resist the expected loads with reasonable safety factors and that the expected deflections are within permissible limits. Recommendations are provided for detailing and modification of the wind blade for a power pole application in which crossarm and davit connections are highlighted, and foundation details are emphasized.
1 October 2022 in Journal of Materials in Civil Engineering
E-glass fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) composite wind turbine blades are nonbiodegradable, and their end-of-life recycling solutions are limited. Research on reusing and repurposing applications, where minimal amounts of refabrication are needed, is being conducted to address this issue. To design new structures from decommissioned blades, their as-received mechanical and physical properties are needed. Even though some long-term property data for FRP composites exist in the literature, very little actual data for the as-received residual properties of decommissioned blades have been reported. The current work is aimed at developing a methodology to obtain as-received material property data for decommissioned wind turbine blades that are being proposed for use as second-life structural components. In this paper, details of the methods used and the test results for the key physical and mechanical properties of glass FRP material specimens extracted from the spar cap of a decommissioned 1.5-MW GE37 wind turbine blade are reported (the blade is from a General Electric 1.5 MW turbine which is known as a GE37 blade), including burnout testing for constituents’ weight and volume fractions as well as fiber architecture and tension, compression, and shear testing in the longitudinal and transverse material directions. Comparisons between test results of other investigators and the experimental data obtained show promising strength and stiffness retention levels of the material for different properties. The results show that structural integrity still exists for the tested composite materials and no deterioration, crack propagation, or delamination was observed in the materials due to the cyclic loading levels experienced in their first life.
The production of wind energy worldwide has increased 20-fold since 2001. Composite material wind turbine blades, typically designed for a 20-year fatigue life, are beginning to come out of service in large numbers. In general, these decommission blades, composed primarily of glass fibers in a thermoset matrix, are demolished and landfilled. There is little motivation for recycling the composite materials, as the processes for reclaiming the fibers (solvolysis, pyrolysis) have not been proven to be economically viable. This research seeks to establish structural reuse applications for wind turbine blades in civil engineering infrastructure, hypothesizing that advanced composite materials may be an attractive alternative to conventional infrastructure materials (e.g. steel, reinforced concrete). This paper presents an analysis and materials characterization of a 47 meter Clipper C96 wind blade. The primarily numerical analysis is accompanied by materials characterization taken from an un-used Clipper blade donated to the project from the Wind Turbine Testing Center (WTTC). The paper presents a brief background on wind turbine blade adaptive re-use, proposing a hypothetical load bearing application of the Clipper wind blade as an electrical transmission tower structure carrying axial compression, along with flapwise and edgewise bending forces. The paper summarizes the composite laminates and cross-section geometries of the blade and establishes the axial and flexural stiffnesses of the blade at multiple sections along the blade length. From a first-order estimation of applied loads for the tower application, the resulting stresses in the composite materials are estimated and compared to the design material properties for the wind blade as originally constructed.