The use of fuzzy logic to assess students’ knowledge is not a completely new concept. However, despite dealing with a large quantity of data, traditional statistical methods have typically been the preferred approach. Many studies have argued that machine learning methods could offer a viable alternative for analyzing big data. Therefore, this study presents findings from a Random Forest (RF) regression analysis to understand the influence of demographic factors on students’ achievements, i.e., teacher-given grades, students’ outcomes on the national assessment, and fuzzy grades, which were obtained as a combination of the two. RF analysis showed that demographic factors have limited predictive power for teacher-assigned grades, unlike INVALSI scores and fuzzy grades. School type, macroregion, and ESCS are influential predictors, whereas gender and origin have a lesser impact. The study highlights regional and socio-economic disparities, influencing both student outcomes and fuzzy grades, underscoring the need for equitable education. Unexpectedly, gender’s impact on achievements is minor, possibly due to gender-focused policies. Although the study acknowledges limitations, its integration of fuzzy logic and machine learning sets the foundation for future research and policy recommendations, advocating for diversified assessment approaches and data-driven policymaking.
1 July 2024 in International Electronic Journal of Mathematics Education
The evolution of mathematics coincided with advancements in its teaching. The 19th and 20th centuries marked a pedagogical revolution in mathematics education. This paper argues that Bruner’s (1966) model, Gagné’s (1985) taxonomy, innovative teaching methods emphasizing research and problem-solving, and the inclusion of data analysis topics have shaped modern mathematics education. Additionally, the paper explores transformative trends, emphasizing mathematics literacy and the integration of virtual reality (VR) and artificial intelligence (AI) in education. This evolution emphasizes practical, contextually relevant approaches. VR enhances engagement and comprehension of abstract concepts, while AI offers personalized learning experiences, fostering deeper understanding and skill development.
Assessing student mathematical knowledge is an important factor in the mathematics learning process because students obtain important feedback to improve their knowledge and learning. Despite the importance of student assessment, several researchers have shown that student grades comprise noncognitive and metacognitive factors and teachers’ prejudices and beliefs. One method to obtain a more objective view of student mathematical knowledge is through standardized assessments. In this paper, we analyze two methods of assessing student mathematical knowledge by considering their written and oral grades and achievements on the Italian National Assessment of Knowledge (INVALSI). The final grade was produced using the fuzzy logic inference system. It was tested on a sample of 2279 Grade 13 Italian high school students, who had both an oral and written grade in mathematics and who took the INVALSI assessment in the school year 2020–2021. Both tested fuzzy-logic-based assessment methods lowered the mean grades.
Inquiry-based learning (IBL) in mathematics is a student-centered approach that encourages exploration, problem-solving, and critical thinking, allowing students to actively engage with mathematical concepts and discover relationships through hands-on activities and collaborative learning. Despite the growing interest in IBL within mathematics education, which has demonstrated the effectiveness of this method on students’ achievements, less is known about its impact on Gagné’s taxonomy of knowledge (conceptual, procedural, and problem-solving knowledge). This study, based on Bruner’s instructional model, compares the effectiveness of IBL against traditional teaching methods in promoting mathematical learning across Gagné’s three taxonomies of knowledge in Grade 9 algebra content, using a sample of 258 Slovenian students (132 in the experimental group). Results show that the experimental group outperformed the control group in most areas, with no significant difference observed in procedural knowledge. The study suggests that IBL enhances students’ conceptual understanding and problem-solving abilities by fostering deeper engagement and critical thinking but may not have the same impact on procedural fluency, which requires repetitive practice.
Although the idea of evaluating students’ mathematical knowledge with fuzzy logic is not new in the literature, few studies have explored the possibility of assessing students’ mathematical knowledge by combining teacher-assigned grades (i.e., school grades) with students’ achievements on standardized tests (e.g., national assessments). Thus, the present study aims to investigate the use of fuzzy logic to generate a novel assessment model, which combines teacher-assigned mathematics grades with students’ results on the Italian National Assessment of Mathematical Knowledge (INVALSI). We expanded the findings from previous works by considering a larger sample, which included more than 90,000 students attending grades 8, 10, and 13. The results showed that the tested model led to a lower assessment score compared to the traditional grading method based on teacher’s evaluation. Additionally, the use of fuzzy logic across the examined school levels yielded similar results, suggesting that the model is adequate among different educational levels.