Forum papers are thought-provoking opinion pieces or essays founded in fact, sometimes containing speculation, on a civil engineering topic of general interest and relevance to the readership of the journal. The views expressed in this Forum article do not necessarily reflect the views of ASCE or the Editorial Board of the journal.
District energy systems supplied by geothermal heat pumps (GHPs) have been deployed across the United States for both heating and cooling end uses. To better understand their performance and potential, the geothermal research team at the National Renewable Energy Laboratory analyzed cost and performance of five existing GHP-based district energy systems in the United States. The five systems selected are Ball State University in Indiana, Colorado Mesa University in Colorado, Miami University in Ohio, West Union in Iowa, and Whisper Valley in Texas. The necessary information, including district size, operation period, GHP performance, and costs, was collected through literature review and interviews. The survey results indicated the five systems studied consist of geothermal borehole field(s) and ground loop(s) connected to central loop. While the GHPs were in central plants at Ball State University and Miami University, the central loops at Colorado Mesa University, West Wood, and Whisper Valley were connected through service lines to individual heat pumps in each building. Our analysis indicates the systems have been operating reliably and cost-effectively and contributed to a reduction in carbon emissions.
Thermal resistivity dry-out curves (TRDCs) are measured for three sandy soils representing a range of grain characteristics and size distribution. Experiments were conducted using an instrumented hanging column apparatus instrumented for automated measurement of specimen thermal resistivity, matric suction, and degree of saturation along an initial drainage path, thereby allowing both the TRDC and soil-water characteristic curve (SWCC) to be obtained concurrently. SWCC and TRDC measurements are compared with independent measurements obtained using a conventional hanging column method and a multiple-specimen method, respectively. Fine-grained sand is shown to have higher thermal resistivity than coarse-grained sand over the complete range of saturation. Results provide information that may be used to estimate thermal properties of unsaturated coarse-grained porous media in applications such as the design of buried high-voltage power cables or near-surface geothermal heat exchange loops.
In this study, soil critical temperature was measured using two distinct approaches: (1) a temperature profile established from a heating element located at the top of a vertical column and (2) temperature and moisture profiles induced from a centrally placed heating source in a ‘horizontal’ apparatus. Steady-state thermal and moisture equilibrium took longer to establish in the horizontal apparatus (on average, nine hours longer); however, the resulting temperature and moisture profiles were more consistent in the horizontal apparatus and with easily discerned slope discontinuities between the dry and moist zones. More ambiguous temperature profiles were observed in the vertical apparatus, even with insulation and heat tape applied to minimize horizontal boundary losses. This is indicative of the difficulty in maintaining one-dimensional heat flow in a vertical column. As soil critical temperature is an important parameter used in designing underground infrastructure impacted by significant heat transfer, such as buried power cables, refinement and standardization of equipment and protocol for determining this parameter in a precise and mechanistically sound manner is of prime concern.