An understanding of the migratory connectivity between breeding and nonbreeding areas is fundamental to the management of long-distance migrants under pressure from habitat change along their flyways. Here we describe evidence for genetic structure within the nonbreeding range of the endangered Arctic-Canadian rufa subspecies of Red Knots (Calidris canutus). Using blood and tissue samples from the major nonbreeding regions in Argentina (Tierra del Fuego and Río Negro), northern Brazil (Maranhão), and southeastern USA (Florida), we estimated genetic structure in 514 amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP) loci, applying cluster assignment analyses in DAPC, assignPOP, and STRUCTURE. Using a priori location information, individuals could be correctly re-assigned to their nonbreeding regions, which validated that the assignment accuracy of the data was sufficient. Without using a priori location information, we detected 3–5 genotype clusters, and posterior assignment probabilities of samples to these genotype clusters varied among the three regions. Lastly a chi-square test confirmed that allele frequencies varied significantly among nonbreeding regions, rejecting the hypothesis that samples were drawn from a single gene pool. Our findings hint at undescribed structure within the Red Knot rufa breeding range in the Canadian Arctic and indicate that each rufa nonbreeding area in this study hosts a different subsample of these breeding populations. The observation that nonbreeding sites of rufa Red Knots contain different genetic pools argues for separate conservation management of these sites. • Red Knots of the rufa subspecies are famous for their cross-continental migrations, connecting people and cultures in South and North America, where they act as ambassadors for coastal habitat protection. • Through ongoing habitat loss and degradation along their flyway, rufa Red Knots are currently listed as “Threatened” or “Endangered” in the USA, Argentina and other countries in the flyway. • The internationally collaborative efforts for the protection of this species depend on recurrent updates of the population status, but also on our understanding of how Red Knots from Arctic Canada distribute themselves over their distant nonbreeding areas. • Therefore, we set out to test whether rufa Red Knots spending the boreal winter in Argentina (Tierra del Fuego and Río Negro), northern Brazil (Maranhão) and southeastern USA (Florida) can be considered to come from one interbreeding population, by genotyping 150 Red Knot samples with population genetic markers. • We detected genetic differences that warrant the recognition of three nonbreeding regions in Argentina, northern Brazil and southeastern USA (each hosting 3,600–13,000 Red Knots) as distinct units, even though the breeding origin of the birds remain unknown. • The unique assortments of genotypes suggest that these regions receive birds from different areas within the Arctic, and therefore a detailed study of interbreeding across the breeding range is justified, once more samples become available.