Large‐scale ecological sampling networks, such as national forest inventories (NFIs), collect in situ data to support biodiversity monitoring, forest management and planning, and greenhouse gas reporting. Data harmonization aims to link auxiliary remotely sensed data to field‐collected data to expand beyond field sampling plots, but outliers that arise in data harmonization—questionable observations because their values differ substantially from the rest—are rarely addressed. In this paper, we review the sources of commonly occurring outliers, including random chance (statistical outliers), definitions and protocols set by sampling networks, and temporal and spatial mismatch between field‐collected and remotely sensed data. We illustrate different types of outliers and the effects they have on estimates of above‐ground biomass population parameters using a case study of 292 NFI plots paired with airborne laser scanning (ALS) and Sentinel‐2 data from Sawyer County, Wisconsin, United States. Depending on the criteria used to identify outliers (sampling year, plot location error, nonresponse, presence of zeros and model residuals), as many as 53 of the 292 Forest Inventory and Analysis plot observations (18%) were identified as potential outliers using a single criterion and 111 plot observations (38%) if all criteria were used. Inclusion or removal of potential outliers led to substantial differences in estimates of mean and standard error of the estimate of biomass per unit area. The simple expansion estimator, which does not rely on ALS or other auxiliary data, was more sensitive to outliers than model‐assisted approaches that incorporated ALS and Sentinel‐2 data. Including Sentinel‐2 predictors showed minimal increases to the precision of our estimates relative to models with ALS predictors alone. Outliers arise from many causes and can be pervasive in data harmonization workflows. Our review and case study serve as a note of caution to researchers and practitioners that the inclusion or removal of potential outliers can have unintended consequences on population parameter estimates. When used to inform large‐scale biomass mapping, carbon markets, greenhouse gas reporting and environmental policy, it is necessary to ensure the proper use of NFI and remotely sensed data in geospatial data harmonization.
Extended growing season lengths under climatic warming suggest increased time for plant growth. However, research has focused on climatic impacts to the timing or duration of distinct phenological events. Comparatively little is known about impacts to the relative time allocation to distinct phenological events, for example, the proportion of time dedicated to leaf growth versus senescence. We use multiple satellite and ground-based observations to show that, despite recent climate change during 2001 to 2020, the ratio of time allocated to vegetation green-up over senescence has remained stable [1.27 (± 0.92)] across more than 83% of northern ecosystems. This stability is independent of changes in growing season lengths and is caused by widespread positive relationships among vegetation phenological events; longer vegetation green-up results in longer vegetation senescence. These empirical observations were also partly reproduced by 13 dynamic global vegetation models. Our work demonstrates an intrinsic biotic control to vegetation phenology that could explain the timing of vegetation senescence under climate change.
In a changing climate, the future survival and productivity of species rely on individual populations to respond to shifting environmental conditions. Many tree species, including northern red oak (Quercus rubra), exhibit phenotypic plasticity, the ability to respond to changes in environmental conditions at within‐generation time scales, through varying traits such as leaf phenology. Phenotypic plasticity of phenology may vary among populations within a species' range, and it is unclear if the range of plasticity is adequate to promote fitness. Here, we used a 58‐year‐old common garden to test whether northern red oak populations differed in phenological sensitivity to changes in temperature and whether differences in phenological sensitivity were associated with differences in productivity and survival (proxies of fitness). We recorded 8 years of spring leaf emergence and autumn leaf coloration and loss in 28 distinct populations from across the species' full range. Across the 28 populations, spring leaf out consistently advanced in warmer years, but fall phenology was less responsive to changes in temperature. Southern, warm‐adapted populations had larger shifts in phenology in response to springtime warming but had lower long‐term survival. Moreover, higher phenological sensitivity to spring warming was not strongly linked to increased productivity. Instead, fitness was more closely linked to latitudinal gradients. Although springtime phenological sensitivity to climate change is common across northern red oak populations, responses of productivity and survival, which could determine longer‐term trajectories of species abundance, are more variable across the species' range.
Ecologists—especially those new to the field—are tasked with finding relevant literature matching their research interests and deciding upon a suitable venue for the publication of their work. To provide a roadmap for early career researchers to identify journals aligned with their interests, we analyzed major research themes found across the top 30 ecology journals and three high‐impact multi‐disciplinary journals (Nature, PNAS, and Science), utilizing an automated content analysis (ACA) of 84,841 article abstracts, titles, and author keywords published over the last four decades. Journals clustered into 10 distinct groups based on 46 research themes identified by ACA. We examined the frequency of ecological themes in each of these journal groups to identify the journals most associated with each theme. We found three themes (anthropogenic impacts, disease, and traits) that occurred at a high frequency in the high‐impact multi‐disciplinary journal group containing Nature, PNAS, and Science. Themes that increased in frequency over the last four decades, such as climate change, traits, anthropogenic, and cellular biology, were found more often in journals with higher impact factors, indicating that emerging research themes in ecology will likely become of interest to a broader readership over time. Our study provides a thematic review as a potential roadmap for junior ecologists to browse and publish journal articles.