6 February 2019 in Enterprise Information Systems
Maturity models (MM) have been used by different enterprise segments. However, while many MM have been developed, few have been validated because of the lack of studies that demonstrate how to classify model levels. This study investigates the literature that presents assessment models for classifying maturity levels as well as the development of the research area. A systematic literature review was carried out, finding 409 relevant papers and a list of the few methods for classifying the maturity level. This review enabled us to update the state of the art on MM and identify gaps that may prompt future research.
1 January 2022 in International Journal of Decision Support System Technology
KRKassia Tonheiro Rodrigues
Kassia Tonheiro Rodrigues
Organizational climate impacts on the employee’s well-being, commitment and positive behavior. Most studies to assess climate in healthcare organizations use qualitative and/or statistical methods. Here, we propose a general framework, based on a multiple criteria decision making/aid (MCDM / A) method, which considers different objectives in a single problem. Such framework includes internal and external factors to assess organizational climate and presented adequate results when tested in a particular case. To assess the organizational climate, we use the ELECTRE TRI method, an outranking method that combine the decision-maker (DM) preferences and his value judgments. We conclude that MCDM methods can improve agility, provide a systemic vision on organizational climate assessment and contribute to the decision-making process
1 January 2021 in International Journal of Decision Support System Technology
NLNaylil Liria Baldin de Lacerda
Naylil Liria Baldin de Lacerda
Considering the increasing scenario of natural gas consumption, it is necessary that all agents in the chain use methods that structure decision-making and problem-solving processes. This paper proposes a multicriteria decision model to solve a site selection problem for a pressure reducing station. A natural gas distribution company was selected to test the model and the preference modeling was conducted through the flexible interactive tradeoff (FITradeoff) approach, according to the preferences of the decision maker (DM). FITradeoff's decision support system was used to assess the alternatives of the model, through the inference of the criteria scale constants. The results proved the robustness of the model and the DM evidenced consistency in its preferences. Also, the FITradeoff method demonstrated to be intuitive to apply, since a smaller effort is required from the DM and this is because the procedure does not require complete information in the scale constants elicitation process.
1 January 2023 in International Journal of Decision Support System Technology
ACAna Paula Cabral Seixas Costa
Ana Paula Cabral Seixas Costa
This paper proposes a decision model for a maturity model choice problem via the multiple-criteria decision analysis method. The authors implemented the model in FITradeoff decision support system to select a project management maturity model for a Brazilian industry operating in the sector of distributing natural gas. FITradeoff is a flexible and interactive procedure of elicitation for multi-criteria additive models that requires only partial information from the decision maker (i.e., there is no need to elicit very detailed information from the decision maker, an approach that the decision maker can find laborious and tiring). The authors observed that the use of a multi-criteria approach imposes certain rigor and pattern on the decision process to select a maturity model in project management. Applying the model enabled comparison of information from the four maturity models and therefore selecting a project management maturity model based on the decision-maker preferences.
1 January 2023 in Pesquisa Operacional
This article aims to present a Multicriteria Decision Aiding (MCDA) model for assessing risk management maturity. Therefore, it is proposed to use a Maturity Model (MM) for risk management aligned with the ELECTRE TRI method. The ELECTRE TRI was chosen as the sorting method because it has a strong axiomatic structure based on the relationship of concordance and discordance between the alternative and the profile that delimits each of its classes. To test the proposal, a case study was carried out on a real company in the construction industry. For the development of the risk management maturity assessment model, a questionnaire was applied to collect data related to risk management practices in the organization. After collection, the data were used for modeling in a Decision Support System to apply the ELECTRE TRI, which managed to classify and identify the organization’s risk management maturity at level 3 (managed).
1 July 2025 in Discover Applied Sciences
In the current era of energy transition, the emergence of new technologies and increasing energy demand have led to significant changes in the energy sector. In this context, natural gas plays a key role in reducing greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions and planning its distribution is essential to achieve efficient results. To address this need, this paper presents a novel approach integrating the geographic information system (GIS) and multicriteria decision-making/aiding (MCDM/A) to develop a decision support system (DSS) for natural gas distribution planning. The study outlines possible projects for extending natural gas distribution networks using a multicriteria model with a benefit-to-cost ratio-based (BCR-based) technique for portfolio selection. The model considers multiple criteria including payback, internal rate of return, demand for natural gas, risk, and cost considerations, to evaluate different investment decisions and identify the optimal solution. In the MCDM/A preference modeling process, the proposed model considers a partial information approach based on the ROC (Rank Order Centroid) surrogate weighting technique, using the swing elicitation procedure to obtain to ranking of criteria weights, which makes the elicitation process less cognitively demanding for decision-makers. The model also considers a decision rule that meets the conditions of the business model of developing natural gas distribution networks. This paper presents an actual portfolio selection case study faced by a Brazilian natural gas distribution company, demonstrating the applicability of the system with the aim of improving and supporting strategic decisions. Results have shown an optimal portfolio of projects obtained consuming 97.38% of the budget while ensuring spatial connectivity and operational feasibility. The robustness of the results was also evaluated within the developed DSS through a sensitivity analysis, corroborating the model's reliability under varying input conditions. This work goes a step further in the field of portfolio selection both from (i) a theoretical perspective, with the development of a new ROC-SWING BCR-based modeling approach for portfolio problems; and (ii) a practical perspective, by addressing a challenging real-world decision-making problem in the field of energy management.